It was a mostly party-line vote that rebuked Rep. Joe Wilson (R-SC) on the floor of the House yesterday. But 12 Democrats voted against the resolution, and seven Republicans voted in favor. (Five members, all Democrats, voted present.)
Here are those who broke the mold:
DEMOCRATS VOTING NO (12): Giffords (AZ), Delahunt (MA), Taylor (MS), Hodes (NH), Teague (NM), Arcuri (NY), Hinchey (NY), Maffei (NY), Massa (NY), Kucinich (OH), McDermott (WA), Moore (WI).
REPUBLICANS VOTING YES (7): Flake (AZ), Rohrabacher (CA), Cao (LA), Emerson (MO), Jones (NC), Inglis (SC), Petri (WI).
Wilson's SC GOP colleague voted yes. Congressional Quarterly's Jonathan Allen calls the vote in favor of the resolution a "bold political move" for Rep. Bob Inglis (R-SC), who is already facing four challengers in next June's GOP primary and who claim "he isn't conservative enough" for the district.
UPDATE: An apology. There is a widespread, and legitimate, debate on whether race is a factor, or even the main factor, in the opposition to President Obama. The debate continues in the wake of Joe Wilson's "You lie" outburst on the floor of the House.
Today, in the Political Junkie segment on NPR's Talk of the Nation, there were several callers from South Carolina who weighed in on the motive behind Wilson's comment. One person pointed out that Wilson was one of just a handful of state lawmakers who voted to keep the Confederate symbol as part of the state flag. Another pointed out the dressing down Wilson gave Essie Mae Washington, who is Strom Thurmond's biracial daughter, for raising the issue of Thurmond's parentage. It's beyond my pay grade to ascribe racism to people's motives, and I think too many people do it too freely. I did say, somewhat weakly, that perhaps Wilson's motive was simply to defend Thurmond, for whom he previously worked.
I got a scathing note from someone who called my comment "shallow, ill-informed, ahistorical and just plain uninsightful."
Here is my response.
I was trying to make the argument that everything Wilson has done may not necessarily have to do with race, and I still feel that way. But I can see how my answer was seen as insensitive, and I knew it immediately. And I apologize for it.