Reaction to the Obama Speech - Part Two
Sen. Barack Obama's speech on race and politics in America continues to be much discussed Wednesday morning. While many thought the speech one of the best given by a politician in recent memory, others believe it was nothing more than a shallow attempt to distance himself from the sermons of his former pastor the Rev. Jeremiah Wright.
Eugene Robinson, columnist for the Washington Post, and Joe Klein, columnist for Time magazine, told Michelle Norris on All Things Considered that they felt Obama had been successful in dealing with the political dimension of his speech - his need to explain his relationship to Wright. But Robinson wasn't sure if it would make any difference to his critics. Klein felt that the most affective part of the speech was when Obama talked about his relationship with his grandmother and connected that to the reality of racism in America.
Michael Goldfarb writes at The Weekly Standard: "The controversial speech that would have saved Obama's campaign is here, and it was delivered on the fiftieth anniversary of Brown v. Board of Education by a man who really has transcended race. On that day, Bill Cosby said, "Brown Versus the Board of Education is no longer the white person's problem." He said 'We cannot blame white people.' And he spoke about a culture of accountability as the only path to success for Black America.
"If Obama had said those things, perhaps he would have won 88 percent of the Black vote instead of 90 percent, but he would have laid this whole controversy to rest. Instead, he started the speech with 'we the people.' You can't go any further back in American history than those words. Obama just overturned the whole rationale for his campaign, and I don't think he solved any of the problems that his association with Reverend Wright has exposed."
In an analysis for the Boston Globe, Peter Canellos writes that the speech "had greater weight and specificity than his usual stump speech, and made fewer promises as it wrestled with the legacy of his former pastor and his inflammatory rhetoric."
"But this speech will be remembered as the moment that Obama got a little more down and dirty, and grounded his candidacy in serious mechanics of governance. He tried to take apart the engine and get some grease on his hands rather than just pat the hood. This wasn't the gauzy vision of diversity draped in tapestry metaphors and colored in rainbow hues: It was a nation confronting its sins and overcoming its deeply held fears and prejudices."
The Washington Times editors had little patience for Obama's argument that while Wright's view of race relations in America may be static, he did good works too "such as providing day care, housing for the homeless and prison counseling. Well, so do Louis Farrakhan and Fidel Castro."
"Alas, the discussion now needs to move beyond the rebukes to one about what is tolerable 'free speech' in a presidential campaign and what is "political speech" in the pulpit. If the junior senator from Illinois, who wants to be president, insists on defending Mr. Wright, then the path to 'a more just, more equal, more free, more caring and more prosperous America' will take a lot longer.
"Mr. Obama conceded that he didn't always agree with Mr. Wright. 'Did I strongly disagree with many of his political views? Absolutely,' he said. Then why didn't Mr. Obama walk away from the church?"
Andrew Sullivan of The Daily Dish at theAtlantic.com writes that the reaction to the speech from many conservatives has been an "epiphany of sorts."
"Not that I have changed my mind about the things I wrote in The Conservative Soul. Not that I have stopped believing in limited government, individual freedom, personal responsibility, pragmatic change. But I have come to believe that large swathes of today's conservative movement truly are hateful ...
"I am immensely grateful that McCain is the nominee, because he is a far bigger man than many in the 'conservative' movement today. To read [NRO's ] the Corner today was to be reminded that some are immune to the grace and hope and civility that Reagan summoned at his best; the anger and bitterness is so palpably fueled by fear and racism it really does mark a moment of revelation to me."
Finally, here is a video that shows how a focus group of black and white Americans reacted to Obama's speech. It illustrates, to a degree, the racial split in the reaction to the speech.
8:00 AM ET | 03-19-2008 | permalink

