Report: 2008 Financial Crisis Was 'Avoidable'
RENEE MONTAGNE, host:
It's been more than two years since the world financial markets imploded, and a federal panel is weighing in on who is responsible for that. The Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission released a report this morning. That report lays a large part of the blame on government regulators, including former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan. It also blames reckless risk-taking on Wall Street.
NPR's Chris Arnold reports.
CHRIS ARNOLD: The inquiry commission held interviews with more than 500 witnesses. Last January, it called the CEOs of the nation's largest banks to testify publically. Back then, the bankers said that they were not reckless or negligent; rather, they depicted themselves as victims of an economic natural disaster that they couldn't anticipate.
Here's Lloyd Blankfein, the CEO of Goldman Sachs from back then, being questioned by Commission Chairman Phil Angelides.
Mr. LLOYD BLANKFEIN (CEO, Goldman Sachs): Everything is context driven. Look, how would you look at the risk of a hurricane? The season after we had four hurricanes on the East Coast, which was absolutely extraordinary, versus the year before.
Mr. PHIL ANGELIDES (Chairman, Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission): Mr. Blankfein, I want to say this: Having sat on the board of the California Earthquake Authority, acts of God we'll exempt. These were acts of men and women.
Mr. BLANKFEIN: I'm just saying that if you're asking me a question...
Mr. ANGELIDES: No. These were controllable, is my only observation.
Mr. BLANKFEIN: I agree.
ARNOLD: Angelides' point appears to be the conclusion of the overall inquiry.
Mr. MIKE CALHOUN (President, Center for Responsible Lending): The key finding of the report was that this was not an accidental crisis.
ARNOLD: Mike Calhoun is the president of the nonprofit Center for Responsible Lending.
Mr. CALHOUN: It happened because key players were richly rewarded, played loosely, and made highly leveraged gambles that ultimately devastated our economy. And that included - in particular - Wall Street companies that ordered up risky home loans and then packaged them deceptively and dumped them on investors, often fraudulently.
ARNOLD: But the report isn't just critical of financial firms. Regulators come under some pretty harsh criticism, too, for not intervening as a plague of bad home loans spread throughout the financial system.
Mr. CALHOUN: The report hammers the Federal Reserve. It had the responsibility and authority to set mortgage rules for all types of mortgage lenders.
ARNOLD: William Black agrees. He's a law professor at the University of Missouri, Kansas City. He's also a former regulator, and served on a similar commission that looked into the causes of the savings and loan debacle back in the wake of that crisis. He, too, thinks that the Federal Reserve shares a big part of the blame for ignoring warning signs. He says back in 2004, the FBI warned of an epidemic of mortgage fraud. And even before that, the giant subprime lender Ameriquest was investigated, and found to be making big profits by selling bad home loans to investors. But Black says the Fed did nothing.
Professor WILLIAM BLACK (Economics and Law, University of Missouri, Kansas City): Think of this as a river of toxic waste. The Fed could have stopped the river at its source, could have dammed it and dried it all up.
ARNOLD: The report also says that mistakes were made by both Republicans and Democrats in Washington. It blames the Clinton administration for allowing for scant regulation of financial derivatives. But while the overall report casts blame pretty far and wide, some Republicans on the commission had a different view.
Peter Wallison is on the commission, and wrote his own dissenting report.
Mr. PETER WALLISON (Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission): My view is that this was fundamentally the government's fault. The government was creating demand for these mortgages.
ARNOLD: Wallison thinks the effort to promote home ownership - under the Clinton and then the Bush administrations - is what really set the stage for the crisis. The majority of inquiry commission members, though, disagreed.
Chris Arnold, NPR News.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.