In Defense of Cucumber Sandwiches... Kinda

Last weekend my roommate and I planned to go to the Mount Pleasant farmers market here in Washington, buy lunch ingredients and then have a picnic in Meridian Hill Park. Unfortunately, it was almost too hot to shop out doors, never mind eat outside. So instead we resigned to have a "bourgeoisie picnic" -- that is, an air-conditioned picnic -- in our living room complete with cucumber sandwiches, lemonade and prosecco. Why do I bring this up? Because it has absolutely nothing to do with the topic of today's oped. Well almost nothing. Our little "bourgeoisie picnic" WAS the image that popped into my head when I began to think about elitism all of ten minutes ago, but after reading through Mark Swed's article for the LA Times, it's quite obvious that my weekend lunch was haughty at best, but really a far cry from elite.
Rather, elitism is just a way to categorize "the best" and not only has it got a bad rep, says Mark Swed, but we should use the word more... what do you think... when is categorizing "the best" helpful... and when is it not?

1:58 PM ET | 07-28-2008 | permalink

 

Comments (Send a comment)

Elite and elitism are distinctly differetn terms, and the distinction is important. To be among the elite is to the best, while elitism traditionally means rule by the elite, or a belief in the power of the elite. One may be elite and not be an elitist. Humility is a blessing.

Sent by Scott | 7:18 PM ET | 07-28-2008

The problem is, the word elite has more than one connotation. Republicans fear the word, because they ARE the elite. They are just a cut above the others, because they have more, and therefore deserve more.

It's possible the person who thinks he has joined the elite is a Wal-Mart manager, and can buy a nice-looking house. He can be decieved into thinking he has interests in common with multimillionaires, who are getting million-dollar tax breaks. He gets his few thousand in a tax break, and thinks he is the one they are talking about.

Fearful that the voting public will see elitism in their motives, they project elitism on democrats. They aren't elite because they're richer, they think they're elite because they're so smart.

Most voters don't have a college degree, so they might resent a person who thinks he knows so much. John Kerry is well-spoken, so he might think he knows better than the rest of us, and may just be eating caviar and listening to an opera when we aren't looking.

Yeah, that's it. Call a lot of college-educated democrats elitists, and they won't be looking so much at us country-club types, who have in common little but a bank account. Get 'em!

Sent by Gene Douglas | 8:54 PM ET | 07-28-2008

I strongly beieive the word 'elitist' as assigned to Barrack Obama is at it's core, a code word for 'upity'. How else can you explain this tag being leveled by affluent powerful white men in america. Who themselves clearly fit the definition.

Sent by Randy Cousar | 9:03 PM ET | 07-28-2008

What about delicious burritos in Meridian Hill Park?

Sent by Ryan T. Swamp | 8:43 AM ET | 07-29-2008

Send a Comment

Comments are reviewed and edited by NPR prior to display. All comments will be read, but not all will be posted.







 (privacy policy)

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.



   
   
   
null


 
E-mail this page Print this page
 
 
 

Bloggers

Neal Conan

Neal Conan

Host,
Talk of the Nation

 

Scott Cameron

Scott Cameron

Editor,
Talk of the Nation

 

Sarah Handel

Sarah Handel

Associate Producer,
Talk of the Nation

 

Barrie Hardymon

Barrie Hardymon

Assistant Editor,
Talk of the Nation

 

 
 
Get My Vote promo

Share Your Story

What would it take to get your vote? Share text, audio or video.

 
 

 
 

About Blog of the Nation

Blog of the Nation is the official blog of the NPR talk show Talk of the Nation. For more information about the blog, the show and everything else in between, please be sure to read our show's Frequently Asked Questions guide and the discussion rules.

 
 

Related News Feeds

 
 

Contact Us:

Want to contact us privately? Write us!

 
 
 

Search the Blog


 
 

Browse Topics

Services

Programs