How Much Do You Tell?
“How do you balance the need to talk about what is happening to you with the tears of a close friend when you tell him or her the truth? There's no simple answer.”
Honesty is the best policy. Isn't that what we're taught from childhood? OK, so the whole story about George Washington and the cherry tree was a lie, but it's the thought that counts. I've written before about the whole issue of honesty and many of you have commented about it, too. How much do you tell? Should you tell everything? Can people — to quote Jack Nicholson in A Few Good Men — "handle the truth?"
Here's what a woman named Cherie wrote in to say:
"I have stage four colorectal cancer with liver mets. This is a strange journey, one I am not entirely sure I can share with my loved ones. I am scared it might rob them of the hope I see in their eyes. The hope which I sometimes don't believe in."
For those of you who may not know the jargon of cancer, a little bit of translation: Stage four is the worst, last stage of cancer. "Mets" is short for metastasized, meaning that the cancer has spread — in Cherie's case, to her liver. I'm a stage four, too, with lung and brain mets, although the brain tumor was cut out. The doctors thought I had a liver met, too, but it turned out that whatever it was that they saw, it wasn't a tumor.
Not that it matters much. When I was first told I had five tumors in my lungs, I was devastated. But then one of my doctors explained that, one tumor or five, there really isn't that much difference. Chemo will attack them all. I guess having cancer is like the old line that you can't be a little bit pregnant. You can't have a little cancer — either you do or you don't.
But Cherie's main point is that she doesn't want to let the truth rob her friends of their hope. I agree completely. I learned that lesson early on, when I told too many people what my early prognoses were. I stopped doing that. It's important that they have hope.
But what about hope for the patient? Not talking about it and keeping it all inside — or at least a lot of it — can make you pretty lonely. How do you balance the need to talk about what is happening to you with the tears of a close friend when you tell him or her the truth? There's no simple answer.
I guess it's up to us to try to decide as best we can. Jack Nicholson may have been right, but those of us with cancer were never asked whether we could handle the truth.
7:03 AM ET | 07-26-2006 | permalink

