How A Recession Rewires Your Tolerance For Risk

A trader works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on August 11, 2011. US stocks made another dramatic comeback after a stunning fall on Thursday, in another day of extreme volatility in markets around the world. i i

hide captionA trader works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on August 11, 2011. US stocks made another dramatic comeback after a stunning fall on Thursday, in another day of extreme volatility in markets around the world.

Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images
A trader works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on August 11, 2011. US stocks made another dramatic comeback after a stunning fall on Thursday, in another day of extreme volatility in markets around the world.

A trader works on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on August 11, 2011. US stocks made another dramatic comeback after a stunning fall on Thursday, in another day of extreme volatility in markets around the world.

Stan Honda/AFP/Getty Images

This past week the stock market took a serious nose-dive, the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped 500 points on Thursday. As a result, investors across the board have been flocking to safer investments. Now you might expect older people to cash out in order to save their nest eggs — but young people? The standard investment advice would be to hold tight. Turns out, they're actually the ones fleeing from stocks the fastest.

UC Berkeley Economics Professor Ulrike Malmendier has been researching how big economic changes, such as a recession or depression, affect the way people invest. She says the past decade — with the tech bubble burst of 2000, the crash of 2008 and the plunge of this month — has made young people less likely to invest in the stock market.

"Your average lifetime experience so far has a strong predictive power on your willingness to take risk. So if you're born in a period where things are going badly, stagflation in the 70s or just the current financial crisis, you are very unlikely to be investing at all in the stock market, if so very little. Vice versa if it has been a boom period, the post-World War II boom or you know, during the tech bubble if only the good stuff happened to far."

Ulrike Malmendier, Associate Professor of Economics at UC Berkeley, says that living through a serious recession can make you less likely to invest in the stock market for decades.

hide captionUlrike Malmendier, Associate Professor of Economics at UC Berkeley, says that living through a serious recession can make you less likely to invest in the stock market for decades.

University of Berkeley, California

Malmendier says the chaos in the markets now could have a long-term effect on young people.

"It takes about thirty years to go away, but then it does. So if somebody experienced the Great Depression in the twenties, in the fifties that person will actually not be as distinguishable from somebody who did not experience the Great Depression," she says.

What happens in the years following a depression or recession, Malmendier explains, is that the people affected actually think bad events are more likely to happen than they are. So if you give them a 50-50 gamble, they think it is really more like a 90-10 proposition and walk away.

"You attach the wrong probabilities to the outcome," she says.

Malmendier's says her research suggests that young people today are likely to invest very little, if at all, in the stock market for decades.

"This is drastic because despite all those ups and downs I think most financial economists would agree that a young person who is saving for the long-run should just have a broadly diversified portfolio, and this is not likely to happen at least for the next coming years," she says. "So the younger generation is really losing out in terms of the long-term preparation for when they have high expenses, family, ultimately retirement even."

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: