The NPR News Blog
 
 

Clinton Trip Official Says Bosnia Was Dangerous

Last night we received the following comment from retired Ambassador Carey Cavanaugh, currently the director of the Patterson School of Diplomacy and International Commerce at the University of Kentucky. In 2000 during the Clinton presidency, he was confirmed by the U.S. Senate as Ambassador/Special Negotiator responsible for conflicts in Eurasia and Co-Chairman of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) Minsk Group. He served both the Clinton and Bush administrations.:

I accompanied the First Lady on this trip while serving as the Director for Southern Europe at the State Department. We had been warned shortly before landing in Bosnia of security concerns on the ground (although I do not recall whether the possible threat was snipers). Mrs. Clinton and her daughter were moved to the C-17's cockpit, it was suggested that staff sit on their flak jackets and our aircraft did conduct a rapid and sharp descent to land at Tuzla Air Base.

On the ground the 1st Armored Division's extraordinary security measures were readily visible, including strategically placed armored vehicles and Apache attack helicopters hovering just above the airfield to ensure our protection. While a greeting ceremony did take place on the tarmac, my recollection is that it was briefer than had been originally planned.

As has been reported, there was a USO component to this visit that included Sheryl Crow and Sinbad (I, in fact, accompanied Sinbad for his performances at forward base camps). To reach the troops at these locations we traveled in a helicopter that flew an evasive zig-zag path just above the trees -- I was told -- to avoid potential ground fire. That, however, had been clearly deemed by the US Army to be insufficient for Sinbad's safety. We were accompanied throughout the day by Apache gunships to deal with any possible anti-aircraft threats or snipers. The flight into Tuzla, the helicopter rides across the wasteland of destroyed villages and farms, the security measures of the US armed forces, and the need to have 1,000s of armed US troops to maintain order would convey to no one a sense that it was particularly safe during Hillary Clinton's visit to Bosnia.

Was it foreign policy? Questions about relative safety have been accompanied by doubts about the significance of such foreign engagement by Senator Clinton. The March 25, 1996 Tuzla visit was part of a much larger program of stops in Germany, Italy, Bosnia, Turkey and Greece. The purpose of this trip was multifaceted, encompassing a wide range of domestic and foreign policy issues. First and foremost the intent was to show support for the US troops serving in Bosnia (and their families who had remained behind in Germany when they were forward deployed), as well as those forces supporting our Bosnia operation from Aviano Air Base in Italy. The stops in Turkey and Greece -- which included meetings with the new political leadership in both nations -- were designed to underscore the importance of US relations with these two key NATO allies in advance of visits by President Demirel, President Stephanopoulos and Prime Minister Simitis to Washington. In Turkey, Clinton also held meetings to show support for pressing women's issues and helped advance a groundbreaking interfaith dialogue among a broad group of religious leaders in Istanbul. Finally, in Olympia, Clinton represented the U.S. at the ceremony lighting the torch that would be used to open the 1996 Atlanta Olympic Games. There should be no doubt that such travel and activities advance the foreign policy interests of the United States.

 

Comments (Send a comment)

Nice try. Video trumps all.

Sent by emily | 12:27 PM ET | 03-26-2008

Yes, this is a very nice, more detailed description of the event.

But, it does not explain Mrs. Clinton's claim, on T.V. and in a "major foreign policy speech" on 3/17, to have literally dodged "sniper fire" (not just the threat) and "run for cover" forgoing any "welcome ceremony."

We have all seen the CBS news footage now and can see for ourselves that her vivid memory was more than a misstatement, it was a lie.

In addition, Mr. Cavanaugh's words do not prove any foreign POLICY experience simply because she took a long diplomatic trip abroad.

(Remember, the White Water investigation was going on at the time, and her trip was often described as a way to distance herself from the troubled White House.)

So, in essence, I don't want anyone who asks me explicitly to "hire [her] for President" to tell lies, canards, whatever, just because she's reached a point of desperation so unappealing that I'm sorry I voted for Bill Clinton. Twice.

She should have told the truth... like she did in her book "Living History."

Well, she told the truth... as far as I know.

Sent by Margie | 12:31 PM ET | 03-26-2008

OK, So here's my question, and it deals with judgment: If this was a dangerous situation that required "1,000s of armed US troops to maintain order" why would you bring your teenage daughter with you? Why would you seemingly risk her life? To me that shows poor judgment.

Also, if this trip was truly "multifaceted, encompassing a wide range of domestic and foreign policy issues," why bring your teenage daughter? I don't bring my kids on the most mundane business trips.

So the Clinton camp is either piling lie on top of lie, or Hillary Clinton has shown extraordinarily poor judgment as a mother and a diplomat.

