Democracy In Egypt An Uncertainty, Analysts Fear

  • Egyptians stand on top of sacks of garbage collected from the streets of Tahrir Square in Cairo on Saturday.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians stand on top of sacks of garbage collected from the streets of Tahrir Square in Cairo on Saturday.
    Emilio Morenatti/AP
  • Soldiers hug as others remove the wreckage of a car burned during the anti-government protests in Cairo.
    Hide caption
    Soldiers hug as others remove the wreckage of a car burned during the anti-government protests in Cairo.
    Pedro Ugarte/AFP/Getty Images
  • Volunteers scrub paint and graffiti off of a wall in Tahrir Square. Cleaning crews, both paid and unpaid, made quick work of cleanup where thousands of protesters lived and fought for more than two weeks.
    Hide caption
    Volunteers scrub paint and graffiti off of a wall in Tahrir Square. Cleaning crews, both paid and unpaid, made quick work of cleanup where thousands of protesters lived and fought for more than two weeks.
    Chris Hondros/Getty Images
  • Morning breaks Saturday on Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the popular revolt that drove Hosni Mubarak from power.
    Hide caption
    Morning breaks Saturday on Tahrir Square, the epicenter of the popular revolt that drove Hosni Mubarak from power.
    Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images
  • Egyptians gather around graffiti that reads, "January 25, Egypt's greatest and noblest day, Martyrs Square" in Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians gather around graffiti that reads, "January 25, Egypt's greatest and noblest day, Martyrs Square" in Tahrir Square.
    Khalil Hamra/AP
  • Egyptians read about Friday's events in front a tank.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians read about Friday's events in front a tank.
    Manoocher Deghati/AP
  • Egyptians gather to clean up Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians gather to clean up Tahrir Square.
    Chris Hondros/Getty Images
  • Soldiers remove a car burnt during clashes in Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Soldiers remove a car burnt during clashes in Tahrir Square.
    John Moore/Getty Images
  • Volunteers clean up Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Volunteers clean up Tahrir Square.
    John Moore/Getty Images
  • A mountain of blankets sits in an encampment in Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    A mountain of blankets sits in an encampment in Tahrir Square.
    John Moore/Getty Images
  • Soldiers remove barbed wire at one of the main entrances to Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Soldiers remove barbed wire at one of the main entrances to Tahrir Square.
    Hussein Malla/AP
  • An Egyptian woman waves the national flag in front of a tank.
    Hide caption
    An Egyptian woman waves the national flag in front of a tank.
    Manoocher Deghati/AP
  • Egyptians embrace while celebrating Mubarak's resignation.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians embrace while celebrating Mubarak's resignation.
    Chris Hondros/Getty Images
  • Egyptians celebrate Mubarak's resignation.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians celebrate Mubarak's resignation.
    Chris Hondros/Getty Images
  • Protesters sing by a field medical clinic near the barricades in Tahrir Square.
    Hide caption
    Protesters sing by a field medical clinic near the barricades in Tahrir Square.
    Ben Curtis/AP

1 of 15

View slideshow i
During a coup d'etat led by General Muhammed Naguib,  Egyptian army tanks and field guns are drawn up in front of the royal  Abdin Palace, in Cairo, on July 26, 1952. Appointed Premier Ali  Maher Pasha issued an ultimatum to King Farouk I, forcing the Egyptian monarch  to abdicate. i

During a coup d'etat led by General Muhammed Naguib, Egyptian army tanks and field guns are drawn up in front of the royal Abdin Palace, in Cairo, on July 26, 1952. Appointed Premier Ali Maher Pasha issued an ultimatum to King Farouk I, forcing the Egyptian monarch to abdicate. AP hide caption

itoggle caption AP
During a coup d'etat led by General Muhammed Naguib,  Egyptian army tanks and field guns are drawn up in front of the royal  Abdin Palace, in Cairo, on July 26, 1952. Appointed Premier Ali  Maher Pasha issued an ultimatum to King Farouk I, forcing the Egyptian monarch  to abdicate.

