Paying For College: More Tough Decisions

  • Kelley Hawkins (center) smiles at her daughter Carley (left) as her other daughter Chelsea (right) looks on, in their home in Harrisburg, Pa.
    Hide caption
    Kelley Hawkins (center) smiles at her daughter Carley (left) as her other daughter Chelsea (right) looks on, in their home in Harrisburg, Pa.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Kelley (left) and her sister-in-law LaDonna Martin jointly care for Kelley's grandmother AnnaBelle Bowers, who is no longer able to live independently.
    Hide caption
    Kelley (left) and her sister-in-law LaDonna Martin jointly care for Kelley's grandmother AnnaBelle Bowers, who is no longer able to live independently.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Carley, 17, chats with AnnaBelle, whom the family affectionately calls "Snootzie," after returning from lacrosse practice.
    Hide caption
    Carley, 17, chats with AnnaBelle, whom the family affectionately calls "Snootzie," after returning from lacrosse practice.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Kelley meticulously tracks her daughters' activities, her grandmother's medical appointments and her hospital work schedule.
    Hide caption
    Kelley meticulously tracks her daughters' activities, her grandmother's medical appointments and her hospital work schedule.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • The Hawkins family, Chelsea (from left), Kelley, Carley and Scott in front of their home just before Carley leaves for the senior prom. By next year, Kelley and Scott will have two daughters in college.
    Hide caption
    The Hawkins family, Chelsea (from left), Kelley, Carley and Scott in front of their home just before Carley leaves for the senior prom. By next year, Kelley and Scott will have two daughters in college.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR

1 of 5

View slideshow i

Part of the Family Matters series

Middle age is prime time for saving money. From your late 40s through early 60s, you're supposed to squirrel away cash to cope with health care costs in your old age.

But for millions of Americans, middle age also is the time when children are seeking help with higher-education bills, and elderly parents may be needing assistance with daily care.

Scott and Kelley Hawkins, both 46, are in that middle position. As they brace for paying rising college expenses for two daughters in school at once, they know they will have many tough financial decisions to make. "A lot of extra stuff we used to have money for, we don't have the money for" now that the hefty-tuition years are looming, Scott Hawkins said.

The Hawkinses belong to one of three multigenerational families being profiled in NPR's eight-week series, "Family Matters: The Money Squeeze." They already have been paying for their older daughter Chelsea's college costs, and in a few months, they will see their second daughter, Carley, head off to college.

This tuition double whammy comes at a time when the couple also is helping care for AnnaBelle Bowers, Kelley's 87-year-old grandmother. As the generations stack up on each other in one household, the Hawkins family has to set priorities to make education-related expenses fit into the budget.

Share Your Photos, Stories

Do you live in a multigenerational household? Share your candid photos and stories with us on Tumblr or #nprfamilymatters on Twitter and Instagram.

They believe that helping the next generation is a worthwhile investment. "It's very hard because college is very, very expensive," Kelley Hawkins said. "But you just make it work."

The College Board, a nonprofit group, estimates that at a four-year private college, tuition, fees and room and board now average nearly $39,000 per year. For in-state students at public four-year institutions, that annual "sticker price" averages just over $17,000. Scholarships and other forms of assistance can greatly reduce the price.

Still, most students end up having to borrow money to help pay for college. A just-released study by Rutgers University found that 6 in 10 graduates owe an average of $20,000 to pay off their education costs.

All of that debt has rolled up to a total of more than $1 trillion, according to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a federal agency.

Despite its cost, higher education is more valuable than ever as the wage gap between high school graduates and college graduates widens. U.S. Census Bureau data show that the average gap in annual earnings between a high school and college graduate now stands at nearly $27,000.

Nicholas McDonald is a 24-year-old member of another family in the NPR series. He'd like to make money to help his mother, Natasha Shamone-Gilmore, 58, his stepfather, Curtis Gilmore, 63, and his grandfather Franklin Brunson, 81. They all live together in a small home in Maryland, just outside Washington, D.C.

  • Nicholas McDonald, 24, lives in Capitol Heights, Md., with his mother, Natasha Shamone-Gilmore, stepfather, Curtis Gilmore, and grandfather Franklin Brunson.
    Hide caption
    Nicholas McDonald, 24, lives in Capitol Heights, Md., with his mother, Natasha Shamone-Gilmore, stepfather, Curtis Gilmore, and grandfather Franklin Brunson.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Nicholas visits Natasha at the office where she works as an industrial trainer. After witnessing the family struggle financially, Nicholas is looking for a good-paying job to help contribute.
    Hide caption
    Nicholas visits Natasha at the office where she works as an industrial trainer. After witnessing the family struggle financially, Nicholas is looking for a good-paying job to help contribute.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Natasha moved her father, Franklin, 81, into the family home after he developed dementia. "The hardest part is the memory loss," says Nicholas of his grandfather's condition.
    Hide caption
    Natasha moved her father, Franklin, 81, into the family home after he developed dementia. "The hardest part is the memory loss," says Nicholas of his grandfather's condition.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Natasha embraces her husband, Curtis, after Sunday worship at The Sanctuary Baptist church. "I love Curtis," Nicholas says. "He keeps a roof over our heads and keeps us laughing."
    Hide caption
    Natasha embraces her husband, Curtis, after Sunday worship at The Sanctuary Baptist church. "I love Curtis," Nicholas says. "He keeps a roof over our heads and keeps us laughing."
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR
  • Nicholas has briefly abandoned his musical aspirations to enter the workforce and contribute to the family's finances. "I'd like to give my mom $100 every now and then," he says.
    Hide caption
    Nicholas has briefly abandoned his musical aspirations to enter the workforce and contribute to the family's finances. "I'd like to give my mom $100 every now and then," he says.
    Kainaz Amaria/NPR

1 of 5

View slideshow i

But McDonald's training and career plans are still in flux. After running up about $6,000 in student loans at The Art institute of Washington, a for-profit college, he realized too late that such schooling was not right for him. "I didn't agree with the amount of money I was paying," he said. So he dropped out and began pursuing a $16-an-hour construction job.

"Sixteen dollars an hour is something I can contribute with — gas up, get food for the house," he said.

The latest statistics about current college graduates' job prospects suggest McDonald may be wise to stop taking on more student debt to pursue an art education.

The Rutgers study showed that just half of the people who graduated from college between 2006 and 2011 are working full time. So financial planners say students must take a harder look at which degrees are leading to jobs, such as those involving engineering, and which ones — particularly in the arts and humanities — are leading to unemployment lines.

Tim Maurer, a financial adviser in Hunt Valley, Md., says that when making decisions about higher education, you need to "take a look at the value proposition."

Going to an expensive college for a degree that leads to a low-paying job may not be a good financial decision, even though college is, generally speaking, a path to a better living, he says.

"Education is in many ways priceless, but it is not without a price tag," he says. "You need to gauge how much you are willing to pay for your education, based on how much money that is going to help you make in the future."

McDonald says that by giving up on college, he hopes to avoid adding to his family's debt load and begin contributing sooner. He says his goal for now is to keep himself and the older generations living together under one roof — but in a better way. "I want to see my family eating good, not struggling for money," he said. "I want to see us comfortable."

Paying For College

Notes

1. College savings survey poll of 843 parents of at least one child under the age of 18, across income groups and geographic region.
2. Student loan data for 2010-2011 academic year are preliminary.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: