Daily Picture Show

Blurring The Border To See Two Sides

  • Liliana (Lily) Ramos reaches over her daughter toward her dog, Linda. Lily had heard pets help people deal with difficult situations, so she got the dog after she was ordered to be deported.
    Hide caption
    Liliana (Lily) Ramos reaches over her daughter toward her dog, Linda. Lily had heard pets help people deal with difficult situations, so she got the dog after she was ordered to be deported.
    Dania Maxwell
  • A framed picture of Lily with her two girls at her home in Bend, Ore. Lily left the picture and her kids — Brian, Ashley and Karleen — with a relative when she was deported to Mexico. "No quiero que sufren," she said. "I don't want them to suffer."
    Hide caption
    A framed picture of Lily with her two girls at her home in Bend, Ore. Lily left the picture and her kids — Brian, Ashley and Karleen — with a relative when she was deported to Mexico. "No quiero que sufren," she said. "I don't want them to suffer."
    Dania Maxwell
  • Lily asked her mother, Micaela, to move from Los Angeles to Bend to watch over her three children. Micaela quickly found a job as a hotel maid.
    Hide caption
    Lily asked her mother, Micaela, to move from Los Angeles to Bend to watch over her three children. Micaela quickly found a job as a hotel maid.
    Dania Maxwell
  • In preparation for her deportation, Lily brought her son, Brian, to a vocational training program about 200 miles southeast of Bend.
    Hide caption
    In preparation for her deportation, Lily brought her son, Brian, to a vocational training program about 200 miles southeast of Bend.
    Dania Maxwell
  • After meeting with an immigration officer, Lily has little to say to her friends. "I have to leave the country."
    Hide caption
    After meeting with an immigration officer, Lily has little to say to her friends. "I have to leave the country."
    Dania Maxwell
  • Lily stands on top of a hill near her new home in Tijuana. She feels branded as a deportee by others living in the city. "Estoy marcada," she says. "I am marked."
    Hide caption
    Lily stands on top of a hill near her new home in Tijuana. She feels branded as a deportee by others living in the city. "Estoy marcada," she says. "I am marked."
    Dania Maxwell
  • Amy Thompson and other sheriff's deputies in Phoenix are required to call immigration control when there is suspicion that someone is an illegal immigrant.
    Hide caption
    Amy Thompson and other sheriff's deputies in Phoenix are required to call immigration control when there is suspicion that someone is an illegal immigrant.
    Dania Maxwell
  • In 2010, Arizona passed a law that makes it a crime to be in the U.S. illegally. According to law enforcement agents, if they believe they have "reasonable cause," they are entitled to determine an individual's immigration status.
    Hide caption
    In 2010, Arizona passed a law that makes it a crime to be in the U.S. illegally. According to law enforcement agents, if they believe they have "reasonable cause," they are entitled to determine an individual's immigration status.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Two days before her 11th birthday, Daniela Cruz moved to Phoenix from Mexico with her mother.
    Hide caption
    Two days before her 11th birthday, Daniela Cruz moved to Phoenix from Mexico with her mother.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Francisco Duran scans the street from his window before stepping out to drive his mother to English class. He had just warned his friends on Facebook that a sherriff's deputy was a few blocks from his home on Phoenix's west side.
    Hide caption
    Francisco Duran scans the street from his window before stepping out to drive his mother to English class. He had just warned his friends on Facebook that a sherriff's deputy was a few blocks from his home on Phoenix's west side.
    Dania Maxwell
  • A year after graduating from high school, Francisco became a father to Javier. Between work and his responsibilities as a father, he has had less time for activist causes.
    Hide caption
    A year after graduating from high school, Francisco became a father to Javier. Between work and his responsibilities as a father, he has had less time for activist causes.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Dinner is family time for Sandra (center) and her daughters Isle (left) and Carina Montes. The family relocated to the U.S. from Mexico when Carina was 2 and Isle was just 5 months old. The girls have been in the Phoenix school system since kindergarten — and are two of an estimated 1.7 million illegal youth living in the United States.
    Hide caption
    Dinner is family time for Sandra (center) and her daughters Isle (left) and Carina Montes. The family relocated to the U.S. from Mexico when Carina was 2 and Isle was just 5 months old. The girls have been in the Phoenix school system since kindergarten — and are two of an estimated 1.7 million illegal youth living in the United States.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Victor Arriaga and his family wait inside the Marine Corps recruiting office before he starts boot camp. Victor decided to join the Marines in the hopes that he could help bring his mother back from Mexico. She was deported when he was a freshman in high school.
    Hide caption
    Victor Arriaga and his family wait inside the Marine Corps recruiting office before he starts boot camp. Victor decided to join the Marines in the hopes that he could help bring his mother back from Mexico. She was deported when he was a freshman in high school.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Victor's sister shows her daughter what he will wear when he is a Marine.
    Hide caption
    Victor's sister shows her daughter what he will wear when he is a Marine.
    Dania Maxwell
  • Friends say goodbye to Victor at a party before he leaves for boot camp.
    Hide caption
    Friends say goodbye to Victor at a party before he leaves for boot camp.
    Dania Maxwell
  • "I wanted to visit my mom, but you're not allowed to leave the country while on your leave," Victor says in front of his home in Bonita Springs, Fla.
    Hide caption
    "I wanted to visit my mom, but you're not allowed to leave the country while on your leave," Victor says in front of his home in Bonita Springs, Fla.
    Dania Maxwell

1 of 16

View slideshow i

Growing up in Santa Barbara, Calif., photojournalist Dania Maxwell saw two different sides of life.

"I grew up, I feel, with a lot of privilege," she says. "I was given a house, a home, a family that I love."

But her mother, an immigrant from Argentina, wanted to show her that there was "another side" to her hometown.

They would spend time at Latino community centers — and Maxwell's nanny was an illegal immigrant from El Salvador. Her mother, Maxwell says, "made me think critically about what was happening."

"A lot of people around me immigrated to the U.S. because they wanted something better," she explains — mostly for their children. Maxwell's mother provided her with opportunity but also curiosity, which has been the force behind her ongoing project about immigration and youth in America.

In 2010, she was at Ohio University when Arizona passed a bill requiring immigrants over the age of 14 to register with the government and carry their documents with them at all times. So she headed to Phoenix.

There she met Francisco Duran, a young man who had lived as an illegal immigrant in Phoenix since he was 3 years old. She met Daniela Cruz, who was present at rallies and working to put herself through classes at a community college. She also met sisters Carina and Isle Montes, two active high school students.

They'd all come to the U.S. as young children with their parents; they had gone through the public education system, but were still unsure of the future.

After finishing grad school in Phoenix, Maxwell got an internship in Oregon, where she met Lilian Ramos. The mother of three had applied for political asylum after living in the United States for 21 years. Although all of her children were born with legal status, Ramos was ultimately deported.

Now a photojournalist at the Naples Daily News in Florida, Maxwell recently met Victor Arriaga, a popular high school student at the top of his class who excelled in band and advanced classes. He joined the Marines, partly hoping to improve his chances of bringing his mother — who was deported when he was a freshman — back to the U.S.

"I want people to see the sacrifices and the struggle," she says. "I want audience members to question what might otherwise be perceived as black and white — right and wrong."

Like her mother wanted for her, Maxwell wants viewers to see more than one side.

Editor's Note: Rebecca Sell was an instructor of Maxwell's at Ohio University, but had no involvement in this particular project.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.