Are These Music Schools Ranked Right?

The Juilliard School: a top conservatory, no doubt, but is it the best? Depends who you ask. i i

The Juilliard School: a top conservatory, no doubt, but is it the best? Depends who you ask. Michael DiDonna/courtesy of Juilliard hide caption

itoggle caption Michael DiDonna/courtesy of Juilliard
The Juilliard School: a top conservatory, no doubt, but is it the best? Depends who you ask.

The Juilliard School: a top conservatory, no doubt, but is it the best? Depends who you ask.

Michael DiDonna/courtesy of Juilliard

Via a friend's Facebook posting, we saw this ranking of conservatories and music schools around the US.

To be honest, we're not familiar with the site that offers this particular list, and the methodology looks rather sketchy, to say the least. ("Our USCollegeRanking.org ranking methodology is based on our research on an aggregate of other rankings from Times Megazine [sic], Forbes, USNews.com, Princeton Reviews, and other college and school ranking/review websites...")

Nonetheless, this Top 10 got us thinking.

  1. University of Rochester (Eastman School of Music)
  2. Indiana University-Bloomington
  3. University of Michigan-Ann Arbor
  4. The Juilliard School
  5. Curtis Institute of Music
  6. New England Conservatory of Music
  7. Northwestern University
  8. Oberlin College/Oberlin Conservatory
  9. University of Cincinnati
  10. University of Illinois-Urbana/Champaign

One can sense some predilections here: There's a liking for programs that are within or tied to much larger liberal arts institutions, and a bias toward Midwestern schools. But is location everything? We were pretty surprised to see that the people responsible for promoting Eastman — based at the University of Rochester in upstate New York — are quick to point out that they aren't exactly located in one of America's cultural epicenters:

The Eastman School of Music: not in Boston or New York.

Such lists raise more questions for us than answers, and we'd like your input. What differentiates one super-specialized music school from another? Is it the faculty — and access to that faculty? Is it the school's location and links — perceived or real — to other cultural opportunities in that locale? Is it the breadth of the total program? (For example, we're impressed with what we've heard and read about the New England Conservatory's recently established "Entrepreneurial Musicianship" program, which recognizes the 21st century reality that emerging classical musicians can't wait around for fairy godmothers to build their careers for them.) Is it the school's placement rate, the percentage of graduates who go on to full-time professional careers in music?

What do you think? What matters most in pursuing a musical education, if you choose to go the conservatory/music school route? And if you are speaking from rearview mirror experience, what kinds of questions do you wish you'd asked?

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.