Did The Great Recession Bring Back The 1930s?

Thousands of unemployed people wait outside the State Labor Bureau in New York City to register for federal relief jobs in 1933. i i

hide captionThousands of unemployed people wait outside the State Labor Bureau in New York City to register for federal relief jobs in 1933.

AP
Thousands of unemployed people wait outside the State Labor Bureau in New York City to register for federal relief jobs in 1933.

Thousands of unemployed people wait outside the State Labor Bureau in New York City to register for federal relief jobs in 1933.

AP

The long economic downturn that began in late 2007 came to be known at the Great Recession –- the worst period since the Great Depression of the 1930s.

Even though both events were momentous enough to earn the word "great" as a modifier, they really are not comparable, according to recent research by economist Mark Vaughan, a fellow at the Weidenbaum Center on the Economy at Washington University in St. Louis.

"It's now clear the Great Recession was the worst downturn of our lifetime — the worst since the Great Depression," Vaughan said. "But in terms of human suffering, it pales in magnitude" with the 1930s.

The Great Depression was painful in ways we can scarcely imagine now because we have grown so accustomed to having a government-funded safety net, he said.

For example, the unemployment rate hit a peak of 10 percent in October 2009, but Congress provided those laid-off workers with extended unemployment benefits. As a result, jobless Americans were able to collect up to 99 weeks of government checks to help ride out tough times.

In contrast, the jobless rate shot to 25 percent in the Great Depression and stayed in the double digits for a decade. When the job market first collapsed in 1930, workers could not rely upon unemployment insurance, food stamps, Social Security or other forms of government help, Vaughan noted.

After 1933, "the New Deal started to introduce safety-net programs, but they weren't there in the early 1930s and they weren't on the same scale as today," he said.

Job seekers wait to attend a job fair in the Brooklyn borough of New York City in 2010. i i

hide captionJob seekers wait to attend a job fair in the Brooklyn borough of New York City in 2010.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images
Job seekers wait to attend a job fair in the Brooklyn borough of New York City in 2010.

Job seekers wait to attend a job fair in the Brooklyn borough of New York City in 2010.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

So why do so many people today feel the Great Recession was miserable enough to be in the same ballpark as the Great Depression? In November 2008, for example, TIME magazine's cover inserted Barack Obama's face into a famous photo of Depression-era President Franklin D. Roosevelt.

Vaughan says people may feel the Great Recession was so bad because the recovery has been so slow paced. Today, the unemployment rate remains high at 8.2 percent, economic growth is weak around 2 percent, foreclosures are still going forward, and both consumers and business owners remain very worried about looming problems, such as a financial crisis tied to European debt troubles.

Vaughan says this has been the most painful economic period Americans under 80 can remember. For those who lost both jobs and homes — all while carrying heavy consumer and student debt — this has indeed felt like a depression, which actually has no official definition. But generally, economists say a depression is an event that lasts at least two years and involves a sustained decline of about 10 percent of gross domestic product.

Vaughan has compiled lots of statistics to measure the magnitude of the two great downturns of the past century. He did find some interesting parallels between the Great Depression and the Great Recession.

Here are some similarities:

Both were preceded by good economic times.

- 1921-29: Annual real economic growth was 4.4 percent

- 1982-2007: Annual real economic growth was 3.2 percent

Both were preceded by the movement of banks into new business lines.

- 1920s: Banks ramped up real estate lending/investment banking

- 1990s-2000s: Banks ramped up real estate lending/securitization of mortgages

Both were preceded by innovations in consumer finance.

- 1920s: Installment consumer credit (e.g., monthly payments for autos)

- 2000s: Banks ramped up real estate lending/securitization of mortgages

Both were preceded by asset bubbles.

- 1920s: Florida real estate boom and the stock market

- 1990s-2000s: Residential real estate and the tech-stock boom

Both followed an era in which the Federal Reserve was highly regarded.

But the differences are huge because the Great Depression was much worse. The chart below makes the comparisons.

    Great Depression Great Recession
Photo Length Of Contraction 43 months (August 1929 to March 1933) 18 months (December 2007 to June 2009)
Photo Drop In Industrial Production 51.7 percent 14.9 percent
Photo Rise In Unemployment 19.3 percentage points 5.7 percentage points
Photo Change In Consumer Prices Down 27.2 percent Up 1.5 percent
Photo Number Of Bank Failures 9,000 443
Photo Drop In The Dow Jones Industrial Average 89.2 percent 53.8 percent
  • Great Depression: 43 months (August 1929 to March 1933)
  • Great Recession: 18 months (December 2007 to June 2009)
  • Drop In Industrial Production:
  • Great Depression: 51.7 percent
  • Great Recession: 14.9 percent
  • Rise In Unemployment:
  • Great Depression: 19.3 percentage points
  • Great Recession: 5.7 percentage points
  • Change In Consumer Prices:
  • Great Depression: Down 27.2 percent
  • Great Recession: Up 1.5 percent
  • Number Of Bank Failures:
  • Great Depression: 9,000
  • Great Recession: 443
  • Drop In The Dow Jones Industrial Average:
  • Great Depression: 89.2 percent
  • Great Recession: 53.8 percent
  • Source: Mark Vaughan – Weidenbaum Center fellow

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: