Jules Massenet's 'Manon'

From the Vienna State Opera

Who's Who?

Anna Netrebko ..... Manon

Roberto Alagna .... Des Grieux

Ain Anger ... Count Des Grieux

Adrian Erod ..... Lescaut

Michael Roider ..... Guillot

In-Sung Sim ..... Bretigny

Simina Ivan .... Poussette

Sophie Marilley ... Javotte

Juilette Mars ...... Rosette

Bertrand de Billy ... conductor

Vienna State Opera Orchestra

More about the performers ...

The Hit Single

Manon is full of hit tunes, and this "Gavotte" from Act II may be the flashiest. As she sings it Manon is the toast of Paris, and resolves to use youth and beauty to her best advantage.

Generally, opera is considered a serious art form. By contrast, composer Jules Massenet has been described as a lightweight — and at times, it's easy to hear why. Even his wildly popular Manon, an opera with a deadly serious story, has plenty of froth.

Roberto Alagna and Anna Netrebko i i

Soprano Anna Netrebko, as Massenet's Manon, meets tenor Roberto Alagna as Des Grieux, in the Vienna State Opera's production. Photo: Axel Zeininger/Wiener Staatsoper GmbH hide caption

itoggle caption Photo: Axel Zeininger/Wiener Staatsoper GmbH
Roberto Alagna and Anna Netrebko

Soprano Anna Netrebko, as Massenet's Manon, meets tenor Roberto Alagna as Des Grieux, in the Vienna State Opera's production.

Photo: Axel Zeininger/Wiener Staatsoper GmbH

But we don't need to concentrate on the supposedly lofty world of opera to find astonishingly successful composers with lightweight reputations. For another, we can look closer to home, at a legendary figure of American musical theater.

Cole Porter was a true Broadway genius, a brilliant lyricist and a first-rate composer — the creator of dozens of hit songs and shows. Was Porter a "lightweight?" Well, plenty of his songs sound that way. His lively tune "Friendship" comes from the show Dubarry Was a Lady. Like much of Porter's work, it hardly calls high drama to mind. Still, whatever his reputation, Porter did have a serious side. His classic "Love for Sale" conjures up the gritty, work-a-day side of prostitution. The subject matter, and its sophisticated, even disturbing tone, are hardly the work of a lightweight songwriter.

Getting back to Massenet, the two-sided nature we hear in Cole Porter's familiar songs and shows can also be found in Manon — an opera that touches on the same dramatic territory as Porter's "Love for Sale." The title character starts out as an innocent 15-year-old — a kid whose "inclinations" have prompted her parents to ship her off to a convent.

At first that seems unjust, but by the time the opera is over, we might wonder. When it comes to true love, Manon is lucky right from the start. During her journey, she falls for a well-meaning young man of modest means, who adores her. Before long, though, it's clear that Manon has a taste for opulence as well as true love — and she's not above cavorting with rich men she doesn't love in exchange for a luxurious lifestyle. Despite the frothy spots, Massenet's opera doesn't pull any punches, and he gave it all the complex, emotionally powerful music it needs to drive home some unsavory realities.

On this edition of World of Opera, we'll hear Manon in a genuinely star-studded production from the Vienna State Opera. The stunning young soprano Anna Netrebko sings the title role, with acclaimed tenor Roberto Alagna as Des Grieux, her unfortunate, love-struck suitor.

The Story of Massenet's 'Manon'

Soprano Anna Netrebko

Anna Netrebko sings the title role in Manon, playing a young woman who must choose between true love and a luxurious lifestyle. Photo: Axel Zeininger/Wiener Staatsoper GmbH hide caption

itoggle caption Photo: Axel Zeininger/Wiener Staatsoper GmbH
Jules Massenet

For more than 40 years Jules Massenet wrote a wide range of compelling operas for the French stage. Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Getty Images

BACKGROUND: At times, in operatic circles, it's been fashionable to put down Jules Massenet. His popularity as a composer swayed up and down even in his own lifetime (1842-1912). His early successes included a number of hits at the Opera-Comique in Paris. But near the end of his career, Massenet's neatly packaged, dramatically precise operas must have seemed old-fashioned compared with the raucous new sounds found in Salome and Elektra by the young gun Richard Strauss.

Of Massenet's 30 or so surviving operas, two have remained constants on stages the world over. Both Manon and Werther show off Massenet's instinctual writing for the voice, his grasp of orchestral color, and his keen sense for building taught dramatic scenes.

Massenet wasn't the first to make an opera from the story of Manon, and he wasn't the last. In 1893, ten years after Massenet's Manon premiered, Puccini composed his own version, called Manon Lescaut.

