Next Question: Can Romney Win In The South?

Mitt Romney supporters share a pancake brunch in Snellville, Ga., on Sunday. Rival Newt Gingrich won the state on Super Tuesday, by about 22 percentage points.

Mitt Romney supporters share a pancake brunch in Snellville, Ga., on Sunday. Rival Newt Gingrich won the state on Super Tuesday, by about 22 percentage points. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

Given his victories on Super Tuesday, there's growing talk that Republican officeholders and voters are just about ready to line up behind Mitt Romney as the party's "inevitable" presidential nominee.

The South hasn't gotten the memo.

Romney lost Tennessee, Georgia and Oklahoma on Tuesday. Added to his loss in South Carolina in January — which was the first big stumble along Romney's road to the nomination — some Republicans are worried about potentially having a candidate with limited appeal in what is arguably the party's strongest region. (Romney did win Florida, but its demographics make it distinct from the rest of the South.)

And the former Massachusetts governor may be in for some more Southern discomfort, with primaries set for March 13 in Alabama and Mississippi.

Further losses in the South may not be enough to cost him the nomination. And the Republican nominee — no matter who that is — will be expected to prevail in many Southern states against President Obama in the fall.

Obama, who won Virginia, North Carolina and Florida in 2008, hopes to hold onto those states. He travels to North Carolina on Wednesday to talk about jobs and the manufacturing sector.

But Romney's weakness in the region is bound to cause him some further headaches, if only by emboldening his GOP opponents to stay in the race.

  • Mitt Romney hugs his wife, Ann, as he arrived at his Super Tuesday rally in Boston. Romney narrowly beat Santorum in Ohio.
    Hide caption
    Mitt Romney hugs his wife, Ann, as he arrived at his Super Tuesday rally in Boston. Romney narrowly beat Santorum in Ohio.
    Brian Snyder/Reuters/Landov
  • Rick Santorum and his wife, Karen, arrive at a rally in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Hide caption
    Rick Santorum and his wife, Karen, arrive at a rally in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Jim Young/Reuters/Landov
  • Mitt Romney shakes hands with supporters at his primary election night rally in Boston. Romney won the race in Massachusetts.
    Hide caption
    Mitt Romney shakes hands with supporters at his primary election night rally in Boston. Romney won the race in Massachusetts.
    Brian Snyder/Reuters/Landov
  • Rick Santorum supporters stand outside a primary party in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Hide caption
    Rick Santorum supporters stand outside a primary party in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Jim Young/Reuters/Landov
  • Newt Gingrich and his wife, Callista, wave to supporters at an event in Atlanta after he was declared the winner of the Georgia primary.
    Hide caption
    Newt Gingrich and his wife, Callista, wave to supporters at an event in Atlanta after he was declared the winner of the Georgia primary.
    Alex Wong/Getty Images
  • William House waits for Newt Gingrich to arrive during a campaign stop at the U.S. Space and Rocket Center in Huntsville, Ala.
    Hide caption
    William House waits for Newt Gingrich to arrive during a campaign stop at the U.S. Space and Rocket Center in Huntsville, Ala.
    Evan Vucci/AP
  • Romney supporters celebrate during a primary night gathering on Tuesday in Boston.
    Hide caption
    Romney supporters celebrate during a primary night gathering on Tuesday in Boston.
    Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
  • Romney and his wife, Ann, wave to supporters after voting in the Massachusetts primary in Belmont, Mass.
    Hide caption
    Romney and his wife, Ann, wave to supporters after voting in the Massachusetts primary in Belmont, Mass.
    Gerald Herbert/AP
  • Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich speaks at the U.S. Space and Rocket Center, in Huntsville, Ala.
    Hide caption
    Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich speaks at the U.S. Space and Rocket Center, in Huntsville, Ala.
    Evan Vucci/AP
  • Sophia Walsh, 5, watches as her father, William Walsh, fills out his ballot in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Hide caption
    Sophia Walsh, 5, watches as her father, William Walsh, fills out his ballot in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Joe Raedle/Getty Images
  • Ron Paul speaks to a crowd at the Nampa Civic Center in Nampa, Idaho. Paul is expected to do well in the Idaho primary.
    Hide caption
    Ron Paul speaks to a crowd at the Nampa Civic Center in Nampa, Idaho. Paul is expected to do well in the Idaho primary.
    Katherine Jones/Idaho Statesman/MCT/Landov
  • A voter casts his ballot in Montpelier, Vt. Romney is also expected to do well in the state, which borders Massachusetts.
    Hide caption
    A voter casts his ballot in Montpelier, Vt. Romney is also expected to do well in the state, which borders Massachusetts.
    Toby Talbot/AP
  • Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum steps off the trail to speak to the American Israel Policy Affairs Committee in Washington.
    Hide caption
    Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum steps off the trail to speak to the American Israel Policy Affairs Committee in Washington.
    Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
  • Workers hang an American flag in preparation for Santorum's election night party at Steubenville High School in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Hide caption
    Workers hang an American flag in preparation for Santorum's election night party at Steubenville High School in Steubenville, Ohio.
    Eric Gay/AP

1 of 14

View slideshow i

Special Coverage

Super Tuesday

Alaska

Georgia

Idaho

Massachusetts

North Dakota

Ohio (At-Large)

Oklahoma

Tennessee

Vermont

Virginia

full results

"It's a problem, because it's going to keep the other guys hanging around for a while," says Anthony Nownes, a political scientist at the University of Tennessee. "Rick Santorum did so well in Tennessee and Oklahoma [winning both states on Tuesday] that there's enough there for him to keep going."

Not A Perfect Fit

Romney's Southern problems have several different roots. Evangelical voters have been reluctant to embrace him, with more than six in 10 primary voters in Tennessee and Georgia saying it's important to share a candidate's religious beliefs, according to exit polls conducted Tuesday.

As has been the case in other states, Romney has struggled to win over rural and blue-collar voters, who are more prevalent in some Southern states than elsewhere.

"The fact is, the base of the party is white, rural voters, particularly in the South," Nownes says.

And Romney's reputation as the most moderate candidate in the GOP field has been a handicap in the nation's most conservative region.

"He's not a natural for the South," says Merle Black, an expert on Southern politics at Emory University. "He's a guy who thought passing health care in Massachusetts was going to be a plus in 2008. Conservatives certainly don't see him as one of their own."

Coming Home This Fall

The Romney campaign has sought to reassure party leaders across the South that his losses in the region won't matter in the end. The conservatives who have opposed him in primaries will not express further disdain by supporting Obama.

"They may not be particularly fond of Mitt Romney, but given a choice between Mitt Romney and Obama, most white voters [in the South] are going to vote for Mitt Romney," says Charles Bullock, a political scientist at the University of Georgia. (Nationwide, Obama won 43 percent of the white vote in 2008, actually a slight improvement over previous Democratic nominee John Kerry, who won 41 percent of the white vote in 2004.)

There is always a chance that many evangelicals and other Southerners could be so discouraged by a Romney nomination that they'll stay home in the fall.

Even if that were to happen, however, the winner-take-all nature of the Electoral College means that Romney would still be favored across the Deep South.

Still The Solid South

The parties have switched places when it comes to Southern dominance. For much of the 20th century, the South was solid for Democrats. It was only after the South began to favor Republicans that Democrats nominated Southerners such as Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton and Al Gore, in part in hopes of competing in the region.

During their long period of success, Democrats rarely bothered to put Southerners on the ticket — Lyndon B. Johnson in the 1960s and John Nance "Cactus Jack" Garner in the 1930s, both Texans, being the exceptions.

"By and large, you could ignore the South and still win — you could take them for granted," says David Woodard, a Republican consultant who teaches at Clemson University. "They weren't going to vote Republican."

Mitt Romney holds babies during a campaign rally Sunday in Knoxville, Tenn. On Tuesday, Romney finished a distant second to Rick Santorum in the state. i i

Mitt Romney holds babies during a campaign rally Sunday in Knoxville, Tenn. On Tuesday, Romney finished a distant second to Rick Santorum in the state. Justin Sullivan/Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Mitt Romney holds babies during a campaign rally Sunday in Knoxville, Tenn. On Tuesday, Romney finished a distant second to Rick Santorum in the state.

Mitt Romney holds babies during a campaign rally Sunday in Knoxville, Tenn. On Tuesday, Romney finished a distant second to Rick Santorum in the state.

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images

The reverse now is true for Republicans.

Romney's Southern Strategy

Romney and the superPAC backing his campaign have been advertising and sponsoring robo calls in Southern states, in hopes of racking up delegates even in states he is unlikely to win outright.

"Romney began spending money in the state," says Tennessee GOP consultant Tom Ingram, "but that's really the only thing he did. There wasn't any established grass-roots effort."

But not pressing his case too hard — and not shifting further to the right on issues such as abortion and gay marriage in order to appeal to Southern sensibilities — may prove a canny move on Romney's part, Woodard says, that could help him in the fall in the Southern states that may actually be competitive.

The two Southern states that Romney has won thus far — Florida, by dint of a multimillion-dollar effort in January, and Virginia on Tuesday, practically through default (neither Rick Santorum nor Newt Gingrich were on the ballot) — have often supported Republicans, but went for Obama in 2008.

"You can appeal to the moderates and at least this way pick up Virginia, North Carolina and Florida that might get out from under the tent," Woodard says.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.