NPR logo

Painting Trump As Temperamental, Clinton Attempts To Flip Gender Stereotype

  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/488666956/488715197" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
Painting Trump As Temperamental, Clinton Attempts To Flip Gender Stereotype

Politics

Painting Trump As Temperamental, Clinton Attempts To Flip Gender Stereotype

Painting Trump As Temperamental, Clinton Attempts To Flip Gender Stereotype

  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/488666956/488715197" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton arrives to speak at a rally in Commerce City, Colo. on Aug. 3. Andrew Harnik/AP hide caption

toggle caption
Andrew Harnik/AP

Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton arrives to speak at a rally in Commerce City, Colo. on Aug. 3.

Andrew Harnik/AP

There is an old stereotype about women in politics, one that was articulated by a man named Mark Rudolph back in 2008 on the Fox News Channel in an interview with Bill O'Reilly.

"You get a woman in the oval office, the most powerful person in the world, what's the downside?" O'Reilly asked.

Rudolph's answer: "You mean beside the PMS and the mood swings, right?"

Moments later he said he was joking. But for women in politics, questions or jokes about temperament are familiar.

Take Geraldine Ferraro, the 1984 Democratic vice presidential nominee and the first woman on a major party ticket.

"I'm capable of leveling with the American public. I am capable of dealing, again, the hard things I'm willing to do," Ferraro said in a documentary about her run. "I don't know if I were not a woman, if I would be judged in the same way in my candidacy, whether or not I would be asked questions like 'Are you strong enough to push the button?'"

In September 1987, Democratic Congresswoman Pat Schroeder ended her short run for president with a sun swept speech to supporters in Denver Colorado. When she announced that she would not be a presidential candidate, the crowd reacted with emotion.

"There was this huge sigh, which really got me," Schroeder recalled.

In that speech nearly 30 years ago, she went on, "We're going to go on to help this great city, this great state and this great country."

That's the moment when her emotion got to her. Her voice broke. She got out a tissue and leaned on her husband who encouraged her to take a moment before she soldiered on.

"I choked for a few minutes and shed a few tears," Schroeder remembered. "And oh my goodness, the end of the world happened. I mean, people were like that's it. That's it. We can never have women. They are just so emotional."

Former U.S. Rep. Patricia Schroeder wipes away tears after announcing she would not seek the 1988 Democratic presidential nomination at a news conference on Sept. 28, 1987, in Denver. Aaron Tomlinson/Associated Press hide caption

toggle caption
Aaron Tomlinson/Associated Press

Former U.S. Rep. Patricia Schroeder wipes away tears after announcing she would not seek the 1988 Democratic presidential nomination at a news conference on Sept. 28, 1987, in Denver.

Aaron Tomlinson/Associated Press

Schroeder is good humored about it now, but back then she started a file, keeping track of every time a man in politics or sports cried and it didn't cause an uproar.

Now, she watches Hillary Clinton's campaign against Donald Trump with some delight as Clinton attempts to flip the script on the idea of the unbalanced, hysterical woman. She's not the volatile one, she says, he is.

In almost every speech, Clinton delivers some variation on this line of attack. Her address at the Democratic National Convention was no different.

"You really think Donald Trump has the temperament to be commander in chief?" Clinton asked the crowd, who responded with an emphatic "no."

"A man you can bait with a tweet is not a man we can trust with nuclear weapons," she went on.

And Clinton isn't the only one hammering home this idea. Leon Panetta, Doug Elmets and Michael Bloomberg did too in their DNC speeches.

"In an unstable world, we cannot afford unstable leadership," Panetta, a former CIA director, told the audience.

Elmets, a Republican and former Reagan staffer, called Trump a "petulant, dangerously unbalanced reality star."

Bloomberg, the former mayor of New York, called Clinton a "sane, competent person with international experience."

A spokeswoman for Donald Trump says his temperament is "phenomenal." Meanwhile, Clinton casts herself as the candidate with a steady hand.

You won't find anyone happier about this role reversal than Pat Schroeder.

"Temperamentally unfit doesn't just fit for women," she said. "Can you imagine if Hillary stood up and gave the same kind of speech, where she spent 90 percent of the time defending herself against anyone who said anything about her. People would say, what is the matter with her?"

But the question is whether the stereotype of the hysterical female candidate is being put to rest in 2016 or whether it's just this particular race and these particular candidates.