Insane or Just Plain Nuts
It is by far one of the most unpleasant stories out there. A man in Austria commits the worst kind of child abuse -- and then takes it into another stratosphere of evil by keeping his children and grandchildren (all of whom he fathered) in a basement for years. It's a horrible, horrible story -- and my informal survey of friends and compatriots has found either people can't read about it at all -- or they just want to know what breach of hell created this man's particular brand of evil. Austrian courts however, have a different set of questions -- namely, is Josef Fritzl legally insane? One argument says he wouldn't have kept the kids hidden away if he didn't know what he was doing was wrong. Insane is legal term -- not a medical one. (And meshuggeneh is merely a descriptor, if you're curious.) The insanity defense is invoked in Law and Order and CSI a lot -- but it differs from state to state, country to country, and court to court. Insanity Famous defendants that have pleaded insanity range from Zacarias Moussaoui to D.C. sniper Lee Boyd Malvo. Even Reagan's would-be assassin, John Hinckley Jr., used the insanity defense -- and the court found him not guilty back in 1982. Today -- we're talking about Insane vs. Crazy: questions? Post 'em here.
Barrie Hardymon
1:59 PM ET
|
05- 6-2008
|
permalink
|
comments (16)
|
e-mail post
When an Oath Clashes with Personal Convictions
I come from a part of the world where the taking of an oath has a rather unpleasant history.
I grew up in the Annapolis Valley of Nova Scotia in Canada. I lived literally a block from the spot where, in 1755, the British commander told a group of Acadian farmers -- who had grown estranged from France during their almost 150 years in the area and had no interest in the latest British-French blowup -- that they would have to swear allegiance to the King of England or else their lands would be forfeited to the crown and they would be shipped away.
And as Henry Wadsworth Longfellow chronicled in his poem, Evangeline, this is exactly what happened when the proud Acadians refused to take the oath.
For most people, taking an oath is not a problem. But for some their personal convictions -- particularly their personal religious convictions -- can create a troubling situation. Take the case of Marianne Kearney-Brown, a Quaker and graduate student who was fired from her teaching job at California State University East Bay this week because she refused to sign an 87-word Oath of Allegiance to the Constitution that the state requires of elected officials and public employees.
It wasn't so much that she didn't want to swear allegiance to the state's Constitution. As the San Francisco Chronicle reports, "A veteran public school math teacher who specializes in helping struggling students, Kearney-Brown, 50, had signed the oath before - but had modified it each time."
Each time, when asked to "swear (or affirm)" that she would "support and defend" the U.S. and state Constitutions "against all enemies, foreign and domestic," Kearney-Brown inserted revisions: She wrote "nonviolently" in front of the word "support," crossed out "swear," and circled "affirm." All were to conform with her Quaker beliefs, she said.
Kearney-Brown did this several times over her career teaching in California and it was never rejected. But this time she got a letter that said the university's counsel said she couldn't alter the oath (which may or may not be true, as it turns out) and she had to sign it or be fired. She refused to sign and was axed.
Kearney-Brown will be on Talk of the Nation today to talk about what happened to her and why she did what she did.
Should a person be able to change the wording of an oath to suit their religious situation? Atheists are not required to say "under God" while reciting the Pledge of Allegiance, nor are they required to swear on a Bible in court. They can affirm their promise to tell the truth. Should the same consideration be extended to other strong religious beliefs?
Tom Regan
1:58 PM ET
|
05- 6-2008
|
permalink
|
comments (14)
|
e-mail post
Film School at Home
David and Jesse Gilmour had a unique arrangement.
From the witty repartee of Annie Hall and va-va-voom of Lolita, to Tony Montana's "little friend" in Scarface, Jesse Gilmour didn't receive your ordinary high school education. After almost flunking out of school, without remorse, his dad, David, decided to make a deal with him: he could drop out, live at home job- and rent-free, and all he had to do, in exchange, was watch three movies a week with his old man. Every teenager's dream, right? What resulted was a unique exchange between father and son -- film critic and novice. In watching the films, they found ways to talk about girls and relationships, drugs and alcohol, and how to approach life's big decisions -- at a time when most teenage boys pull away from their fathers.
Former film critic and Canadian talk show host David Gilmour wrote about the experience in a new book called The Film Club, and he and his son, Jesse, join us today to share their stories.
Have you ever learned something important from a movie, or a scene from a movie? Tell us about it! And what would your film school curriculum be?
Ashley Grashaw
1:57 PM ET
|
05- 6-2008
|
permalink
|
comments (21)
|
e-mail post
RIP: Yearbooks
My yearbooks, from middle school and high school, are tucked away somewhere in my childhood bedroom. Some day, five or ten years from now, I'll crack them open, to look at awkward studio portraits, to read benedictions and valedictions, to search for an embarrassing photo of a now-famous classmate.
I was sad to read that future classes, in colleges and universities especially, might not have yearbooks to look at, to laugh at. Free social networks, like Facebook and MySpace, and online photo websites, like Flickr and Picasa, have eroded yearbook sales.
Ye Domesday Booke, the yearbook at Georgetown University, is poorly funded and understaffed. The yearbook office at Virginia Wesleyan College is filled with old books. (Many students who ordered copies didn't pick them up.) And The Debris, from Purdue University? There will be no 2009 edition.
Do you mourn the dying yearbook? What does it give you that an website can't? Do you have your old yearbooks? Do you look at them with any frequency?
David Gura
1:56 PM ET
|
05- 6-2008
|
permalink
|
comments (14)
|
e-mail post