On the Stump

McCain at the Urban League

In contrast to the warm words he had for Barack Obama before the NAACP last month, John McCain's speech to the National Urban League conference today opened with a dig at his Democratic rival:

You'll hear from my opponent, Senator Obama, tomorrow, and if there's one thing he always delivers it's a great speech. But I hope you'll listen carefully, because his ideas are not always as impressive as his rhetoric.

After that attention-grabbing start, McCain took up his topic of choice with predominantly African-American crowds: education and economic opportunity. He gave the same speech (almost word for word) that he gave before the NAACP. And I spoke to a few members of the audience who noticed.

The response to the speech was tepid, but the crowd lit up during the Q&A. Questions focused on crime, affirmative action and McCain's views on oil drilling. The "race card" debate of the past 24 hours did not come up.

There were two especially interesting exchanges:

Someone asked him why he voted against a federal holiday for Martin Luther King Jr. in 1983. McCain's answer — "because I was wrong" — got the biggest applause of the day.

And Urban Leage President Marc Morial asked McCain whether as President he would encourage the Justice Department to go after civil rights violations (in cases of police brutality, etc). McCain's response swiped at a recent Bush Administration scandal: "not only that, Marc, I will commit to you that that US Attorneys will be appointed strictly on the basis of qualifications and not political connections."

Also of note, McCain gave a shout-out to Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal, praising him for signing a school choice (voucher) law in that state. Jindal, an Indian-American, has been a prominent contender in the veepstakes rumor mill.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

"Someone asked him why he voted against a federal holiday for Martin Luther King Jr. in 1983. McCain's answer -- "because I was wrong" -- got the biggest applause of the day."

That's an evasion not a real answer. Do not cheer for that. See what he would do in response to a silent crowd. You'd have a much better idea of his character.

Sent by Jody Sol | 2:29 PM | 8-1-2008

People should applaud for people who own up to their mistakes, it helps dispel the 'aura of the untouchable/infallible/noble' that politicians adopt or are given by the voting public. And by seeing a man willingly taking himself down a notch on account of prior blind commitment to anti-federalist ideals (or racism if you wish, I doubt it really)that in turn hindered a legitimate movement to recognize a great American, then kudos for recapitulation and getting humble about it.

Politcal response? Sure, he is after all a politician, but he is still very much human, and we make errors an artform sometimes.


Sent by platonicform | 8:30 PM | 8-1-2008