Clinton Camp Circulates Article that Accuses McPeak of Being Anti-Semitic
James Fallows of theAtlantic.com is pretty upset with the Clinton campaign for distributing a piece from the ultra-conservative American Spectator that accuses former Gen. Merrill "Tony" McPeak, of being an anti-Semite, and a drunk.
The magazine makes this anti-Semite allegation because McPeak -- who garnered attention this week for making a comment that seemed to compare President Bill Clinton to Joseph McCarthy (after Clinton made remarks that McPeak felt questioned Barack Obama's patriotism) -- thinks that Israel should withdraw to its 1967 borders. (Which, as his fellow Atlantic blogger Marc Ambinder notes, "if advocating the pre '67 border map makes one an anti-Semite, just about every iteration of the U.S. government since 1967 would qualify."
I doubt that the author of the hit job ever bothered to speak with or interview McPeak. I have done so many times, during and after his days as Air Force chief of staff (which he was during the first Gulf War). People can agree or disagree with McPeak's foreign policy or his record at the Pentagon -- but that's not what we're talking about here. Any attempt to fish out a quote that will banish him as a bigot is exactly as fair and accurate as depicting Bill Clinton as being personally a racist based on his "fairy tale" and "Jesse Jackson" comments around the time of the South Carolina primary. I say this having heard McPeak lay out his views, starting while the Gulf War was underway 17 years ago, about how to maintain general stability, US interests, and Israeli security in the Middle East.
As Fallows notes, it's also highly ironic for anyone associated with the Clinton campaign to circulate anything from the Spectator. In the 90s, the magazine had its anti-everything Clinton "Arkansas Project," largely funded by conservative billionaire Richard Scaife. (Yes, we did mention him earlier post today-- he owns the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review, to which Sen. Clinton gave her comments about Barack Obama and Jeremiah Wright. Christopher Orr of The New Republic wonders if this means that Clinton has joined the vast right-wing conspiracy.)
Shmuel Rosner of Ha'aretz offers an interesting, and calmer view of both the article and of McPeak.
4:21 PM ET | 03-26-2008 | permalink

