Planet Money
 
 

December 3, 2008

Risk Analyst Checks In

Got this from a person who works in risk analysis for a credit card company:

I work for a credit card company, and I see our risk tolerance continuing to tighten, as we continue cutting lines, closing accounts, and reducing contingent liability. The huge injection from the feds has not changed our risk objectives, and now, in the holiday season, we are still cutting lines, quickly.
So are credit markets going to loosen as a result of the injection? No.

Continue reading "Risk Analyst Checks In" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 26, 2008

Fear Or Uncertainty?

description

The patient is still not well.

finance.yahoo.com
 


The fear index charted above (and more properly known as the VIX or Volatility Index) has been at historic heights for over a month now.

The index looks at what the market thinks will happen to the stock market over the next 30 days.

Listen (above) to Bob Whaley who invented the thing, explain what it all means. Fear? Uncertainty? Certain Doom?

Or download here.

comments () | | e-mail

 

The Bailout Is Making Money

At least part of it is. As we noted earlier, the Treasury department is insuring (already very safe) money market mutual funds. Treasury just gave me the numbers. They have pulled in $332 million in insurance premiums, and haven't had to pay anything out.

"We've made money on it so far," says Jennifer Zuccarelli, a spokesperson for the Treasury Department.

As one of you pointed out in the comments section, and as Treasury readily admits, there is a footnote here.

Continue reading "The Bailout Is Making Money" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 25, 2008

Jefferson Warns Us

A friend sent this quote to me today.

I believe that banking institutions are more dangerous to our liberties than standing armies. If the American people ever allow private banks to control the issue of their currency, first by inflation, then by deflation, the banks and corporations that will grow up around the banks will deprive the people of all property until their children wake up homeless on the continent their fathers conquered.
Thomas Jefferson 1802

Now, I think this is a bit of a cheap shot. And it's unfair--I mean, in the 206 years since he said this, banks have contributed way more to US wealth than the bits of trouble they've caused. Jefferson wanted this to be an Agrarian nation. We now know that means a poor nation. I feel like I've always been on Hamilton's side of the Jefferson-Hamilton fights over the future of the US economy. Well, I think I am, I don't really know enough to make such a big statement.

But, hey, it's a great quote and perfect and I just couldn't resist.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Hank: Just Tell Us What You're Doing

Our friend and economist house caller, Simon Johnson (along with Peter Boone and James Kwak), has a great post today on his site with some suggestions for how the government might handle this crisis better.

His post has an awful lot in it. What I like most is the suggestion that the Treasury Department tell us clearly what they are planning to do and why they are planning to do it. What sorts of banks will be rescued without question, which ones don't need full-out rescuing but can get that precious stock injection.

If I were investing in banks, I would have no idea what to think. Do I buy some bank stock with no way of knowing if they might collapse tomorrow or if the government might swoop in and help them up? Or maybe the government will choose some totally different approach all of a sudden?

Continue reading "Hank: Just Tell Us What You're Doing" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 24, 2008

$700 Billion? Try $7.7 Trillion

A lot of listeners have been sending in this from Bloomberg, "U.S. Pledges Top $7.7 Trillion to Ease Frozen Credit." The headline more or less says it all, but what the heck -- here's the intro graph:

The U.S. government is prepared to provide more than $7.76 trillion on behalf of American taxpayers after guaranteeing $306 billion of Citigroup Inc. debt yesterday. The pledges, amounting to half the value of everything produced in the nation last year, are intended to rescue the financial system after the credit markets seized up 15 months ago.

Emphasis mine.

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 20, 2008

They're Testing US

Our friend and Economic House Caller, Simon Johnson, has a disturbing piece on the Wall Street Journal site, about how the financial crisis is far from over. Headline: the U.S. government has no good options but can choose from the least lousy.

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 19, 2008

Deflation: Google Trend

From Google Trends, take a look at the spike in searches for the word "deflation" in recent months.

Meanwhile, the Consumer Price Index plunged a record 1% in October, largely on lower energy costs.

Wall Street analysts were expecting an 0.8 percent decline and it was the biggest drop since the U.S. Labor Department began collecting monthly data in 1947.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Schoolhouse Rock: The Financial Edition

Slate's Big Money website has put together a video explainer for those who want to understand bonds a bit more but don't want to fall asleep. It's done in a Schoolhouse Rock style, which should make sense to anyone over the age of 30.

Am I wrong? Did Generation Y grow up on Schoolhouse Rock too?


comments () | | e-mail

 
November 18, 2008

Financial Regulation: What Could And Should It Look Like?

For those who have been kept up at night wondering what new regulations of the global financial market should and could look like, here's a blog post for you.

We hear a lot about regulation these days. It's a complex topic and everyone seems to have an opinion. Some ideas are just plain noise while others could end up formulating the basis of some of the biggest changes to the global economic system in a half century. At this point, it's impossible to know which is which.

For a start, here are two Brooking Institution reports advocating some basic tenets of what new economic regulations should look like and which institutions and countries should be a part of it.

Take a read. We plan to offer up a bunch of similar posts about possible new financial regulations in the coming weeks. And, of course, feel free to give us some of your thoughts too.

comments () | | e-mail

 

The Evolution Of Hank Paulson

The Washington Post has the first of a two-day series on the evolution of Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson from a free marketeer to one of the most famous market interventionist of the early 21st century.

Among the best tidbits: It was Paulson who first suggested the Securities and Exchange Commission temporarily ban short selling of financial stocks this fall.

Continue reading "The Evolution Of Hank Paulson" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 13, 2008

History vs. Histrionics

Not everyone likes historian Niall Ferguson . I get it. Saying the Harvard prof is a self-promoter is like saying Hank "King Henry" Paulson appears a bit unsure of how to deal with the financial crisis this week. There's understatement and then there's understatement.

Despite that, I'm a fan. One plug: "The War of the World: Twentieth Century Conflict and the Descent of the West" is a really good book.

Here's his historical take on the recent economic downturn in Vanity Fair this month.

Here's another exploring whether the current financial crisis means the global balance of power is shifting for good. In short, it looks at whether the relationship between China and America - ok, a term he annoyingly termed as "Chimerica" several years ago -- is likely to move in China's favor.

Continue reading "History vs. Histrionics" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 12, 2008

Change We Can Believe In

Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson and the Bush Administration are likely in for more criticism that they lack a cohesive plan to deal with the financial crisis. Why? This morning, the Treasury Department said the $700 billion rescue plan would not be used to purchase banks' troubled assets as originally planned.

Yes, banks are going to get some of that cash directly injected to their balance sheets. But Paulson now says a new goal for the program is to support financial markets, which supply consumer credit in such areas as credit card debt, auto loans and student loans.

Mr. Paulson says almost half of the nation's consumer credit is provided through selling securities that are backed by pools of auto loans and other such debt. He said these markets had "for all practical purposes ground to a halt" and needed support.

Continue reading "Change We Can Believe In" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 11, 2008

The Upside To The Downside

Richard Posner, one of most cited legal scholars alive, has a new post on the blog he co-writes with Nobel laureate Gary Becker . It's his take on the silver lining of economic downturns.

On the surface, it reads a bit like an ode to Phil Gramm and his ilk who scoff at our nation of whiners. It's actually more of a plain-old market defense of why it's better to go through the pain now rather than delay it for an inevitable future. He does, however, support a tax increase right now.

Take a look and let us know what you think.

Here's a brief excerpt:

A depression increases the efficiency with which both labor and capital inputs are used by business, because it creates an occasion for reducing slack.One might think that a firm that has slack in good times will have as much incentive to reduce it as it would in bad times; slack (failing to maximize profits) is an opportunity cost, which in economics has the same motivational effect as an out-of-pocket expense. But firms are organizations, and organizations experience agency costs, which are more difficult to control in good times than in bad. If a firm's profits are growing, it is easier for the firm's executives to skim some of the profits, pocketing them in the form of excessive compensation or perquisites, than when the firm is shrinking. In the former case, stockholders will be doing well, so the pressure they exert through the board of directors to minimize the extraction of rents by executives and other employees will be less intense than when the firm is at risk of collapse. When the depression ends, the firm will have lower average costs, though they will drift upwards as the firm re-grows.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Detroit Bailout

Now that an automaker bailout seems to be gathering serious steam in Washington, this seems to be a good time to get all sorts of opinions about whether taxpayers will benefit under a Detroit handout.

It's not easy getting good numbers on wages in the auto industry. University of Michigan professor Mark Perry has tried to come up with some. Here's his estimate of the average hourly compensation for employees at the Big Three, which includes hourly pay plus benefits. GM, Ford and Chrysler: $73.20; Toyota: $48; workers in other industries: $28-47.

Perry believes it's better if we let the market take its course and allow foreign car makers who have an industry price advantage to essentially take control of the global auto market.

Here's a vote for the other side. Their take: the auto industry has such a huge impact on the overall economy due to the large number of actors involved in producing, selling and maintaining a car that there is no other choice but to help the U.S. auto industry get off life support.

comments () | | e-mail

 

How High Will The Dollar Climb?

The long-maligned U.S. dollar has made some of its sharpest gains against foreign currencies in decades as a global economic slowdown is spurring demand for the greenback.

Here's an interesting brief on why it's happening and why a strong dollar is likely here for a while.

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 10, 2008

Stimulus for China

David Purdy sends this, from Bloomberg: "China Stimulus Plan Will Boost Stocks Sentiment." Bloomberg reports:

The stimulus package, of which 100 billion yuan is earmarked for this quarter, will be spent on low-rent housing, roads, railways and airports and infrastructure in rural areas. The funds, equivalent to almost a fifth of China's gross domestic product last year, will be used by the end of 2010, the Beijing-based State Council said yesterday on its web site.

And Ray Tucker sends a vintage Business Week article about reshaping the world financial system from 1998.

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 7, 2008

A Helpful Video From Harvard Business School. We Promise.

This probably says a lot about how boring and nerdy I can be at times, but I watched a recent 90-minute presentation by a number of Harvard economic heavy hitters last night. (It's also available on the school's Web site.)

It's actually fascinating and the panelists kept the discussion in terms all of us can understand. The panel includes Harvard Business School's dean, Jay Light; bankruptcy expert Elizabeth Warren; and Nobel prize winner Robert Merton.

You can watch the whole thing or move around during the talk. Take a look.

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 5, 2008

Goodbye TED Spread?

The closely watched rate at which banks lend money to each other -- known as the London interbank offered rate, or LIBOR -- fell on Wednesday to its lowest level in almost four years, indicating severe strains in the money market continue to ease. That's important for everyone because the LIBOR is the rate used to calculate interest on trillions of dollars of home mortgages, student loans and credit cards.

The interest rate for three-month loans fell to 2.51 percent today, from 4.82 percent on Oct. 10. It's the 16th straight daily decline. The LIBOR hasn't been as low since the failure of Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. on Sept. 15.

Yes, things remain very very scary. But a little good news never hurts....


comments () | | e-mail

 

Bailout Costly For Taxpayers

If the goal is to rescue the banks, the Paulson bailout plan is one of the most expensive ways to go about it.

That's the conclusion of a paper titled "Paulson's Gift" by Luigi Zingales and Peitro Veronesi at the University of Chicago.

They do find one option that would be worse than the current Paulson plan. That would be the plan he originally proposed.

Suffice to say they're not big fans of our treasury secretary.

Continue reading "Bailout Costly For Taxpayers" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
November 3, 2008

AIG Bailout: Working?

Elizabeth sends this, from the Washington Post: "Effectiveness of AIG's $143 Billion Rescue Questioned." The Post reports:

A number of financial experts now fear that the federal government's $143 billion attempt to rescue troubled insurance giant American International Group may not work, and some argue that company shareholders and taxpayers would have been better served by a bankruptcy filing.

And April sends a New York Times piece on the psychology of predicting economic disaster.

Continue reading "AIG Bailout: Working?" »

comments () | | e-mail

 

Manufacturing Takes A Hit

Stocks are starting November on a wobbly note and have been bouncing around all day. The reason for today's peripatetic market performance is newly released manufacturing data for last month.

According to the Institute for Supply Management, its measure of U.S. manufacturing activity fell to its lowest level in 26 years last month as credit conditions tightened and as disruptions remained from Hurricane Ike. The trade group reported that its index of manufacturing activity fell to 38.9 in October from 43.5 in September. It was the weakest reading since September 1982 and well below the 41.5 economists had predicted.

One bit of good news today: constuction spending fell less than expected as continued weakness in residential housing was off set by a stronger than expected performances in the non-residential market.

