Daily Picture Show

Burrowed In Brooklyn: A Little Ukrainian Beach Town

1 of 15

View slideshow i

Resting on the southern shore of Brooklyn, between Coney Island and Manhattan Beach, is a place known to New York City dwellers as Brighton Beach. To some, though, it's just "Little Odessa."

Photographer Uliana Bazar grew up in Ukraine and had heard of "Little Odessa" during her childhood. The New York community is named after a Ukrainian city on the Black Sea — and today it's a community of mostly Eastern Europeans, many of whom immigrated after 1970.

In 2012, when Bazar was a graduate student at the Corcoran College of Art and Design, she decided to visit the place she'd heard so much about. And then she went back 26 more times.

Initially, she found that people in the tightknit community did not want to be photographed, and it took time to build trust. She said they didn't want to be misrepresented, and many are illegal immigrants who were nervous about being exposed.

But eventually they began to open their homes. First it was a family's personal Easter celebration. Later, a man saw her editing photos in a coffee shop and invited her to visit a Russian sauna. Bazar even met a woman from a Ukrainian village neighboring her grandmother's who offered her a place to stay — a one-room apartment with a single bed, which they shared.

"I think I was attracted to people who could potentially be my relative or my parents' friends," Bazar says.

Even if not literally related to the people in Little Odessa, Bazar said she could still relate — to the idea of being caught between two worlds, to a vibrant immigrant culture, and also to their feeling of homesickness.

"When you remove all of these colors, traditions and vibrancy ... you see people are lonely and isolated," she says.

The "fantasy," as she calls it, is that coming to the United States will mean a better life. Many immigrants don't tell their relatives back home how hard life is, not wanting them to know that they work long hours to send money back home, for example.

In addition to taking the photos, Bazar asked the people she met to write down their feelings about their life in Little Odessa. i i

hide captionIn addition to taking the photos, Bazar asked the people she met to write down their feelings about their life in Little Odessa.

Uliana Bazar
In addition to taking the photos, Bazar asked the people she met to write down their feelings about their life in Little Odessa.

In addition to taking the photos, Bazar asked the people she met to write down their feelings about their life in Little Odessa.

Uliana Bazar
A portion of one letter, written by a woman named Maria, reads, "I think that main beauty of Brighton Beach is the ocean and its shore, when I look at it I forgetting all my sorrows and nostalgia for my homeland." i i

hide captionA portion of one letter, written by a woman named Maria, reads, "I think that main beauty of Brighton Beach is the ocean and its shore, when I look at it I forgetting all my sorrows and nostalgia for my homeland."

Uliana Bazar
A portion of one letter, written by a woman named Maria, reads, "I think that main beauty of Brighton Beach is the ocean and its shore, when I look at it I forgetting all my sorrows and nostalgia for my homeland."

A portion of one letter, written by a woman named Maria, reads, "I think that main beauty of Brighton Beach is the ocean and its shore, when I look at it I forgetting all my sorrows and nostalgia for my homeland."

Uliana Bazar

Bazar says she understands well that feeling of homesickness that is portrayed in so many of her images. And looking through her photos, one of her professors pointed out a trend: "I realized half of my pictures are of single women and isolated," she says. "Maybe it is a reflection of myself?"

As these things often go, you set out to look at other people and end up learning about yourself. Throughout the process, the Little Odessa community received Bazar's work with open arms, just as they had her.

Bazar knows they tried to help her, not as a student doing a project, but as a fellow Ukrainian, far away from home.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: