Government

Ireland Went Down With Its Banks. Why Didn't That Happen In The U.S.?

Ireland and the U.S. both bailed out their banks during the heat of the financial crisis.

In the U.S., the banks have made a strong comeback, and the government has been paid back for a big chunk of the bailout. In Ireland, the banks have driven the nation to the brink of bankruptcy.

Why the difference?

Irish banks were in much worse shape than U.S. banks, and they were much bigger relative to the overall economy.

This chart shows the astonishing amount of risk that Ireland took on when it guaranteed its banks.

The U.S. isn't on the chart, which is based on EU data. But Jacob Funk Kierkegaard, the Peterson Institute fellow who put the chart together, told me that the U.S. would be somewhere to the left of the U.K. Roughly speaking, the U.S. was on the hook for somewhere around 10 percent of GDP, Kierkegaard said.

"We're not talking about getting even close to Ireland, or, for that matter, close to the U.K.," he said.

What's more, during the boom, home prices rose even more in Ireland than they did in the U.S. So prices also have further to fall, which means more trouble for Irish banks.

It's as if one of the regions in the U.S. where the housing bubble was the craziest — South Florida, say — was a whole country. That's not so implausible; the population of South Florida is actually a bit bigger than the population of Ireland.

Ireland has been able to avoid a bailout until now only because it's a sovereign nation with the implicit backing of the EU, which has made it easier for the country to borrow money.

"If this had been a state government regional bank, they would have gone bust already," Kierkegaard said.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.