The NPR News Blog
 
 

Research Finds Many Blacks Earn Less than Parents Did

A trio of new reports about the economic mobility of Americans is encouraging in some ways but disquieting in others: Two out of three Americans have higher incomes than their parents, and 50 percent of that group is upwardly mobile, meaning that they have moved up at least one rung on the economic ladder from their parents.

But the studies released today as part of the Economic Mobility Project from the Pew Charitable Trust also found that nearly half of the children born to middle-class black families in the late 1960s fell down the ladder. Forty-five percent of black children whose parents were in an income bracket with median earnings of $55,600, adjusted for inflation, in 1968 are now in the lowest fifth of wage earners.

The reports, written by Julia B. Isaacs, a researcher at the Brookings Institution, used data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics, which followed 2,367 people from across the country, including 730 African-Americans, since 1968.

A summary of key findings for the three reports states, "In every income group, blacks are less likely than whites to surpass their parents' family income and more likely to fall down the economic ladder."

The reports don't offer any reasons for the disparity (that will be looked at more closely in the project's next series of studies), but Isaacs did offer some theories based on other studies to The Wall Street Journal: Black parents have fewer assets, like houses or stocks, to pass on to their children, and marriage rates are lower for blacks than whites, so black children are more likely to grow up to be single parents. A third possibility is that more black women were working 30 years ago than white women, so whites have benefited more economically from women entering the workforce.

 

Comments (Send a comment)

Unfortunately this society doesn't care about the blacks. All we care about is locking them up.
And now we are to busy killing people for oil and telling other countries what to do.

Sent by skm | 6:05 PM ET | 11-13-2007

Being the only white person in a household of Japanese Americans and Puerto Ricans I can tell you with all certainty that prejudice and discrimination is alive and well,and shockers I reside in Connecticut.It covers employment,housing and medical care.I'm not speaking of handouts-simply being listened to in an equal and humane manner without dismissal.I find unless you live it you claim a certain protected ignorance.I did until my rose-colred glasses were forcibly removed.......countless times.

Sent by Susan MacDonald | 8:20 AM ET | 11-14-2007

I often listen to NPR as I drive into work each day and I always say to myself that I should write in with my thoughts on various subject matters. However, I have never done so. That changed this morning due to some things that was expressed by your Juan Williams in his discussion on "Redefining what it means to be Black in America". The piece left me with mixed feeling. (If we are into labeling I am the so call middle class "Black American"). Due to limitation of time I will stick to one subject mater that concerned the most, "Blacks no longer see themselves as a single race" and that we should be more defined by class. To this argument I say that if we (I am primary talking about the so call middle class Black Americans) accept that argument then we will CONTINUE to lose our collective bargaining power at the table in the political and economical areas. In fact I will say we will no longer be given a seat at either one of these tables. All of the gains that Black Americans have achieved in America have been done so because of our collectiveness as a people regardless on our social/economic class.
One thing that was abundantly clear in the piece is that it was selective. Your (Juan Williams) and people like Bill Cosby are laying the foundation that will ultimately exclude even the so call middle class Black American from a seat at the table or even an invitation to enter the room. Your noses are so high up the food chain that you cannot or do not wish to consider the possibility. Its easy to attack the least among us that way we do not have to do any self examination or carry a baggage of shame for not doing more to help or lend our fellow Black American (of a low social/economical status) a boot or a bootstrap.

We as Americans, black, white, brown and etc. should know that RAP/HIP HOP is not just limited to the negative impact to Black Americans but to all Americans. And that RAP/HIP HOP is a reflection of the lack of morality that is plaguing our country on all fronts. The American family structure has been and is currently being under minded. RAP/HIP HOP is just one of the tools that is being used to erode moral values.

