Vox Politics
 
 

Palin Takes No Prisoners in Debut Speech

Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin took the podium to a huge standing ovation from the Xcel Center crowd -- it must have lasted at least two minutes. And after all the recent talk about Palin's so-called unpreparedness for the customary attack-dog role of the VP nominee, she came out tonight with guns blazing. Her speech covered all the bases -- some of her own life story, John McCain's bio, national security, the economy, and a string of well-delivered one-liners mocking and sometimes savaging the Democratic ticket and the media.

Palin opened with some discussion of her family -- a touchy subject this week as many bloggers and pundits have wondered aloud about her mothering responsibilities. She did not directly discuss her pregnant teenage daughter Bristol, but she did tackle another subject that's generated online interest: her baby son, Trig, who has Down Syndrome. Questions have arisen in some circles about whether Palin can sufficiently parent Trig if she is elected. (As Rudy Giuliani pointed out in his remarks tonight -- and we here at VoxPol offer a hearty 'hear, hear' on this one -- that would never be asked about a male candidate.) Palin took the subject head on -- promising that if she's in the White House she'll make a point of working on behalf of special needs kids like Trig.

Sometimes even the greatest joys bring challenge.


And children with special needs inspire a special love.

To the families of special-needs children all across this country, I have a message: For years, you sought to make America a more welcoming place for your sons and daughters.

I pledge to you that if we are elected, you will have a friend and advocate in the White House.

Palin talked up her own political germination as an "average hockey mom" (joking that the only difference between a pitbull and a hockey mom is lipstick) who "signed up for the PTA because I wanted to make my kids' public education better." She worked her way up, earning a seat on the city council and eventually reaching the mayor's office in her hometown of Wasilla. She described that job with poke at Barack Obama's oft-cited beginnings as a community organizer in Chicago.

I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a "community organizer," except that you have actual responsibilities. I might add that in small towns, we don't quite know what to make of a candidate who lavishes praise on working people when they are listening, and then talks about how bitterly they cling to their religion and guns when those people aren't listening.


We tend to prefer candidates who don't talk about us one way in Scranton and another way in San Francisco.

She then cut straight to dissing the media...

Here's a little news flash for all those reporters and commentators: I'm not going to Washington to seek their good opinion - I'm going to Washington to serve the people of this country. Americans expect us to go to Washington for the right reasons, and not just to mingle with the right people.

Palin touted her credentials as a reform-minded governor of Alaska, firing her predecessor's private chef and selling his luxury jet on eBay.

And then she turned her attention to a weaker area of her resume: foreign policy. She dropped a few overseas energy references like a pro as she pushed for more domestic energy production and an increased focus on renewables:

With Russia wanting to control a vital pipeline in the Caucasus, and to divide and intimidate our European allies by using energy as a weapon, we cannot leave ourselves at the mercy of foreign suppliers.

To confront the threat that Iran might seek to cut off nearly a fifth of world energy supplies ... or that terrorists might strike again at the Abqaiq facility in Saudi Arabia ... or that Venezuela might shut off its oil deliveries ... we Americans need to produce more of our own oil and gas.

And take it from a gal who knows the North Slope of Alaska: we've got lots of both.

Palin then turned her sights directly on Barack Obama, spending the next section of the speech portraying the Democratic nominee -- rather snidely -- as strong on rhetoric but weak on policy.


Listening to him speak, it's easy to forget that this is a man who has authored two memoirs but not a single major law or reform - not even in the state senate.

This is a man who can give an entire speech about the wars America is fighting, and never use the word "victory" except when he's talking about his own campaign. But when the cloud of rhetoric has passed ... when the roar of the crowd fades away ... when the stadium lights go out, and those Styrofoam Greek columns are hauled back to some studio lot - what exactly is our opponent's plan? What does he actually seek to accomplish, after he's done turning back the waters and healing the planet? The answer is to make government bigger ... take more of your money ... give you more orders from Washington ... and to reduce the strength of America in a dangerous world. America needs more energy ... our opponent is against producing it.