The story, originally part of a long novel by the Abbe Prevost, concerns a young woman torn between true love and the lure of luxury.

She's opera's true "Material Girl," who, as in Madonna's pop song, likes her men laden with riches, "because the boy with the cold hard cash is always Mr. Right." Except for Manon, it's not quite that simple.

ACT ONE: In a bustling French courtyard filled with food, drink, gamblers and a few finely dressed prostitutes, Lescaut waits for the arrival of the next stagecoach. His cousin Manon is paying a visit while on her way to a new life at the convent.

This is Manon's first time away from home, and she's clearly excited by all the hubbub as she walks through the crowd with Lescaut. Almost immediately Manon is propositioned by a financier named Guillot, who tells her that any time she's ready, his coach will be waiting. Lescaut warns about becoming too friendly with strange men, but the advice is ignored as Manon meets Des Grieux, who has just missed his coach on his way to visit his father. It's love-at-first-sight, and with little convincing Manon agrees to leave with Des Grieux. Guillot has said that his coach was at her disposal, so they hop in and head for Paris.

ACT TWO: Manon and Des Grieux have moved into a small Paris apartment. Des Grieux writes a letter to his father, trying to explain his new live-in girlfriend, whom he says he will marry soon. Manon is touched by the letter — but not so sure she wants to get married. A knock at the door reveals Lescaut and a wealthy tax collector named Bretigny, disguised as a guard. Lescaut has come to reclaim his cousin. Bretigny has ideas of his own. While Des Grieux shows Lescaut his letter, proving his good intentions, Bretigny whispers to Manon. De Grieux's father has arranged his son's kidnapping for later that day. If she keeps quiet, and doesn't interfere with the abduction, she can live with Bretigny and bask in his wealth.

Lescaut and Bretigny leave, the maid announces supper, and Des Grieux runs out to post his letter. Manon is conflicted. She loves Des Grieux, but feels she may not be worthy of him. After he returns, there's a knock at the door. Manon tells him not to answer, but he does. There's a struggle, and Des Grieux is taken away.

ACT THREE: Massenet contrasts the pathos of the last scene by opening Act Three in high spirits. A crowd is gathered at the Cours-la-Reine, a promenade alonside the Seine, where Manon is happy to be on the arm of Bretigny. Everyone is there: Lescaut eyes the girls, Guillot hovers, and even Poussette, Javotte and Rosette (the "special" ladies) are seen running out from a nearby dancehall. Manon's happiness turns into the "Gavotte," a sparkling aria extolling her carefree life of luxury, and one of the best known "hits" of the opera.

Afterward, Manon overhears Des Grieux's father in conversation with Bretigny. After losing Manon, Des Grieux is about to take holy orders and is preaching tonight at St. Sulpice. Massenet breaks the somber mood again by introducing a lively ballet, which Guillot has arranged especially to impress Manon. But Manon can think only of Des Grieux. In the midst of the dancing she leaves for the church, again disappointing Guillot.

Mixing sensuality and piety was one of Massenet's specialties, and the next scene, in which the two former lovers meet at the church, is especially moving and passionate. Des Grieux, alone, pledges himself to God. It's the only way to relieve the pain of losing Manon. As the organ plays the Magnificat, Manon hopes she can persuade Des Grieux to change his mind. When he sees her, he denounces her for infidelity and asks her to leave. But Manon reminds him of their happier days, and at her physical touch Des Grieux caves in; the two run off together once again.

ACT FOUR: At an illegal hotel casino, the familiar crew of characters is in full party mode: Lescaut, Guillot, Poussette, Javotte and Rosette, plus a crowd of others. Manon and Des Grieux have fallen on hard times, and she makes it clear than when "their" money is gone, she will be, too. Des Grieux tries to improve their fortunes at the gaming table. Guillot is hot under the collar just at the sight of them. Des Grieux has good luck at the tables, winning repeatedly. But Guillot has hatched a plan of revenge. He'll keep Des Grieux busy until the police — and Des Grieux's father — can arrive. As the police enter, Lescaut slips away, but Manon and Des Grieux are arrested, accused of cheating.

ACT FIVE: Des Grieux has been exonerated, but Manon has not fared as well. She's on her way to deportation as a prostitute.

On the road to Le Havre, Lescaut bribes a guard to allow Des Grieux a few moments alone with Manon — enough time for a final love duet. Manon is desolate and gravely ill. She asks for his forgiveness for all the trouble she's caused. There's nothing to forgive, he tells her, reassuring her of happy times ahead. But Manon is exhausted. The stars in the night sky remind her of the diamonds she once wore. After one final kiss, Manon dies in her lover's arms.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.