News & Views
 

Bloggers' Roundtable: Racist Cartoons Reemerge

Here's an issue we'll be discussing on today's bloggers' roundtable (should time permit): racist cartoons from the 1940s that have been circulating on the Web.

Cartoons like this one:

The New York Times has more:

Among the millions of clips on the video-sharing Web site YouTube are 11 racially offensive Warner Brothers cartoons that have not been shown in an authorized release since 1968.

The cartoons, known as the 'Censored 11,' have been unavailable to the public for 40 years.

... These cartoons were controversial when first released; the N.A.A.C.P. unsuccessfully protested "Coal Black" before it was shown in 1943. Richard McIntire, the director of communications for the N.A.A.C.P., wrote in an e-mail message that 'the cartoons are despicable. We encourage the films' owners to maintain them as they are -- that is, locked away in their vaults.'"

What do you think? Should the clips be removed and "locked away in their vaults"? Or are they culturally and historically relevant -- no matter how racially insensitive?

comments | |

 

Comments

View all comments »

Add a Comment

Please note that all comments must adhere to the NPR.org discussion rules and terms of use. See also the Community FAQ.

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.

They should not be locked away. That way the American People can see the true discriminatory view of the company who distribute this garbage. They seem to be the same people hollering "bigot" whenever they hear an African-American protest ill treatment in America

Sent by Don Gray | 2:00 PM ET | 04-30-2008

To MC Curtis' comment, I want to add that while we all all have much to say within reason, this forum is not Jeremiah's, it's Obama's. As Mr. Obama clearly stated in his speech, he could not dare misuse it thus; neither could Hilary, John McCain, or any other politician. We must understand that JW is irrelevant not because he is not a valued member of society but because he is not important to this campaign. People that care about JW should encourage him to step away from the limelight before he is turned a complete buffoon. The NAACP should not follow in that path...we--America of many shades and cultures--all should be Spartans and stay our weapons and let this man's campaign take its destined course.

Sent by Evelyn S. Myrthil | 2:59 PM ET | 04-30-2008

The cartoons should be available at libraries and other research institutions as archival material. To lock these away never to be seen is akin to locking away materials from Nazi Germany, the holocaust and other dark periods in the world. These items can do more good by being made available because they show our historical growth as human beings, or the lack thereof. Should they become syndicated shows on Television? No. Please keep in mind that these cartoons cannot make you a racist. They only fortify those who already are racist. Thanks.

Sent by Maria Gomez | 4:44 PM ET | 04-30-2008

Though they are shameful, the films are pertinent to American history as it relates to Black History in America and should not be locked away. They represent the truth about the misconceptions that was( and still is) held about African Americans. Hiding it won't change the past as a matter of fact concealing such despicable misuses of art might actually perpetuate the negative steroetypes that are still alive and well in 2008. "We have to know our past in order to know our future - Sankofa"
The cartoons should remain in the light..let them circulate. . .justice will prevail at some point...remember it's not what we're called, it's what we answer to.

Sent by Goddess 7 | 4:44 PM ET | 04-30-2008

We need truth...we do not hide our shame...we must remember it...however, on the internet these are probably more used by ridiculous individuals as comedy relief--which sickens me...

Sent by Jake | 11:14 PM ET | 04-30-2008

These cartoons, as deplorable as they may seem to this generation, are as American as the famed apple pie. At the time they were not meant to be demeaning or to be taken as a put down but were meant to be humurous, a diversion from whatever could be concerning the viewer at the time. And, in those days there were many concerns. I have in my posession a book given to me by my parents about 1945 called, "A Treasury of American Folklore". A compilation of stories, songs, poems, braggings, and sayings from Paul Bunyon to jump rope jingles of kids of all generations. Stories of black people about black people and stories by immigrant steel workers of the blast mill towns of a growing industrial Northeast. These stories are told in the vernacular, as closely as could be written, of the people involved in telling the story. Likeweise these cartoons tell a story about the common attitudes of the time and should be preserved as should my book, which has a forward by Carl Sandburg, as a history of the common American people.

Sent by riccar | 8:22 AM ET | 05-01-2008

I agree with everyone that says these should not be locked away. It's apart of our history and it should be preserved or else we'll most surely repeat it. For no matter how many steps forward the country takes there are those who want to take the country backwards.

Racism--Expose it. Stand together against it.

Sent by Thomas B | 8:24 PM ET | 05-01-2008

hi there-

i think that these should be available. i also think that in the interest of healing our nation; true american history should be mandatory for all students in order to claim "educated" status. this to me would be more "culturally and historically relevant" than cartoons.

Sent by focusedpurpose | 5:13 AM ET | 05-02-2008

It's not racism...just bad sterotyping. Let's stop being so sensitive.

Sent by Mike Witter | 11:24 AM ET | 05-05-2008

these cartoons are part of American history which most of us are not quite proud of. It is funny that people like Shawn Hanity (Fox want to be news)gets offended when one expresses that fact: we have done things that we have a hard time explaining to our childrent today. History cannot be locked down or hidden. it can only be judged. I agree let them be out there for their authors to be held accountable.

Sent by Mimi | 6:56 AM ET | 05-11-2008



   
   
   
null


 

SPECIAL PROGRAMMING NOTE

 
 

About 'News & Views'

News & Views is the companion blog of NPR's news magazine show, News & Notes. It extends News & Notes' ongoing conversation about the diversity of the African-American experience. For more information, read our Frequently Asked Questions guide and our Discussion Rules.

 
 

Staff & Bloggers

Tony Cox

Host,
News & Notes

 

Nicole Childers

Executive Producer,
News & Notes

 

Christabel Nsiah-Buadi

Sr. Supv. Producer,
News & Notes

 

Geoffrey Bennett

Producer,
News & Notes

 

Geoffrey Gardner

Web Producer,
News & Notes

 

 
 

Search 'News & Views'

Search for the word(s):
 
 

Browse Topics

Services

Programs