Confessions Of An Operaholic

'La Stupenda' Reassessed: Straight Talk From Tim Page On The Late Joan Sutherland

Soprano Joan Sutherland, photographed in 1960. i i

Soprano Joan Sutherland, photographed in 1960. Getty Images hide caption

itoggle caption Getty Images
Soprano Joan Sutherland, photographed in 1960.

Soprano Joan Sutherland, photographed in 1960.

Getty Images

From Enrico Caruso and Maria Callas to Jessye Norman and Renee Fleming, many of the greatest opera singers have sparked some kind of controversy. Soprano superstar Joan Sutherland, who died Oct. 11, was no exception.

I sat down with Tim Page, a Pulitzer Prize-winner for his classical music criticism at the Washington Post, to talk about Sutherland's voice.

Hear Tim Page discuss Joan Sutherland with NPR's Tom Huizenga.

Page's praise is generous. He says there has been no singer who comes close to Sutherland, either before or after her.

"I can't think of anyone I've heard live in my lifetime," Page says, "who combined the strength, agility and the ability to do these amazingly florid, almost super-human soprano turns."

But his criticisms are sharp.

"I couldn't stand the fact that she enunciated as if she were on Novocaine," he says. "You could hardly understand what she was singing most a lot of the time."

Opera fans are notoriously territorial when it comes to their favorite divas. And some of the interview will doubtless ruffle a few partisans in the parterre. Please feel free to tell us your opinions about La Stupenda in the comments section.

Tim Page is a professor of journalism and music at the University of Southern California. His latest book is "Parallel Play."

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.