Pitchfork's Decade Of Lists

Last week, Pitchfork counted down its Top 200 albums of the 2000s as voted on by the Web site's staff. Lists can be great fun and great frustration, but I'll admit that this is the one decade-ender I've been salivating over. Pitchfork's influence may be exaggerated, but as the site itself has noted, it grew up during this decade, alongside the rise of the MP3, file sharing, and multiple shifts in the dominant sound of whatever "indie rock" might have been at a given point in the last 10 years.

I followed along all week as the site unveiled the list, nodding along with some of the selections (No. 1 should be no surprise to anyone who has read the site regularly), pulling others off the shelf for the first time in years to load them into iTunes. But the real attraction of the event was the chance to take Pitchfork's evaluation of the decade as a moment to chart its own development. Pitchfork has always seemed more obsessed with canonizing indie rock than most Web sites, and what makes this moment particularly useful is the fact that Pitchfork has published Top 20 lists for each year of the decade as that year came to a close, so that the changes in the site — as well as the things it has held fast to — are made stark.

In 2005, I did a story for NPR on how Pitchfork's growing influence, along with that of a new, diffuse network of MP3 blogs, quickly exposed the unsigned band Clap Your Hands Say Yeah to a wider audience — one that would eventually help the band sell a couple hundred thousand copies of its self-released debut record. Following Arcade Fire's rise the year before, this was a turning point. Early in the decade, Pitchfork functioned kind of like an overgrown personal blog rather than a magazine. Its devotion to certain underground acts seemed like quirks of taste; later, they would be seen as gestures toward posterity.

Pitchfork's position as indie kingmaker was cemented at the decade's mid-point, but kings don't always last in indie rock. The twin peaks of the Forkhype range were Arcade Fire's Funeral, which showed up at No. 2 on the decade list, and CYHSY's self-titled debut, which was left off entirely. That binary seems fitting for a Web site that's more emblematic of music in the Internet era than any other: Pitchfork in the 2000s has been the story of how effusive praise can avalanche into a kind of canonization, even as the thrill of discovery sometimes ends in embarrassment and revisionism. Mid-decade was also the time that mainstream hip-hop (led by Kanye West) started regularly showing up in the site's news and reviews sections, and melodic pop and dance music moved from fringe concerns to central tenets (Daft Punk's Discovery, the No. 3 record on the decade list, didn't even make 2001's Top 20).

If Pitchfork were only confirming its taste, it would still be fun to scan the new list for justification and omissions, but that recently flowering diversity (it's not all revisionism; the site employs a larger and more diverse stable of writers than it did 10 years ago) makes new lists irresistible for a nerd like me. I took the end of the site's first full decade in operation as a moment to examine, in a pseudo-scientific way, how it has changed over the last 10 years.

A first glance betrays the little ways in which the decade list updates Pitchfork's prior assessments. Stock in Art Brut and Prefuse 73 has fallen since those bands showed up on year-end lists (Prefuse 73 hit No. 10 in 2001 and No. 6 in 2003, and Art Brut scored the No. 3 album of 2005), and rap makes more of a mark on those Pitchfork staffers who voted in the decade-spanning list than it did in the first half of the decade. (Four albums — by Outkast, Ghostface Killah, Eminem and the Wu-Tang Clan — made the decade list for 2000, vs. zero in the year's original list.)

Perhaps it's just that the site's influence has led to an abundance of caution: Pitchfork seems more hesitant than ever to lend its seal of approval to newcomers. The fact that 2009 only rated three picks in the Top 200 records of the decade doesn't mean this year's albums aren't worthy of esteem — it may reasonably take time for any kind of consensus to jell — but apparently slim pickings in the last two years of the decade (15 albums in the Top 200) stand out in comparison to the albums representing the first two (nearly twice that number in the Top 100 alone).

Burrowing further into the 2000 and 2001 lists — specifically the albums that didn't make it into the decade countdown — hint at how the site has changed. Grandaddy, Crooked Fingers and the Microphones, whispery indie rockers all, fall off the 2000 list, replaced by stoned noise (Boredoms), glitchy house (Luomo) and those four rap albums. How quickly does the site's taste change? Take note: Every single album on the decade list for 2008 showed up — in slightly shuffled order — in that year-end list. Pitchfork may have opened itself to revision, but it takes some time for the ship to turn. If Taylor Swift and Lady Gaga continue to make hits that shape the pop landscape over the next decade, will Fearless or The Fame sneak onto a re-vamped list in ten years?

Below, I've broken Pitchfork's Top 200 of the 2000s down into the decade's respective years, and then paired those lists against the Top 10 lists the site published at the end of each year. (In 2002, the year-end list grew from 20 to 50, so albums that finished 21-50 but showed up on the Best of the 2000s list are included in the year-end lists below.) In each of the broken-down decade lists, I've listed the album's overall finish in the Top 200 countdown in parentheses.

There's a lot of information, and many questions I didn't get to. Do these changes mean Pitchfork is getting safer, or more interesting? Did any change surprise you? How will these lists change in 10 years?

Decade - 2000

1. Radiohead — Kid A (1)
2. Modest Mouse — The Moon & Antarctica (6)
3. Sigur Ros — Agaetis Byrjun (8)
4. The Avalanches - Since I Left You (10) [#3 on 2001 list]
5. Ghostface Killah — Supreme Clientele (11)
6. Outkast — Stankonia (13)
7. Yo La Tengo — And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out (37)
8. Boredoms — Vision Creation Newsun (39)
9. Luomo — Vocalcity (43)
10. D'Angelo — Voodoo (44)
11. Clinic — Internal Wrangler (53)
12. Godspeed You Black Emperor! — Lift Your Skinny Fists... (65)
13. The Clientele — Suburban Light (80)
14. Gas — Pop (85)
15. The New Pornographers — Mass Romantic (91) [#9 on 2001 list]
16. Eminem — The Marshall Mathers LP (119)
17. Ryan Adams — Heartbreaker (122)
18. PJ Harvey - Stories From the City, Stories From the Sea (124)
19. Primal Scream — XTRMNTR (142)
20. Wu-Tang Clan — The W (162)
21. Les Savy Fav — Rome (Written Upside Down) (164)
22. Common — Like Water for Chocolate (169)
23. Bright Eyes — Fevers and Mirrors (170)
24. Broadcast — The Noise Made by People (177)
25. Elliott Smith — Figure 8 (190)

2000 list

1. Radiohead — Kid A
2. Sigur Ros — Agaetis Byrjun
3. Modest Mouse — The Moon & Antarctica
4. Yo La Tengo — And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out
5. Godspeed You Black Emperor! — Lift Your Skinny Fists...
6. Grandaddy — The Sophtware Slump
7. Microphones — It Was Hot, We Stayed in the Water
8. Les Savy Fav — Rome (Written Upside Down)
9. Clinic — Internal Wrangler
10. Smog — Dongs of Sevotion
11. King Biscuit Time — No Style EP
12. Gas — Pop
13. Crooked Fingers — S/T
14. Super Furry Animals — Mwng
15. Enon — Believo!
16. Sleater-Kinney — All Hands on the Bad One
17. Summer Hymns — Voice Brother and Sister
18. Badly Drawn Boy — The Hour of Bewilderbeast
19. Two Lone Swoardsmen — Tiny Reminders
20. Jackie-O Motherf***er — Fig. 5

Decade 2001

1. Daft Punk — Discovery (3)
2. Jay-Z — The Blueprint (5)
3. The Strokes — Is This It (7)
4. The White Stripes — White Blood Cells (12)
5. Fennesz — Endless Summer (26)
6. Basement Jaxx — Rooty (33)
7. Radiohead — Amnesiac (34)
8. Fugazi — The Argument (45)
9. The Microphones — The Glow, Pt. 2 (73)
10. Missy Elliott — Miss E: So Addictive (77)
11. Super Furry Animals (84)
12. Bjork — Vespertine (92)
13. Spoon — Girls Can Tell (96)
14. Dismemberment Plan — Change (97)
15. The Shins — Oh, Inverted World (115)
16. Low — Things We Lost in the Fire (117)
17. The Beta Band — Hot Shots II (118)
18. Ted Leo/Pharmacists — The Tyranny of Distance (120)
19. Life Without Buildings — Any Other City (128)
20. Andrew W.K. — I Get Wet (2001)
21. Cannibal Ox — The Cold Vein (152)
22. Jim O'Rourke — Insiginificance (166)
23. Herbert — Bodily Functions (173)
24. Kompakt VA — Total 3 (175)
25. Stars of the Lid — The Tired Sounds of Stars of the Lid (187)
26. Pulp — We Love Life (194)