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 31, 2008

Another Indicator

John sends this link about the Baltic Dry Index. It measures the cost to ship goods around the planet.

Some people like the Baltic Dry Index as a way to measure the real economy because it tells you how much stuff is moving around for delivery, right now, and how much that's costing. You don't have to worry that speculators are driving up the cost of wheat in 2009 or whenever. You just look on there and see what's actually moving.\

We'll try to take a closer look at this next week.

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 30, 2008

Economist House Call--The U.S. House of Reps, that is

Our Economist House Caller, Simon Johnson, paid a call on the U.S. House of Representatives and the Senate today at the Joint Economic Committee.

He summarizes his testimony on his blog.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Bretton Woods 2.0

They created the International Monetary Fund, the World Bank and much of the way business and finance are conducted today. The 44 nations gathered in New Hampshire in 1944 hammered out the Bretton Woods Agreement, a kind of economic constitution for the globe.

The planet's economy looking, um, shaky just now, NPR's Scott Neuman asks whether it's time for a new Bretton Woods. One historian tells him:

"There's a broad sense on the part of the Europeans that the international monetary, financial and trade institutions are stuck -- that they haven't worked properly for some time and in a sense they see this crisis then as an opportunity to address a long-standing set of concerns about how the international economy ought to function."

World leaders are set to start a new summit on the economy in Washington, D.C., on Nov. 15. Few expect anything as sweeping as Bretton Woods to emerge.


comments () | | e-mail

 

Oh, Southwest

Southwest

Pictured at right: the scene this morning at BWI airport, courtesy of those freewheeling Southwest employees.

The funny thing is, Southwest has actually lost money because it had bet fuel prices would stay high.

I note a failure of the free market here also. The coffee shop wanted to charge 40 cents extra for whipped cream. Shouldn't there be an entrepreneur standing outside the door with a can, offering it at 39 cents?


comments () | | e-mail

 
October 27, 2008

IMF Too Small?

When your nation is in economic trouble -- and I mean really big economic trouble -- you call in the cavalry, in the form of the International Monetary Fund. The IMF comes in and loans your nation great heaps of money. Its officials climb around in the national financial records and make lots of recommendations for belt-tightening. The process never sounds like much fun, but if you need help from the IMF, you're not in any position to argue.

Lately, the IMF has been making plans for Iceland, Ukraine and Hungary. Economist Brad Setser, a frequent guest on our podcast, makes the argument today that the IMF isn't big enough to do what's being asked of it. The IMF needs to be lending hundreds of billions, Setser writes:

Continue reading "IMF Too Small?" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 26, 2008

Fear Gadget

VIX

What fear looks like today.

 

Erik Saltwell, who brought you the cool Google gadget so you can track the TED Spread (our favorite barometer of the credit crisis) has done a new one for the VIX, known as the fear index. The VIX is a measure of how volatile people expect the stock market to be over the next 30 days.

Click for it.

Erik is using the National Terror Alert system colors. The gadgets appear Green for "low risk" up to Red for "severe." The VIX is solidly in severe territory right now.

Thanks, Erik!

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 24, 2008

Hedge fund health? See for yourself

Here's a nice, up-to-date table showing how hedge funds are doing.

Yes those funds are secretive, but they need investors. So they talk to places like hedgefund.net which provides the information to the rest of us.

The bottom of the table breaks things out by investment strategy. "Arbitrage" refers to bets that are in theory supposed to make money nomatter what.

As you can see that's not working.

Continue reading "Hedge fund health? See for yourself" »

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 23, 2008

Wall Street's 'California Problem'

Alex Blumberg, who's cranking away at This American Life, send this from the LA Times, about Wall Street's "California problem." Key bit:

California occupies a weird place in the American economy, and American politics, right now. It is the center of the housing crisis that helped cause the financial crisis that will probably tip the presidential election. More than any other state, it gave America subprime lending, no-money-down buying and the booming foreclosure market. Yet the state's economy and specific problems go undiscussed in presidential politics because its votes are already counted for the Democratic Party.

comments () | | e-mail

 

CDS Silliness

I'm always a fan of Portfolio columnist Felix Salmon. He's sharp, he knows his stuff, and isn't afraid to come way out and call a fool a fool.