During a coup d'etat led by General Muhammed Naguib, Egyptian army tanks and field guns are drawn up in front of the royal Abdin Palace, in Cairo, on July 26, 1952. Appointed Premier Ali Maher Pasha issued an ultimatum to King Farouk I, forcing the Egyptian monarch to abdicate.

AP

Egyptians welcomed military rule Friday with a massive display of joy.

Protesters across Cairo reveled at the victory they had wrought, and Egyptian reporters on cable TV channels were reduced to tears as they sought to convey their happiness.

But many questions remain about what comes next — and there are strong doubts about whether military rule will lead to the demonstrators' ultimate goal: a credible transition to democracy.

"The heavy lifting begins now," says Robert Springborg, a professor at the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School. "Now is the time for the military to confront its moment of truth."

More Questions Than Answers

Recently appointed Egyptian Vice President Omar Suleiman announced the dramatic shift in a simple, one-sentence address on state TV. He said President Hosni Mubarak had decided to waive his office as president and asked "the Armed Forces Supreme Council to run the state."

As with just about every official pronouncement these past two weeks, it left many more questions than answers. Will a new, more democratic constitution be created and when? Will the Parliament, filled with Mubarak loyalists, be dissolved? Will elections scheduled for September go ahead, be rescheduled or be put off? And what about the opposition leaders who've emerged over the past three weeks?

"We don't know how this new military junta will interact with them," says David Patel of Cornell University. "Will it just consult with them? Even if the military today says it wants early elections, the question is whether that opposition is part of this interim regime."

During 18 days of street demonstrations, there were numerous signs that the military — or at least some junior members — were siding with protesters. Some stood together with protesters on military tanks and some outright joined the ranks in Tahrir Square. On Friday, before the takeover announcement, military personnel in Alexandria handed out water bottles to demonstrators. A growing number of protesters had been asking for what they call "the people's army" to step in and launch a coup.

Still, Jason Brownlee, of the University of Texas, Austin, questions whether Egypt's military really has a sovereign, civilian government in mind.

"I don't see evidence the military is willing to go backstage," he says. The message could be "we've heard you, we've responded, congratulations, now go home."

Brownlee thinks protesters might keep more of their new leverage if they maintain a peaceful presence on the streets, pushing for broader change in the overall security regime. "If the Ministry of Interior, the police, and all of that stays around," he says, "it's hard to see how Egyptians' daily lives would be substantively improved a year from now."

Protesters have made clear they want not only Mubarak's departure but true regime change.

"There are tens of thousands of members of the regime and the military-industrial complex," analyst Patel says. "How many of those people are going to see their patronage-based positions challenged?"

  • Egyptians celebrate in Tahrir Square after hearing the news of the resignation of President Hosni Mubarak on Friday.
    Hide caption
    Egyptians celebrate in Tahrir Square after hearing the news of the resignation of President Hosni Mubarak on Friday.
    John Moore/Getty Images
  • Hundreds of thousands chanted, "The people have brought down the regime!"
    Hide caption
    Hundreds of thousands chanted, "The people have brought down the regime!"
    Hussein Malla/AP
  • Millions of Egyptians celebrated the country's first transition of power in 30 years.
    Hide caption
    Millions of Egyptians celebrated the country's first transition of power in 30 years.
    Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images
  • Egyptian soldiers celebrate with anti-government protesters. Vice President Omar Suleiman announced the military will take control over affairs of state.
    Hide caption
    Egyptian soldiers celebrate with anti-government protesters. Vice President Omar Suleiman announced the military will take control over affairs of state.
    Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images
  • Demonstrators rejoice in Tahrir Square. "We are emancipating 85 million people who have been repressed for decades," said Nobel Peace Prize laureate Mohamed ElBaradei.
    Hide caption
    Demonstrators rejoice in Tahrir Square. "We are emancipating 85 million people who have been repressed for decades," said Nobel Peace Prize laureate Mohamed ElBaradei.
    Mohammed Abed/AFP/Getty Images
  • Vice President Omar Suleiman delivers an address on Egyptian state television Friday, stating that President Hosni Mubarak has stepped down.
    Hide caption
    Vice President Omar Suleiman delivers an address on Egyptian state television Friday, stating that President Hosni Mubarak has stepped down.
    Al-Masriya TV/AFP/Getty Images
  • Protesters wave flags outside the Presidential Palace on Friday. Cairo's streets exploded in celebration when Mubarak stepped down after three decades of autocratic rule.
    Hide caption
    Protesters wave flags outside the Presidential Palace on Friday. Cairo's streets exploded in celebration when Mubarak stepped down after three decades of autocratic rule.
    Pedro Ugarte/AFP/Getty Images
  • Egyptian anti-goverment demonstrators shout in Cairo's Tahrir Square on Friday, the 18th consecutive day of protests demanding the resignation of Mubarak.
    Hide caption
    Egyptian anti-goverment demonstrators shout in Cairo's Tahrir Square on Friday, the 18th consecutive day of protests demanding the resignation of Mubarak.
    Pedro Ugarte/AFP/Getty Images
  • Protesters take a break for prayer amid the protests in Tahrir Square on Friday.
    Hide caption
    Protesters take a break for prayer amid the protests in Tahrir Square on Friday.
    Tara Todras-Whitehill/AP
  • In an address to the nation Thursday, Mubarak announced his plan to stay until the September elections, with the backing of Egypt's military. Anti-government protests escalated.
    Hide caption
    In an address to the nation Thursday, Mubarak announced his plan to stay until the September elections, with the backing of Egypt's military. Anti-government protests escalated.
    Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images
  • An anti-Mubarak poster hangs over graffiti endorsing the president. Clashes between anti-government protesters and Mubarak supporters have thrown Cairo into violence.
    Hide caption
    An anti-Mubarak poster hangs over graffiti endorsing the president. Clashes between anti-government protesters and Mubarak supporters have thrown Cairo into violence.
    Amr Nabil/AP
  • In the early hours Friday, anti-government demonstrators rest in front of posters of people killed during the latest political crisis.
    Hide caption
    In the early hours Friday, anti-government demonstrators rest in front of posters of people killed during the latest political crisis.
    Pedro Ugarte/AFP/Getty Images
  • In a gesture of disrespect Friday, anti-government protesters raise their shoes in front of the Egyptian national TV building, which is currently secured by the Egyptian army.
    Hide caption
    In a gesture of disrespect Friday, anti-government protesters raise their shoes in front of the Egyptian national TV building, which is currently secured by the Egyptian army.
    Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images
  • A protester reads a newspaper while resting against an army tank in Tahrir Square on Friday.
    Hide caption
    A protester reads a newspaper while resting against an army tank in Tahrir Square on Friday.
    Pedro Ugarte/AFP/Getty Images
  • A soldier stands guard next to a tank as crowds protest in front of the state television building in downtown Cairo on Friday.
    Hide caption
    A soldier stands guard next to a tank as crowds protest in front of the state television building in downtown Cairo on Friday.
    Emilio Morenatti/AP
  • An Egyptian army officer speaks to anti-government protesters outside the national television building after President Mubarak's Thursday address to the nation.
    Hide caption
    An Egyptian army officer speaks to anti-government protesters outside the national television building after President Mubarak's Thursday address to the nation.
    John Moore/Getty Images

1 of 16

View slideshow i

Springborg, of the U.S. Naval Postgraduate School, says Egypt's military has ossified for decades, with little role other than to support the president. The institution "needs to be modernized and subject to civilian control," he says. "They're going to fight that and it's going to be a huge issue."

Egypt's Long Military History

Egypt's military has been integral to governance ever since it staged a revolt against the Egyptian monarchy and its British advisers in 1952.

