Long-Term-Care Insurance: Who Needs It?

  • AnnaBelle Bowers, 87, has lunch with granddaughter Kelley Hawkins in Harrisburg, Pa. Kelley and her sister-in-law, LaDonna Martin, jointly care for AnnaBelle.
    Hide caption
    AnnaBelle Bowers, 87, has lunch with granddaughter Kelley Hawkins in Harrisburg, Pa. Kelley and her sister-in-law, LaDonna Martin, jointly care for AnnaBelle.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • AnnaBelle, affectionately nicknamed "Snootzie," lost her husband years ago and in the past few years has become too frail to live alone.
    Hide caption
    AnnaBelle, affectionately nicknamed "Snootzie," lost her husband years ago and in the past few years has become too frail to live alone.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • LaDonna talks on the phone with Kelley while helping AnnaBelle with her makeup in her family's living room.
    Hide caption
    LaDonna talks on the phone with Kelley while helping AnnaBelle with her makeup in her family's living room.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Kelley and LaDonna, both nurses in their 40s with two children each, agree that the decision to take on AnnaBelle's care wasn't an easy financial choice. Above, AnnaBelle's pillbox.
    Hide caption
    Kelley and LaDonna, both nurses in their 40s with two children each, agree that the decision to take on AnnaBelle's care wasn't an easy financial choice. Above, AnnaBelle's pillbox.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Every two weeks AnnaBelle rotates from one home to another. After two years of moving her back and forth, LaDonna and Kelley have fine-tuned their routine but still fill an SUV with AnnaBelle's necessities.
    Hide caption
    Every two weeks AnnaBelle rotates from one home to another. After two years of moving her back and forth, LaDonna and Kelley have fine-tuned their routine but still fill an SUV with AnnaBelle's necessities.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • LaDonna speaks with AnnaBelle's longtime physician, Walter Watkin.
    Hide caption
    LaDonna speaks with AnnaBelle's longtime physician, Walter Watkin.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • LaDonna and Kelley live minutes away from each other in suburban Harrisburg, making it easy to move AnnaBelle back and forth.
    Hide caption
    LaDonna and Kelley live minutes away from each other in suburban Harrisburg, making it easy to move AnnaBelle back and forth.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • "I'm not rich moneywise, but with family I'm a millionaire," AnnaBelle says, acknowledging the care she is getting from Kelley (left) and LaDonna (right).
    Hide caption
    "I'm not rich moneywise, but with family I'm a millionaire," AnnaBelle says, acknowledging the care she is getting from Kelley (left) and LaDonna (right).
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • LaDonna hands AnnaBelle's clothes to Kelley. "I'm hoping my daughters see how we are taking care of Snootzie and treat me the same way," says Kelley.
    Hide caption
    LaDonna hands AnnaBelle's clothes to Kelley. "I'm hoping my daughters see how we are taking care of Snootzie and treat me the same way," says Kelley.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Kelley supports AnnaBelle as she goes up the steps entering her family's home. AnnaBelle's mobility is significantly hampered owing to rheumatoid arthritis.
    Hide caption
    Kelley supports AnnaBelle as she goes up the steps entering her family's home. AnnaBelle's mobility is significantly hampered owing to rheumatoid arthritis.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • A younger AnnaBelle smiles with her great-granddaughters Chelsea (left) and Carley (right).
    Hide caption
    A younger AnnaBelle smiles with her great-granddaughters Chelsea (left) and Carley (right).
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Kelley's daughter Carley, 17, looks at her prom dress while Kelley tends to AnnaBelle. By next year, Kelley and her husband will have two daughters in college.
    Hide caption
    Kelley's daughter Carley, 17, looks at her prom dress while Kelley tends to AnnaBelle. By next year, Kelley and her husband will have two daughters in college.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • AnnaBelle enjoys a moment with her great-granddaughter and LaDonna's daughter, Lauren, 12. LaDonna says that having AnnaBelle at home has made both sets of children kinder and less self-centered.
    Hide caption
    AnnaBelle enjoys a moment with her great-granddaughter and LaDonna's daughter, Lauren, 12. LaDonna says that having AnnaBelle at home has made both sets of children kinder and less self-centered.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR

1 of 13

View slideshow i

Part of the Family Matters series

An Expert Weighs In

Americans routinely buy all sorts of insurance — for cars, homes, health and even pets and boats.

But when it comes to long-term-care insurance, relatively few sign up. Out of more than 313 million Americans, only about 8 million have any such protection, according to the American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance. The low participation rate largely reflects the high cost of long-term-care insurance.

Geneva Hunter, 66, is among those without protection. She is well aware of how helpful it would be to have such insurance. She gets schooled on that point each day: Her 89-year-old mother, Ida Christian, who has Alzheimer's disease, lives with her.

"I do not have [the insurance] because at the time it was offered [through my company], I could not afford it and take care of my mother at the same time," said Hunter, a member of one of three families being profiled by NPR in a series called Family Matters: The Money Squeeze.

AnnaBelle Bowers' long-time physician, Walter Watkin, gives her a kiss on the forehead at the end of her visit. When asked how long she had been coming to see him, he said, "Long enough for her file to be 2 inches thick." i i

AnnaBelle Bowers' long-time physician, Walter Watkin, gives her a kiss on the forehead at the end of her visit. When asked how long she had been coming to see him, he said, "Long enough for her file to be 2 inches thick." Kainaz Amaria/NPR hide caption

itoggle caption Kainaz Amaria/NPR
AnnaBelle Bowers' long-time physician, Walter Watkin, gives her a kiss on the forehead at the end of her visit. When asked how long she had been coming to see him, he said, "Long enough for her file to be 2 inches thick."

AnnaBelle Bowers' long-time physician, Walter Watkin, gives her a kiss on the forehead at the end of her visit. When asked how long she had been coming to see him, he said, "Long enough for her file to be 2 inches thick."

Kainaz Amaria/NPR

"I think it was close to $400 a month," Hunter said. "That's a lot of money when you are caring for somebody else."

But with each passing birthday, Hunter feels more pressure to buy insurance. "I know it's expensive, but I have to do it," she says, because she fears becoming a financial burden to her daughter.

Many Americans share that financial goal: to not burden others. But the reality is that each year, an estimated 11 million U.S. adults need some type of long-term care.

Information On Long-Term Care And Insurance

Read more about long-term care, including tips on planning and paying for it, at the National Clearinghouse for Long-Term Care, developed by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Resources. The site also includes information on long-term-care insurance.

Such care can be crushingly expensive: Just one hour of home-health-aide care costs roughly $20, while the average private nursing home room costs $87,000 a year. Neither routine employer-based medical insurance nor Medicare will pay for extended periods of custodial care.

Scott Hawkins, 46, and a member of another family in the NPR series, says he hasn't yet explored getting long-term-care insurance. In fact, future elder-care costs are so daunting that only humor can help defuse the ticking financial bomb.

"Our youngest daughter [Carley] is a little bit of a comedian and she made the comment one time to us, 'Hey, when you guys get old, don't worry about it' — and we were thinking she is going to say something nice," he said. Instead, she suggested her parents plan on living with their older daughter, Chelsea, who is studying to be a pharmacist.

Scott recalls Carley joking that he would "eat better if you live at Chelsea's house because she'll be making twice as much money as I make being a schoolteacher!"

For the nation's roughly 78 million baby boomers, the time for humor about who will prepare their meals is quickly running out. Many boomers, people born between 1946 and 1964, are expected to fall so far into poverty trying to provide themselves with paid care that they will qualify for Medicaid — the medical care program for the deeply impoverished.

A fortunate few will have long-term-care insurance, but even that option is looking sketchy as more companies exit the business. Insurance giants such as Prudential and MetLife have recently pulled back from offering long-term-care policies. Others, such as John Hancock and Genworth Financial, have turned to state regulators, seeking permission to dramatically hike premiums. Depending upon the location, the insurers' requests for higher rates have been for amounts such as 18 percent or 40 percent or, in a few cases, 90 percent.

Share Your Photos, Stories

Do you live in a multigenerational household? Share your candid photos and stories with us on Tumblr or #nprfamilymatters on Twitter and Instagram.

Here are answers to some common questions about long-term-care insurance.

What is long-term-care insurance?

This type of policy covers basic daily needs over an extended time. While health care insurance or Medicare helps pay for immediate medical expenses, say, a surgeon's bill, long-term-care insurance helps people cope with the cost of chronic illnesses, such as Alzheimer's disease, or various disabilities. The policies pay for assistance with everything from the basics — bathing and dressing — to skilled care from therapists and nurses for months or even years.

Do you have to be in an institution to collect your benefits?

Long-term-care insurance typically covers out-of-pocket expenses that come with home care, assisted living and nursing homes. Most policies have a waiting period that works like a deductible. So if you need the help of a home-nursing aide, you may have to wait 90 or 120 days before your benefits start to cover those costs.

How much does insurance cost?

The American Association for Long-Term Care Insurance says people should expect to pay an average of $3,335 per year to cover a couple of healthy 60-year-olds on a plan that pays out a $150 daily benefit for up to three years. But prices can vary dramatically, depending upon factors such as the purchasers' age, the level of inflation-adjustment protection and whether the daily benefit will be $100, or some larger amount, say, $150 or $200.

Long-Term-Care Insurance Policy Costs, Values

Compare the costs and coverage offered in a sampling of long-term-care insurance policies.

Age Yearly cost1 Immediate
value2
Value at
age 803
Value at
age 853
Age 55 (single) preferred health $1,720 Range: $1,428 - $2,552 $170,000 $354,000 $418,000
Age 55 (couple) preferred health
(with shared care option)
$2,700 Range: $2,027 - $3,574 $340,000 $708,000 $836,000
Age 60 (couple) preferred health
(with shared care option)
$3,335 Range: $2,700 - $4,204 $340,000 $611,000 $708,000
Age 65 (couple) standard health
(with shared care option)
$4,433 Range: $3,815 - $7,129 $340,000 $533,000 $611,000

Notes

  1. Calculations based on: $150 daily benefit selected at inception of plan, 3-year benefit period, 90-day elimination period, 100 percent home care benefit and 3 percent inflation compounded annually. Includes spousal discount (where applicable) and preferred health discount (when indicated).
  2. Equals available cash value of benefits that would be paid for claim starting at present age (an almost immediate claim). Policies ranged from $162,000 to $200,000 in initial benefits.
  3. Equals available cash value of benefits that would be paid based on 3 percent annual compound growth of policy benefits.
  4. Shared care options vary from company to company. For illustration purposes, this example assumes access to a combined, total pool of funds.

Why is the coverage so expensive?

The premiums are high and rising because providing long-term care can be so risky for the insurer. In contrast, the potential claim on an insured home can be reasonably estimated. If a $100,000 home is burned to the ground, the claim would reflect that amount. But predicting how much care a person might need — and for how long — is not easy.

These days, policies typically are capped at three years because open-ended plans have proved too risky for the insurer. The insurance association points to the case of a woman who purchased coverage at age 43. For three years, she paid her annual premium of $881. Then, she needed care, so she stopped paying premiums and initiated her claim. Her care lasted 15 years and cost the insurer $1.7 million, the association said.

"Insurers paid some $6.6 billion in benefits to roughly 200,000 individuals last year," says Jesse Slome, executive director of the group.

When should you get the insurance?

It's cheaper when you sign up by age 60. You have to be medically healthy to qualify. But, like auto insurance, a policy generally has no "surrender" value. That is, if you never have an auto accident, then all the money you spent on car insurance is gone forever. Typically, that's how it works with long-term-care insurance; i.e., you may pay and pay — and never get back a penny if you don't medically qualify for care.

Also, some people pay their premiums for years, and then get hit with rate hikes they can't afford. They then face the tough decision of dropping their policies — and losing any chance of collecting benefits — or trying to struggle on, paying higher rates or accepting lower benefits, such as less inflation-adjustment protection.

Is it worth buying?

Experts say the insurance can be a huge help, especially for people without children and relatively small retirement savings. But it's far from a perfect solution to all problems. For example, a policy typically covers three years of care, but many people live long beyond that cap. And the new policies are being written with more restrictions to limit insurers' risks.

Whether it makes sense to spend so much money on premiums, rather than focus on building up a retirement savings account, is a complicated equation that requires serious study.

Morning Edition producer Jessica Smith contributed to this story.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.