2001 list

1. Microphones — The Glow, Pt. 2
2. Fennesz — Endless Summer
3. Avalanches — Since I Left You [#4 on the Decade 2000 list]
4. Unwound — Leaves Turn Inside You
5. Circulatory System — S/T
6. Radiohead — Amnesiac
7. Mum — Yesterday was Dramatic, Today Is OK
8. White Stripes — White Blood Cells
9. New Pornographers — Mass Romantic [#15 on the Decade 2000 list]
10. Prefuse 73 — Vocal Studies + Uprock Narratives
11. Autechre — Confield
12. Mouse on Mars — Idiology
13. Les Savy Fav — Go Forth
14. Dismemberment Plan — Change
15. The Strokes — Is This It
16. Jim O'Rourke — Insignificance
17. Cannibal Ox — The Cold Vein
18. The Beta Band — Hot Shots II
19. Dntel — Life is Full of Possibilities
20. Fugazi — The Argument

Decade 2002

1. Wilco — Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (4)
2. Spoon — Kill The Moonlight (19)
3. Interpol — Turn on the Bright Lights (20)
4. Broken Social Scene — You Forgot It In People (23) [#9 on 2003 list]
5. Boards of Canada — Geogaddi (30)
6. The Streets — Original Pirate Material (36)
7. The Flaming Lips — Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots (67)
8. Sleater-Kinney — One Beat (72)
9. Beck — Sea Change (82)
10. 2 Many DJs — As Heard on Radio Soulwax, Pt. 2 (93)
11. McLusky — Do Dallas (94)
12. ...And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead — Source Tags & Codes (100)
13. Sonic Youth — Murray Street (108)
14. Michael Mayer — Immer (116)
15. The Books — Thought for Food (125)
16. The Notwist — Neon Golden (131)
17. Queens of the Stone Age — Songs for the Deaf (134)
18. Sigur Ros — ( ) (135)
19. Iron & Wine — The Creek Drank the Cradle (137)
20. The Libertines — Up the Bracket (138)
21. Neko Case — Blacklisted (141)
22. Clipse — Lord Willin' (155)
23. The Mountain Goats — Tallahassee (176)
24. Max Tundra — Mastered by Guy at the Exchange (182)
25. Scarface — The Fix (185)

2002 list

1. Interpol — Turn on the Bright Lights
2. Wilco — Yankee Hotel Foxtrot
3. ...And You Will Know Us By the Trail of Dead — Source Tags & Codes
4. The Books — Thought for Food
5. The Flaming Lips — Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
6. Spoon — Kill The Moonlight
7. The Notwist — Neon Golden
8. Boards of Canada — Geogaddi
9. Sonic Youth — Murray Street
10. Liars — They Threw Us All in a Trench and Stuck a Monument on Top
11. El-P — Fantastic Damage
12. Max Tundra — Mastered by Guy at the Exchange
13. Keith Fullerton Whitman — Playthroughs
14. Sleater-Kinney — One Beat
15. Enon — High Society
16. Black Dice — Beaches & Canyons
17. Fennesz/O'Rourke/Rehberg — The Return of FennO'Berg
18. The Streets — Original Pirate Material
19. Deerhoof — Reveille
20. Hot Hot Heat — Make Up The Breakdown
24. McLusky — Do Dallas
25. Neko Case — Blacklisted
29. Sigur Ros — ( )
42. Beck — Sea Change

Decade 2003

1. Yeah Yeah Yeahs — Fever To Tell (24)
2. The Shins — Chutes Too Narrow (46)
3. The Rapture — Echoes (57)
4. Ted Leo — Hearts of Oak (59)
5. Exploding Hearts — Guitar Romantic (60)
6. Dizzee Rascal — Boy in Da Corner (62)
7. Sufjan Stevens — Michigan (70)
8. The White Stripes — Elephant (74)
9. The Wrens — The Meadowlands (88)
10. Jay-Z — The Black Album (90)
11. Cat Power — You Are Free (98)
12. The Postal Service — Give Up (104)
13. Caribou — Up in Flames (106)
14. Broadcast — Haha Sound (121)
15. Four Tet — Rounds (123)
16. Lightning Bolt — Wonderful Rainbow (157)
17. Ricardo Villalobos — Alcachofa (165)
18. Annie — Annimal (167) [#15 on 2004 list]
19. Constantines — Shine a Light (172)
20. M83 — Dead Cities, Red Seas & Lost Ghosts (188)
21. William Basinski — The Disintegration Loops (196)
22. Deerhoof — Apple O' (199)

2003 list

1. The Rapture — Echoes
2. The Books — The Lemon of Pink
3. Sufjan Stevens — Michigan
4. Radiohead — Hail to the Thief*
5. Caribou — Up in Flames
6. Prefuse 73 — One Word Extinguisher
7. The Shins — Chutes Too Narrow
8. M83 — Dead Cities, Red Seas & Lost Ghosts
9. Broken Social Scene — You Forgot It In People [#4 on the Decade 2002 list]
10. The Unicorns — Who Will Cut Our Hair When We're Gone?
11. The Strokes — Room on Fire
12. Dizzee Rascal — Boy in Da Corner
13. Mu — Afro Finger & Gel
14. Exploding Hearts — Guitar Romantic
15. Four Tet — Rounds
16. Deerhoof — Apple O'
17. Jay-Z — The Black Album
18. The Wrens — The Meadowlands
19. Non-Prophets — Hope
20. King Geedorah — Take Me to Your Leader
23. Lightning Bolt — Wonderful Rainbow
26. Ted Leo — Hearts of Oak
29. The Postal Service — Give Up
34. Cat Power — You Are Free
42. Broadcast — Haha Sound

Decade 2004

1. Arcade Fire — Funeral (2)
2. Madvillain — Madvillainy (25)
3. Animal Collective — Sung Tongs (27)
4. Kanye West — The College Dropout (28)
5. Joanna Newsom — The Milk-Eyed Mender (47)
6. Junior Boys — Last Exit (76)
7. Franz Ferdinand — S/T (101)
8. M.I.A./Diplo — Piracy Funds Terrorism Vol. 1 (103)
9. Cam'ron — Purple Haze (114) [#9 on 2005 list]
10. Mastodon — Leviathan (126)
11. The Streets — A Grand Don't Come for Free (129)
12. Fiery Furnaces — Blueberry Boat (145)
13. Erlend Oye — DJ Kicks (148)
14. The Walkmen — Bows and Arrows (151)
15. Ghostface Killah — The Pretty Toney Album (154)
16. The Go! Team — Thunder, Lightning, Strike (171)
17. Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds — Abattoir Blues/Lyre of Orpheus (180)
18. Air — Talkie Walkie (191)
19. Devendra Banhart — Rejoicing in the Hands (193)

2004 List

1. Arcade Fire — Funeral
2. Animal Collective — Sung Tongs
3. The Streets — A Grand Don't Come for Free
4. Fiery Furnaces — Blueberry Boat
5. Brian Wilson — Smile
6. Madvillain — Madvillainy
7. Devendra Banhart — Rejoicing in the Hands
8. The Go! Team — Thunder, Lightning, Strike
9. Ghostface Killah — The Pretty Toney Album
10. Joanna Newsom — The Milk-Eyed Mender
11. Sonic Youth — Sonic Nurse
12. M.I.A./Diplo — Piracy Funds Terrorism Vol. 1
13. Dungen — Ta Det Lugnt
14. Erlend Oye — DJ Kicks
15. Annie — Annimal [#18 on the Decade 2003 list]
16. Dizzee Rascal — Showtime
17. Sufjan Stevens — Seven Swans
18. Kanye West — The College Dropout
19. Bjork — Medulla
20. Air — Talkie Walkie
26. Franz Ferdinand — S/T
28. Junior Boys — Last Exit
30. William Basinski — The Disintegration Loops
40. The Walkmen — Bows and Arrows


Decade 2005

1. Sufjan Stevens — Illinois (16)
2. Kanye West — Late Registration (18)
3. The National — Alligator (40)
4. The Hold Steady — Separation Sunday (48)
5. Antony & the Johnsons — I Am a Bird Now (49)
6. M.I.A. — Arular (54)
7. Animal Collective — Feels (55)
8. Robyn — Robyn (68)
9. Wolf Parade — Apologies to the Queen Mary (89)
10. The Mountain Goats — The Sunset Tree (102)
11. LCD Soundsystem — S/T (113)
12. Sleater-Kinney — The Woods (127)
13. Clipse — We Got It 4 Cheap, Vol. 2 Mixtape (130)
14. The Decemberists — Picaresque (143)
15. My Morning Jacket — Z (146)
16. The New Pornographers — Twin Cinema (150)
17. Bloc Party — Silent Alarm (156)
18. Okkervil River — Black Sheep Boy (174)
19. Lil Wayne — Tha Carter II (178)
20. Andrew Bird - & The Mysterious Production of Eggs (181)
21. Vitalic — OK Cowboy (184)
22. Jamie Lidell — Multiply (189)
23. Art Brut — Bang Bang Rock & Roll (192)
24. Boris — Akuma No Uta (198)

2005 List

1. Sufjan Stevens — Illinois
2. Kanye West — Late Registration
3. Art Brut — Bang Bang Rock & Roll
4. M.I.A. — Arular
5. Antony & The Johnsons — I Am a Bird Now
6. Deerhoof — The Runners Four
7. Animal Collective — Feels
8. LCD Soundsystem — S/T
9. Cam'ron — Purple Haze [#9 on the Decade 2004 list]
10. Wolf Parade — Apologies to the Queen Mary
11. Isolee — We Are Monster
12. The New Pornographers — Twin Cinema
13. Various Artists — Run the Road
14. Vitalic — OK Cowboy
15. Clipse — We Got It 4 Cheap, Vol. 2 Mixtape
16. Love Is All — Nine Times That Same Song [#15 on the Decade 2006 list]
17. The Clientele — Strange Geometry
18. Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
19. Sleater-Kinney — The Woods
20. The Hold Steady — Separation Sunday
24. The Mountain Goats — The Sunset Tree
26. The Decemberists — Picaresque
27. Jamie Lidell — Multiply
33. Bloc Party — Silent Alarm
39. Robyn — Robyn
42. My Morning Jacket — Z
48. Okkervil River — Black Sheep Boy

Decade 2006

1. The Knife — Silent Shout (15)
2. TV on the Radio — Return to Cookie Mountain (31)
3. Phoenix — It's Never Been Like That (38)
4. Clipse — Hell Hath No Fury (52)
5. The Hold Steady — Boys and Girls in America (64)
6. J Dilla — Donuts (66)
7. Liars — Drum's Not Dead (69)
8. Ghostface Killah — Fishscale (75)
9. Justin Timberlake — FutureSex/LoveSounds (79)
10. Hot Chip — The Warning (81)
11. Joanna Newsom — Ys (83)
12. Belle & Sebastian — The Life Pursuit (86)
13. Grizzly Bear — Yellow House (95)
14. Band of Horses — Everything All the Time (109)
15. Love Is All — Nine Times That Same Song (139) [#16 on 2005 list]
16. T.I. — King (147)
17. Destroyer — Destroyer's Rubies (158)
18. Girl Talk — Night Ripper (159)
19. Califone — Roots and Crowns (168)
20. Camera Obscura — Let's Get Out of This Country (179)
21. Arctic Monkeys — Whatever People Say I am, That's What I'm Not (183)
22. The Thermals — The Body, the Blood, the Machine (186)
23. Bonnie "Prince" Billy — The Letting Go (195)
24. Jay Reatard — Blood Visions (200)

2006 List

1. The Knife — Silent Shout
2. TV on the Radio — Return to Cookie Mountain
3. Joanna Newsom — Ys
4. Ghostface Killah — Fishscale
5. The Hold Steady — Boys and Girls in America
6. Liars — Drum's Not Dead
7. Clipse — Hell Hath No Fury
8. Grizzly Bear — Yellow House
9. Boris — Pink
10. Scott Walker — The Drift
11. Junior Boys — So This Is Goodbye
12. Band of Horses — Everything All The Time
13. Phoenix - It's Never Been Like That
14. Tim Hecker — Harmony in Ultraviolet
15. Sunset Rubdown — Shut Up I Am Dreaming
16. Beach House — Beach House
17. The Thermals — The Body, the Blood, the Machine
18. Destroyer — Destroyer's Rubies
19. T.I. — King
20. Man Man — Six Demon Bag
25. Justin Timberlake — FutureSex/LoveSounds
26. Hot Chip — The Warning
27. Califone — Roots and Crowns
30. Belle & Sebastian — The Life Pursuit
34. Girl Talk — Night Ripper
38. J Dilla — Donuts
45. Camera Obscura — Let's Get Out of This Country

Decade 2007

1. Panda Bear — Person Pitch (9)
2. LCD Soundsystem — Sound of Silver (17)
3. Radiohead — In Rainbows (21)
4. M.I.A. — Kala (22)
5. Bon Iver — For Emma, Forever Ago (29)
6. Spoon — Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga (35)
7. Burial — Untrue (41)
8. The Field — From Her We Go Sublime (58)
9. Of Montreal — Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer? (63)
10. Kanye West — Graduation (87)
11. Lil Wayne — Da Drought 3 Mixtape (99)
12. Battles — Mirrored (105)
13. Justice - + (107)
14. The National — Boxer (110)
15. Feist — The Reminder (112)
16. No Age — Wierdo Rippers (136)
17. Tough Alliance — A New Chance (149)
18. Jens Lekman — Night Falls Over Kortedala (153)
19. Deerhunter — Cryptograms (160)
20. Yeasayer — All Hour Cymbals (197)

2007 List

1. Panda Bear — Person Pitch
2. LCD Soundsystem — Sound of Silver
3. M.I.A. — Kala
4. Radiohead — In Rainbows
5. Of Montreal — Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?
6. Animal Collective — Strawberry Jam*
7. Spoon — Ga Ga Ga Ga Ga
8. Battles — Mirrored
9. The Field — From Her We Go Sublime
10. Burial — Untrue
11. Jens Lekman — Night Falls Over Kortedala
12. No Age — Wierdo Rippers
13. Jay-Z — American Gangster
14. Deerhunter — Cryptograms
15. Justice - +
16. Lil Wayne — Da Drought 3 Mixtape
17. The National — Boxer
18. Kanye West — Graduation
19. Feist — The Reminder
20. Liars — Liars
25. Tough Alliance — A New Chance
29. Bon Iver — For Emma, Forever Ago
47. Yeasayer — All Hour Cymbals

Decade 2008

1. Fleet Foxes — S/T (32)
2. Deerhunter — Microcastle (50)
3. Vampire Weekend — S/T (51)
4. Cut Copy — In Ghost Colours (61)
5. Portishead — Third (71)
6. No Age — Nouns (78)
7. M83 — Saturdays=Youth (111)
8. Hercules and Love Affair — S/T (132)
9. Erykah Badu — New Amerykah Part One: 4th World War (133)
10. TV on the Radio — Dear Science (140)
11. Air France — No Way Down (161)
12. DJ /rupture — Uproot (163)

2008 List

1. Fleet Foxes — Sun Giant EP/Fleet Foxes
2. Portishead — Third
3. No Age — Nouns
4. Cut Copy — In Ghost Colours
5. Deerhunter — Microcastle
6. TV on the Radio — Dear Science
7. Vampire Weekend — Vampire Weekend
8. M83 — Saturdays=Youth
9. Hercules and Love Affair — Hercules and Love Affair
10. DJ /rupture — Uproot
11. Lil Wayne — Tha Carter III
12. Lindstrom — Where You Go I Go Too
13. Erykah Badu — New Amerykah Part One: 4th World War
14. Air France — No Way Down
15. Crystal Castles — Crystal Castles
16. Vivian Girls — Vivian Girls
17. F***ed Up — The Chemistry of Common Life
18. The Mae Shi — HLLLYH
19. The Walkmen — You & Me
20. F*** Buttons — Street Horrrsing

2009

1. Animal Collective — Merriweather Post Pavilion (14)
2. Grizzly Bear — Veckatimest (42)
3. Dirty Projectors — Bitte Orca (56)

*Animal Collective and Radiohead each released four albums that charted on year-end lists, but Pitchfork capped the number of appearances by any single band on the decade list at three.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.