She wrapped up with a final push on John McCain's character, telling the story of a fellow-POW from McCain's days in the Hanoi Hilton whose spirits McCain lifted with a signal through a pinhole in the cell door. That man, Tom Moe, was also a member of the Ohio delegation tonight. Moe summoned a huge cheer from the crowd when he stood and saluted after his name was mentioned.

Palin's final note of implicit comparison between McCain and Obama:

For a season, a gifted speaker can inspire with his words.


For a lifetime, John McCain has inspired with his deeds.

The feisty speech left no doubt that Palin doesn't plan to roll over this fall. The rave reception she got from the conservative die-hards in the convention hall doesn't necessarily indicate how she'll do with voters at large, and she still has a long way to go to prove that she's really up to the task of the Vice-Presidency. But tonight's performance suggests that the VP debate between Palin and Joe Biden may be a better show than the chattering classes had anticipated.

-- Evie Stone


comments | |

 

Comments

View all comments »

Add a Comment

Please note that all comments must adhere to the NPR.org discussion rules and terms of use. See also the Community FAQ.

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.

Gov. Palin is anything except a "good mom." She neglected to communicate well with her teenage daughter which resulted in the child seeking love elsewhere and getting pregnant. She is obsessed with her own success and she has neglected her duties as a mother even before becoming the Republican VP nominee. The family needs to be in therapy. Very scary to think of Palin spreading her restrictive values nationally. McCain's judgment in picking her is very poor. Both are not what we need to move forward.

Sent by Linda Moore | 9:47 AM ET | 09-04-2008

So you offer a "hear, hear" to that, do you?

Well, fine - and I too agree that a female candidate shouldn't be judged based on her capacity for motherhood.

Except!

Except when that candidate is touting her motherhood as one of her principle selling points, as this one is. Every glowing review you hear of Palin gushes about how she's this "mother of five" or "hockey mom". One of the things the Republicans are trying to push about her is that she identifies with the issues of working moms. She herself puts her motherhood front and center, her family front and center. But then it's somehow inappropriate when the opposition dares to mention it?

It reminds me of how Laura Bush went on the campaign trail in 2000 talking about how she was such a diligent mother and spent so much time on her children. Which was nonsense - she was out on the campaign trail, which meant her children were in the care of other relatives, babysitters, or whatever. Likewise here. I have no problem with Sarah Palin having a large family as well as a job which requires a lot of time and attention - good for her. But it's disingenuous, cynical, and false to pretend that she can somehow devote as much time to her children as the average American homemaker while also handling the demands of a campaign plus the governorship of a state.

Do you know what "drawing a foul" means? In sports, it means deliberately trying to set your opponent up to foul you. The entire Palin candidacy is an attempt to set up a ticket that can blast the opposition and then, when counterattacked, hide behind a defense of "how could you attack this beautiful mother and her children, you monster!"

What's sad is that you guys at Vox Politics fell for it when you should know better.

Sent by Kasreyn | 10:20 AM ET | 09-04-2008

It was a great speech, if you like snarky, condescension and no substance.

I think it's funny that a convention whose theme is "Country First" and whose underlying theme has been service would make such a crusade of mocking community service, or being a community organizer. What says "country first" more than turning down a high-paying job as a lawyer to help people who have lost their jobs?

Sent by SRB | 11:39 AM ET | 09-04-2008

When will the public and TV/Cable talking heads EVER go beyond the speech delivery styles and actually analyze the CONTENT of Palin's speech- which was nothing but a pack of ugly fear-mongering, half-truths, full lies, insults, hypocrisy (my family can be used as props as and when I need it, but is off-limits for any commentary by the media). When will the pundits EVER talk about the LACK of any policy proposals or discussion of real issues in her speech. Are we that dumb, superficial, and trivial a society - interested in mere fluffy pursuits of speech delivery styles and "Oh, what a cute family" exclamations!