Sent by davidconnell | 12:32 PM ET | 03-26-2008

From another blogger at Politico.com:

Wednesday's Clinton Strategy: 6 foot threshold - most states have more people under six feet tall than over six feet tall. Hillary is under six feet tall. Barack is over six feet tall. Conclusion: Hillary is more electable.

Thursday's Clinton Strategy: Overweight threshold - most states have more people who are overweight than are in shape. Hillary is overweight. Barack is in shape. Conclusion: Hillary is more electable.

Friday's Clinton Strategy: Bar Exam threshold - most states have more people who have never passed the bar exam than people who have passed the bar exam. Hillary has not passed the bar exam. Barack has passed the bar exam. Conclusion: Hillary is more electable.

Saturday's Clinton Strategy: Gender threshold. Most states have more women than men. Hillary is a woman. Barack is a man. Conclusion: Hillary is more electable.

I'd share some more strategies for next week but there is heavy sniper fire here in the office and we all gotta put our heads downs and run for the doughnuts.

--Ready in VA

Sent by Hillary's grassroots | 1:09 PM ET | 03-26-2008

McCain and the media would have a field day comparing his REAL heroic Vietnam war experience with Clinton's wartime claim of dodging IMAGINARY sniper fire in Bosnia.

I don't want her sleep-deprived at 3 a.m. and misspeaking to Putin, Ahmadinejad, Kim Jong Il...

Sent by For Crying out Loud | 1:30 PM ET | 03-26-2008

Today from Carl Bernstein:

On January 15, 1995, she had just published her book, It Takes a Village, intended to herald a redemptive "come back" after the ravages of health care; Whitewater; the Travel Office firings she had ordered (but denied ordering); the disastrous staffing of the White House by the First Lady, not the President -- all among the egregious errors that had led to the election of the Newt Gingrich Congress in 1994.

On her book tour, she was asked on National Public Radio about the re-emergence of dormant Whitewater questions that week, when the so-called "missing billing records" had been found. Hillary stated with unequivocal certainty that she had consistently made public all the relevant documents related to Whitewater, including "every document we had," to the editors of the New York Times before the newspaper's original Whitewater story ran during Bill Clinton's 1992 presidential campaign.

Even her closest aides -- as in the case of the Bosnian episode18 years later -- could not imagine what possessed her to say such a thing. It was simply not true, as her lawyers and the editors of the Times (like CBS in the latest instance) recognized, leading to huge stories about her latest twisting of the facts...

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/carl-bernstein/hillary-clinton-truth-or_b_93523.html

Sent by Macaca moments | 1:42 PM ET | 03-26-2008

There has to be truthful accounting for any presidential candidate. Obama gave a wonderful accounting about his problem with the Reverend. Once there is a lie, as with Hillary, the trust is gone. Most often, more lies follow.

Sent by Trudy Hoover | 2:12 PM ET | 03-26-2008

Every time I think I can vote for Hillary - with reservations... she speaks. She alone convinces me to give my vote to Obama.

Sent by Kathleen Conner | 2:20 PM ET | 03-26-2008

Obviously this is from a guy who owes his job, and probably his entire career, to the Clintons. What do you expect him to say?

Sent by Long Tall Texan | 2:43 PM ET | 03-26-2008

I believe her now and she did not lie. Exaggeration is OK with me..

Sent by anser azim | 2:56 PM ET | 03-26-2008

There is NO way Bill Clinton would have sent his wife and only daughter into a war zone if there was any chance whatsoever that they could be harmed. There is NO way the US military would have allowed this trip.

Sent by Vinnie | 3:39 PM ET | 04-01-2008

Mr. Cavanaugh is either a total fool or a complete rump swab. On second thought maybe he is a person who is hallucinating -- I hope it is due to some controlled substance. If it is a controlled substance if Mr. Cavanaugh gives up the controlled substance maybe he will make a complete recovery?

Sent by Fred | 4:04 PM ET | 04-01-2008

Send a Comment

Comments are reviewed and edited by NPR prior to display. All comments will be read, but not all will be posted.







 (privacy policy)

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.



   
   
   
null


 
E-mail this page Print this page
 
 
 
Tom Regan

Tom Regan

Blogger

 
 
 

About Us

This year's election cycle has been one of the most exciting in memory. At the NPR News Blog we'll do our best to bring you interesting, informative -- and controversial -- stories from our own reporters and bloggers, as well as the rest of the best of the Internet and blogosphere. And we hope you'll let us know what you think as well.

Want to learn more? Be sure to read our Frequently Asked Questions and our discussion guidelines.

 
 
Get My Vote promo

Share Your Story

What would it take to get your vote? Share text, audio or video.

 
 

 
 

Search the blog

 
 

Email Tom

If you would like to email Tom privately, please use our contact form.

 
 
 

Browse Topics

Services

Programs