That's when Col. Gamal Abdel Nasser led a clandestine group of junior "Free Officers" to seize power, with the aim of modernizing and democratizing Egypt. But the leadership was beset with infighting. Nasser's plans for a vibrant socialist economy foundered. A fairly liberal constitution was eventually written, but never implemented.

Today's top military officials see themselves as the heirs of those Free Officers. But Robert Scales, the former commandant of the U.S. Army War College, says there's a generational split that could prove crucial.

"One is the old guard represented by Field Marshal Tantawi, and [recently named vice president Omar] Suleiman and others, and then you have the young guard, those who came up in the Egyptian army after the '73 Yom Kippur War. And what you see is a sort of internal tension that seems to be evolving inside the army, as one part seeks to hold on to the old and the younger generation looks for the new."

Scales notes the older generation was trained by the Soviets, while the younger one has been trained and educated by the U.S., "and so there really is a cultural rift."

Military Links To Economy

On Friday, Egypt's military said that Defense Minister Tantawi was presiding over the Supreme Council, the military body that has taken control of the state.

An Egyptian anti-government protester laughs as he shakes the hand of a soldier during celebrations at Cairo's Tahrir Square on Feb 11 after president Hosni Mubarak stepped down. Flag-waving Egyptians danced, sang and cheered as they bid farewell to Hosni Mubarak's 30-year regime, but triumph was tempered with apprehension as they looked ahead to military rule. i

An Egyptian anti-government protester laughs as he shakes the hand of a soldier during celebrations at Cairo's Tahrir Square on Feb 11 after president Hosni Mubarak stepped down. Flag-waving Egyptians danced, sang and cheered as they bid farewell to Hosni Mubarak's 30-year regime, but triumph was tempered with apprehension as they looked ahead to military rule. Patrick Baz/AFP/Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Patrick Baz/AFP/Getty Images
An Egyptian anti-government protester laughs as he shakes the hand of a soldier during celebrations at Cairo's Tahrir Square on Feb 11 after president Hosni Mubarak stepped down. Flag-waving Egyptians danced, sang and cheered as they bid farewell to Hosni Mubarak's 30-year regime, but triumph was tempered with apprehension as they looked ahead to military rule.

An Egyptian anti-government protester laughs as he shakes the hand of a soldier during celebrations at Cairo's Tahrir Square on Feb 11 after president Hosni Mubarak stepped down. Flag-waving Egyptians danced, sang and cheered as they bid farewell to Hosni Mubarak's 30-year regime, but triumph was tempered with apprehension as they looked ahead to military rule.

Patrick Baz/AFP/Getty Images

Top commanders, all with strong political ties to Mubarak, may have decided they needed to break with him for the sake of their own legitimacy. But they still have a vital stake in the status quo, not just politically but also economically.

In a strange public-private alliance forged decades ago, Egyptian military officers own a share in just about every industry in the country, from road construction to car assembly to tourism. This could lead to a serious clash with protesters who've been calling for an end to corruption and for Mubarak to be put on trial.

"To investigate the transgressions of the regime is to take it directly into the military economy," says Springborg. Military leaders have "less than zero interest in having an investigation of that."

The military on Friday also said it would end the 30-year-old state of emergency "as soon as the current circumstances are over." And that it would oversee a revision of the constitution to allow "free and fair presidential elections."

But rewriting a constitution is a long and complicated process. So far, the opposition that's coalesced on the streets of Cairo and other cities has agreed on one key thing: Mubarak's departure. Whether they can agree on broader goals during a protracted debate on constitutional policy is an open question.

Springborg suspects that a real constitutional overhaul is not on the military's agenda. The current document heavily centralizes power in a strong president, something he believes top commanders are loath to change.

"I think the military would breathe a sigh of relief if they had a successful [presidential] candidate under the current constitution," he says. "Someone who won't challenge its privileges and powers."

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.