Agents and Reporters

Listen to this 'Talk of the Nation' topic

The relationship between the FBI and the media is, at times, a lot like most daughters' relationships with their mothers — you know you need each other, but that doesn't stop confrontation from rearing its ugly head every now and again (more now than again, let's be real).

The FBI's job is to catch criminals, whereas the media has a responsibility to inform the public. And, sometimes, these differing agendas can stand at odds with one another. Take the DC Sniper case in 2002, when a reporter released the suspect's license plate number against the FBI's wishes who feared it would hamper ongoing investigations... In the end, a bystander recognized the license plate and called the police, which led to the arrest of two suspects. At other times, the relationship poses ethical dilemmas, as when the FBI pressed The Washington Post to publish the Unabomber's anti-technology manifesto. After much debate, the Post printed it, and as a result, Ted Kaczynski's brother turned him in.

And, as it happens, these are just two examples of the infamous cases now on display at the Newseum's new exhibit, "G-Men and Journalists: Top News Stories of the FBI's First Century." I walked through it yesterday, and to say it's cool would be an understatement. They've got 200 artifacts, including Patty Hearst's gun, Hoover's desk from his days at the FBI, and the Unabomber's actual cabin (!!!). Plus, there's over 300 photographs, and dozens of historic newspapers and interactive displays about everything from the Oklahoma City bombing and the Lindbergh kidnapping to the siege at Waco, Texas.

Today we'll talk to John Miller, who's been on both sides of the fence — first as an ABC News reporter and anchor, and now as Assistant Director of Public Affairs for the FBI. And we'll also talk to NPR's FBI correspondent, Dina Temple-Raston, about covering the FBI, and how she decides what to report and what to leave out.

So, tell us, is the relationship between the media and the FBI too close, or too confrontational? We'd especially like to here from those of you with experience on either side.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

HOW the news is presented is often more important than WHAT is presented.
Grabbing headlines (or ratings), while being timely (but "less than accurate") can lead to someone getting away or (worse) cause innocent people to be put in jail.

For those "professional journalists", I have to say that I have come to trust their judgement on these matters of public safety.
For the Tabloid-types, they should be sued over the panic they cause.

Sent by Harold | 3:18 PM | 6-25-2008

Question for Miller

Have you ever been tempted to find the answer to a question you were unable to answer as a reporter?

Sent by Colin | 3:29 PM | 6-25-2008

Does the museum exhibit contain any FBI fashion items, e.g. agents' regulation white shirt and dark suit, or any of J.Edgar Hoover's party dresses ?

Sent by Clyde T. | 3:30 PM | 6-25-2008

Support comes from: