The Dagobah System

Knot Theory: Why Everything Tangles

Tangled Lights

They're bound to tangle. From Newtonianism for the Ladies hide caption

itoggle caption From Newtonianism for the Ladies

—Special to the BPP from Summer Ash

On the Mathematics of Christmas

Post-Christmas, actually. Time for all that glitters, sparkles, blinks and sings or dances at the flip of a switch, to be packed away until next year. Time to wonder just how it is that Christmas lights to tie themselves in knots no matter how hard you try to outsmart them.

Each year, you open the box to find a tangled mess, right? And after each Christmas, possessed with renewed determination, you scheme to store them more carefully this year, convinced you have finally come up with a fool-proof system. So maybe you roll each strand in a loop around your elbow and then lay it carefully in a box, or you return each rolled strand to its original box, or perhaps you wrap each one in tissue paper, secure them all with a rubber band, twist tie, or God forbid, even a scrunchy. Then next Christmas rolls around, and you retrieve the box full of lights only to open them and discover a twisted, tangled mess, taunting you.

Good news!...sort of.

You can stop blaming yourself for this frustrating phenomenon as researchers at the University of San Diego have recently concluded that it's a mathematical and physical certainty. Blame the universe instead!

There are a couple reasons for this argument. The first being the Second Law of Thermodynamics (Code name: Entropy). Order tends toward disorder, and your carefully packed strands obey by doing their part. The second and more complicated reason is explained in great detail by UCSD physicists Douglas Smith and Dorian Raymer in their Oct. 16 paper: "Spontaneous Knotting of an Agitated String."

Basically, mathematicians have studied knots forever and developed all sorts of theories and classifications of their variations, but physicists have only recently began to explore what equations govern their formation. To look into this, Smith and Raymer built a very simple experimental apparatus consisting of a clear plastic box and a motor. They put one piece of string in the box at a time and spun it around and around, then took it out and documented its final state — knotted or not. They did this 3,415 times, varying the length of string, rotation speed, number of rotations and size of the box.

Why 3,415 times, you may ask? I quote: "The scientific answer is that 3,415 was around the point where we had statistically compelling results," Smith writes. "The human answer is that 3,415 times was about as much as we could stand."

They concluded that with a minimum length of string (18.124 inches) and sufficient space for the string to shift around in its container, knots formed fairly quickly, often within the first few seconds. Inputting these results into a computer model, they even managed to create a program that could identify the
"Jones polynomial" for each resulting knot, a mathematical property based on parameters such as the number of string crossings.

So think about the length of your Christmas tree lights (undoubtedly more than 18.124 inches), how much space they have to move around in their storage boxes (a fair amount I would presume), and how often they might be jostled when moved to and from their yearly resting place (not exactly a smooth ride up those attic stairs). In all likelihood, a knot has formed while the box is till in your hands. Although I guess you could still blame yourself.

Bonus: An in-depth writeup of this labyrinthine marvel here, with thrill-a-minute video of the spinning knot box.

—Special to the BPP from Summer Ash



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.