Sent by Ajay | 12:16 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Yes, she gave a feisty speech; but there was no substance. If the GOP is looking to attract women voters, Palin and the entire "in your face" parade of speakers got my ire up. This whole war-mongering, small town family values, media-bashing event was insulting to my intelligence. I, too, worked and raised a family. I, too, live in a small town. But I am not fooled by this smirking, religious right smoke-and-mirrors routine. They do not represent me, and they do not care about what is best for ALL of the citizens of this country.

Sent by Georgia | 12:57 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Palin's speech did NOTHING for me except make me cringe.

Sent by sem | 1:21 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Yes, she did manage to read the teleprompter without much stumbling, but I saw Karl Rove's lips moving the whole time.

Sent by Gary Cooper | 1:54 PM ET | 09-04-2008

For a party that's claiming how they work across party lines this speech was very divisive. The mockery and dismissiveness towards people who are community organizers (aka social workers) makes me think that they see the only way one serves ones country is with a gun.

Sent by RJD | 2:03 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Would someone please explain to me how having been captured in Vietnam makes John McCain a national hero?
All through this campaign, I've heard this chant repeated over and over (even by Democrats), and during the Republican Convention scarcely ten seconds went by without someone making the claim again.

First, America's actions in the Vietnam War were criminally wrongheaded by almost any standard. Many Americans recognized this from the beginning, and most Americans did by the end of the war. The real American heroes of Vietnam were those who openly refused to participate in the war.

Second, given that McCain did choose to fly bombing missions over Vetnam, I can't see anything "heroic" about having been captured. It was certainly an unfortunate experience, and possibly even reflected badly on his competence as a warrior, but since he never volunteered to be taken prisoner, and presumably would have avoided it if he could, it cannot qualify as an act of heroism, any more than getting mugged on my way home from work makes me a hero.

On the other hand, Barack Obama did choose freely to use his Ivy-League education to help the poor and the powerless instead of enriching himself. He distinguished himself in a job, community organizing, that is much more difficult and demanding than holding public office. This, in my book, is the biography of a real citizen hero.

Sent by Gary Cooper | 2:14 PM ET | 09-04-2008

I live in the same borough in Alaska that Sarah Palin calls home. I worked in Wasilla during the time when Sarah began her political career with the local city government. I do not know her personally; however I've watched her handle each office she has held. As soon as she took on the role of Mayor of Wasilla I recognized a woman who would likely become a leader in the political world. I did not vote for her as governor of Alaska because I felt she wasn't yet ready for that job. After watching her in action for these past several years, I admit that I'm not happy with every decision she has made and vehemently oppose a couple of them. However, she has earned my respect. She isn't afraid to stand up for what she believes in-even when that stance is not with the "party" platform. She knows how to build and to use a team of strong players. What she lacks in true experience she makes up for in energy, commitment and a drive to learn about the issue at hand. Yes, she is scrappy. Isn't that what we want in our leaders? Don't attack her as a mother and a leader if you are not willing to also attack Barack Obama for "abandoning" his young children in his career in Washington thus far. She may not have all the credentials we want to see for the VP, but she has more experience as an administrator than anyone on the Democratic ticket. She is not perfect, but she is very good. I would much rather have a vice president with limited administrative experience over a Commander in Chief who has yet to accomplish anything of national interest other than a few good speeches and a couple of books about his family.

Sent by V Kluever | 2:42 PM ET | 09-04-2008

New joke for Dems out there:

Q: How can you tell when Karl Rove is lying?

A: When Sarah Palin's lips are moving!

You're welcome.

Sent by Kasreyn | 3:12 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Sarah Palin, takes no prisoners...John McCain, POW...I guess that means if the VietCong were as ruthless as she is, McCain would be dead...maybe that should tell us something about being ruthless, and whether we should vote for people who are...

Sent by Matt MC | 3:13 PM ET | 09-04-2008

How about not going back and forth about who is better, more prettier, scrappier, more family involved or qualified and start putting more emphasis on what they are going to do once in office. What is said to win votes and what is actually done once in office are two different things and it never fails that we elect someone to office that fails to deliver a good portion of the time. So good speech or not, lets start to ask the right questions from our candadites and demand the best for the whole country, not a particular party or social/economic class. Lets not get caught up in the speech and forget about what it is we want from our elected officials. Because in the end its the vote that counts and the votes will be counted electing someone who will run this country, not just a portion. United whether we like it or not.

Sent by J. San Antonio | 3:50 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Whoever wrote her speech certainly did a wonderful job on making her look good. Her wit and theatrics made the speech an overwhelming success. However, the proof will be in the days to come. I think she is just a bunch of hot air and no substance. Much of the same.

Sent by sung | 4:15 PM ET | 09-04-2008

When the Republicans sneer and mock Senator Obama for his community service work in poor neighborhoods in Chicago at the same time they are waving signs that read, "Service" and "Country First", they provide all Americans with a perfect example of hypocrisy. The notion of the GOP as the party of selfless giving for the common good was laughable even before the disdain-filled speeches by Mr. Giuliani and Governor Palin on Wednesday. Now it's clear that their platitudes about service and altruism are as vacuous as their plan for reinvigorating America.

Sent by T K Madison | 4:26 PM ET | 09-04-2008

If Palin is so fearless why is she avoiding a press conference?

Sent by mike Fleissner | 9:16 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Sarah Palin is the red-headed bully who threatens Ralfie and his little brother, Randy, on the way home from school every day. Like the infamous "A Christmas Story" bully, Sarah Palin is an outsider. That's why she's a bully. She doesn't have the mettle to work from the inside to build concensus, bring people together and create unity. Like George Bush, Sarah Palin is unqualified for the job, condescending, divisive and deceitful. If anyone thinks women with even half a brain will be persuaded to the dark side by a self-proclaimed pitbull like Sarah Palin, think again. Most of us are working to have pitbulls banished from our communities!

Sent by AMM | 10:55 PM ET | 09-04-2008

Most of you,must have not collected the $700 rebate that Bush just gave us or maybe 1 of 5 million people who came out to collect $ after not paying taxes for 5 years. Were you aware that Borack Hussein Obama doesn't even help his brother in Africa who only make $1/month, how can he help our country? Bush helped protect our country with the Patriot Act which has helped us catch over 100 terrorists & prevented over 30 attacks on our country! Clinton refused to kill or capture Bin Ladin after 2 attacks on the US in 1998, cut our military in half while Pres. & closed half the bases in this country! Cindy McCain helped Mother Theresa & even adopted a girl from her orphanage to help her better her life! John McCain defended our country & was tortured to keep from giving secrets to Vietnam! Borack hasn't even voted half the time hile in the Senate which he was elected to do while a Senator!

Sent by Gloria Alvarado | 3:16 AM ET | 09-05-2008



   
   
   
null


 
Evie Stone

Evie Stone

Blogger

 
Michael Olson

Michael Olson

Blogger

 
Thomas Pierce

Thomas Pierce

Blogger

 
Sean Bowditch

Sean Bowditch

Blogger

 
 
 

About Vox Politics

NPR's producers, reporters and editors follow the latest developments on the campaign trail. For more information, please visit our discussion guidelines.

 
 

Political Rewind

Politcal Rewind podcast icon.Listen to the best political stories of the last few days in one podcast, including the latest from the battleground states and analysis from NPR.



» Get the Podcast

 
 

NPR Politics on Twitter

    Subscribe to nprpolitics on Twitter
     
     

    Search 'Vox Politics'

    Search for the word(s):
     
    Patchwork Nation
     

    Contact Us


    If you'd like to contact Vox Politics privately, please use our contact form.

     
     
     

    Related News Feeds

     
     

    Browse Topics

    Services

    Programs