So, those of us who has the most should look themselves in the mirror and be honest with ourselves. I say that it is the people that have the economic means that is giving us RAP/HIP HOP. Until we are willing to look ourselves in the mirror it will only get worse. Change can only happen if we start at the top (middle class & upper middle class) not the bottom. And with people like your (Juan Williams) and Bill Cosby at the top there will only be further erosion of what we call "Black American". They will have self fulfilled their own argument. And my guess is they will no longer be sitting at the table giving any type of argument because Black American will no longer be a race. And what Dr. King and others like him understood was that RACE will always have a place in America, after all the very fabric of this country was build up on RACE.


Margie Stoney
League City, Texas

Sent by Margie Stoney | 3:00 PM ET | 11-14-2007

As usual, last night's debate ignored the single issue that blocks any real,solution in the Middle East....and in many other places.....ISRAEL.
And right away I'll be branded anit-Semitic...too easy. But, I'm not. I am anti-Israeli lobby...the lobby that lines the pockets of all of our lawmakers and controls much of the media.It is sad that we hold all of the cards to bring about an equitable solution to this problem, but we won't play them. The Jews have not been victims since 1945, but they keep playing that card.

Sent by Gene Allardyce | 7:58 AM ET | 11-16-2007

This isn't a discussion of blacks and whites as much as the ability to improve one's financial status. I suggest the answer is quite simple: rich dad vs. poor dad. Parents who are successful are able to teach their children how to be successful. Parents who are unsuccessful similarly teach their children what they know. Is it surprising that someone who is not able to succeed financially can't educate their children to do so either? These kids are taught from the very beginning very different things about how to view money, handle money, use money, leverage money, manage money. Children do need to learn more than reading, writing, and arithmetic. They also need to learn how to accumulate and manage wealth. (there should be enough bankrupted athletes and musicians to prove this fact.) I don't mean to oversimplfy the issue. I acknowledge there are social factors involved in economic success, but we cannot ingore the importance of financial education.

Sent by Rebecca | 3:27 PM ET | 01-31-2008

African Americans must believe that college and education can be a start to better income. It gives you the opportunity to make more money. If you don't have a degree, go to school at night and get one. Give yourself a raise. Stop being a victim

Sent by Mike | 3:34 PM ET | 01-31-2008

I would like to know if there are characteristics that stood out across A-A and Caucasian families as indicators or predictors of greater or lesser success of the 2nd generation (such as opportunity for home ownership, regions lived in, parenting styles, parents' level of education, etc.

Sent by Florence Saleh | 3:46 PM ET | 01-31-2008

What is "middle class"? - My parents, born in the early 1930's would define it as a family able to afford to buy a home, buy a modest new car, have health insurance that covered the family and after paying all the basic bills, mstill having enough money left over to build a savings retirement. I think most people of their generation defined it that way. So what does that mean for today? - Well, as of Dec of '07 median home selling price was about $220,000 and the mean was about $250,000. In order to buy that median home have a (1) new car, insurance, etc. the household would have to earn more than $70,000. Well, it turns out that about 35% of US households earn $70K or more. So, if only 35% of households can earn enough to buy the top 50% of homes that leaves 65% competing for the bottom half... A true middle class has shrunk for everyone, but surely its been worse for A-A and perhaps Hispanics.

Sent by Juan | 12:42 AM ET | 02-01-2008

Send a Comment

Comments are reviewed and edited by NPR prior to display. All comments will be read, but not all will be posted.







 (privacy policy)

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.



   
   
   
null


 
E-mail this page Print this page
 
 
 
Tom Regan

Tom Regan

Blogger

 
 
 

About Us

This year's election cycle has been one of the most exciting in memory. At the NPR News Blog we'll do our best to bring you interesting, informative -- and controversial -- stories from our own reporters and bloggers, as well as the rest of the best of the Internet and blogosphere. And we hope you'll let us know what you think as well.

Want to learn more? Be sure to read our Frequently Asked Questions and our discussion guidelines.

 
 
Get My Vote promo

Share Your Story

What would it take to get your vote? Share text, audio or video.

 
 

 
 

Search the blog

 
 

Email Tom

If you would like to email Tom privately, please use our contact form.

 
 
 

Browse Topics

Services

Programs