He's been on a roll lately, taking apart some of the sillier ideas about solving the problems caused by Credit Default Swaps (to understand CDS listen to the great story by our Alex Blumberg in our recent This American Life story).

comments () | | e-mail

 

Crisis Or Smokescreen? Oh, Argentina

 
“Untrustworthy governments can use the crisis as a smokescreen for destructive, self-serving policies that wouldn't normally fly. ”
 
 

News yesterday that Argentina decided to nationalize its private pensions struck me as nuts and troubling.

Leave it to Planet Money friend Simon Johnson (our economic house caller) to explain exactly why this is nuts and troubling.

Short version: untrustworthy governments can use the crisis as a smokescreen for destructive, self-serving policies that wouldn't normally fly.

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 22, 2008

Plan A?

description

Still Plan A

David Kestenbaum/NPR

So whatever happened to Plan A, wherein the government buys those toxic assets?

Peter Cramton at the University of Maryland who has been working on a possible design for the auction to do that says he and his colleagues have been in contact with the government on a daily basis.

Cramton says and as far as he knows, the government still plans to buy up toxic mortgage-backed securities. That's what the rest of the $700 billion is for. (The first $250 billion is going toward shoreing up the banks more directly by buying stock in them.)

"Things are moving very quickly," he said in an email.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Cool Charts

I just got an e-mail from Dave Brown at ChartMechanic, who made a nice display of our favorite financial indicator, the Ted Spread. Check it out here.

He also created one for the VIX, known as the "Fear Index" -- which measures market anxiety about how much stock prices might jump.

Right now these are just updated daily. But they're very user friendly.

Full explanations of the fear index here and Ted Spread here.

comments () | | e-mail

 
October 21, 2008

Don't Call It Socialism

NPR friend Wright Bryan sends this from the New York Times, Inside Socialist Party Headquarters. Wright notes that we've been hearing a lot lately about socialism, from the presidential race to the Wall Street bailout.

Capital-S Socialists would like to object in particular to the idea that having the government buy into banks is a socialist move. From the Times:

"It doesn't make any sense," said Zelig Stern, a taxi driver and the secretary of the party's New York chapter. "Corporate socialism can't exist -- it's a contradiction in terms."

comments () | | e-mail

 

How To: 'Socialized Banking'

From The Big Money comes a prescription for American banks, now that the federal government is taking an ownership stake in so many. Edward Hadas writes:

[G]o slow on innovation. A new pharmaceutical can't be sold until it is demonstrated to be both safe and effective. New financial products should be put through roughly similar paces -- consideration of the possible economic advantage, analysis of what could go wrong, small trials to see whether the theoretical analysis works in the real world.

Anyone else have a hard time imagining Wall Street really, truly slowing down for that?

comments () | | e-mail

 

Caterpillar Down

caterpillar

Not so much.

Seth Perlman/AP Photo
 

It's as good an indicator as any.

Caterpillar Inc. said its profits fell 6.4% last quarter. The construction equipment manufacturer said it expects much of the developed world will be in recession next year.

As we mentioned earlier, Caterpillar, like many companies, was having a hard time getting cash during the credit crisis.

comments () | | e-mail

 

Credit Front Lines Report

 
“This is not the heart of finance beating again, this is a massive shock to the heart to try to get it beating. And it didn't work. ”
 
 

Will Aston-Reese, one of our two favorite credit market traders and frequent Planet Money guest (as well as All Things Considered guest) sent me a note this morning critiquing the positive news in a New York Times story. Translation follows.

I'm sure that you have both seen the NY Times by now. I had a message waiting for me this AM from a MM [Money Market] customer who told me that a stealth lender hit several very large Yankee banks late yesterday. The total was in the billions and the term was in the 3-4 months. I believe that this is more of the same, i.e., a "Bailout bank" lending to try to unfreeze the markets.
That fact aside, we have seen no spillover this AM in selling. Bids are creeping up and money is nowhere to be seen.
As for the Times article, despite the reports of money flows out there, I am not seeing the change in sentiment that Mr. Miller purports to see.

In normal times (in other words, before September 15th of this year), Will and his coworkers at Tradition Asiel Securities played an essential role in the global economy. When large banks need to borrow money for a few days or a few months, they would call Will and ask him to find someone to lend them a billion or two.

Continue reading "Credit Front Lines Report" »

comments () | |