John Ridley's Visible Man
 
 

The Amy Winehouse Visa Hypocrisy

Amy Winehouse performs during the MTV Europe Music Awards in Germany in November.

British singer Amy Winehouse, shown performing in November, had been denied a visa to travel to Los Angeles for the Grammy Awards, but authorities reversed their decision.

Sean Gallup/Getty Images for MTV

The off-again/on-again should-we-let-her-in Amy Winehouse visa saga is ... on again! At the 11th hour, the U.S. embassy over in GB rubber-stamped her so that Ms. Winehouse could — if she chooses — participate in Sunday's 50th Annual Grammy Awards. There was no official word as to why she originally got the thumbs down, but I would bet it had something to do with her most recent stab at taking the cure after a 19-minute toke video she starred in was leaked to the U.K. media.

Ironically, Louis C. Camilleri will have no trouble getting his visa stamped when he leaves the country for Switzerland. Mr. Camilleri is the current CEO of Altria Group, which is the parent company of Philip Morris, which is the largest tobacco company in the U.S. And the U.S. is the largest exporter of manufactured cigarettes on the planet, accounting for nearly 20 percent of the world total.

Why is Mr. Camilleri going to Switzerland? Because Altria Group is about to split off PMI — Philip Morris' international unit — from its domestic parent. The move, according to The Wall Street Journal, is being made to "free the tobacco giant's international operations of legal and public-relations headaches in the U.S. that have hindered its growth."

And out from under the yoke of oppressive U.S. regulations and lawsuits, there's plenty of growing to be done. Overseas, 5.2 trillion cigarettes are expected to be sucked down this year. In 2006, PMI out-earned Philip Morris USA with revenue of $48.26 billion to $18.47 billion for its domestic sibling. And without that pesky PC-health-crowd monkey on its back, PMI can start slinging some clever new smokes, like the Marlboro Intense. About a half-inch shorter than a regular Marlboro, this high-potency cigarette is designed to be fast-smoked by the tobacco addict forced outside into the cold and/or rain by indoor smoking bans. Or, how about the Marlboro Mix 9? High-nicotine, high-tar. 'Cause I guess just shooting yourself in the head doesn't kill you quick enough. And if you still don't think smoking is suicide, the WHO predicts 10 million people a year will die of smoking-related illness by 2020, making it the single leading cause of death worldwide.

Now, clearly, the U.S. can't truly stop Camilleri from leaving the country, or PMI from setting up shop in Fencesit-zerland. Smoking tobacco is, after all, legal. But if a guy who makes bank selling cancer is free to travel, comparatively the government shouldn't have been dithering over Winehouse's entry 'cause she might guzzle a little Cristal and trash a hotel room.

Unless, of course, she kills 10 million people in the process.

comments | |

 

Comments

View all comments »

Add a Comment

Please note that all comments must adhere to the NPR.org discussion rules and terms of use. See also the Community FAQ.

NPR reserves the right to read on the air and/or publish on its Web site or in any medium now known or unknown the e-mails and letters that we receive. We may edit them for clarity or brevity and identify authors by name and location. For additional information, please consult our Terms of Use.

"And out from under the yolk of oppressive U.S. regulations and lawsuits, there's plenty of growing to be done."

- Is the U.S. throwing eggs along with regs and lawsuits?

Editor's Note: This has been fixed. Thanks.

Sent by Sue | 8:29 PM ET | 02-08-2008

Comedian Eddie Izzard make the comment in one of his shows that we let those who do truly horrific things off because we can't quite wrap our heads around it.

Be responsible for the deaths of one, two or a few more and the public outcry would have the alleged strung up in the court of public opinion and easy political punditry before you can ask why.

Commit and act (or acts) that results in the death of thousands or even millions of people and you are more likely to be made a political, economic or military ally than to be held accountable.

That Ms Winehouse isn't giving millions in donations to various politicos might have a lot to do with why her application wasn't green lighted immediately.

Sent by Liz Lewis | 8:28 AM ET | 02-09-2008

Conflating the two cases is almost saying that you can not argue for Winehouse without pointing the finger, "look he's worse". That's a weak deflection tactic. Just tell us why Winehouse should be welcomed to the U.S.

Sent by biff | 2:04 PM ET | 02-09-2008

Could not have been said better!!

Sent by Vance High | 8:24 PM ET | 02-11-2008

Yes we do need another crack smoking performer who somehow is glorified by the cool Hollywood types in our country. Who needs her? Why is this such a tragedy?

Sent by kyle | 11:26 PM ET | 02-11-2008

maybe they just didn't like her music, I know I'm not seeing what the big hoopla is over it.

Sent by Nate | 12:41 PM ET | 02-12-2008

Gotta say I like Winehouse's music, and I hate Big Tobacco, but popular,addictive personalities like Amy sell a lot more cigarettes to kids (the vast majority of new smokers) than any paid advertising or new extra potent products.

Sent by Danny Carpenter | 2:19 PM ET | 02-12-2008

I have no doubt the PMI CEO is a criminal of the first water, but I have more than a little trouble with your idea that if the addict can sing she's cool--and maybe even being addicted is cool too. You think waking up on the crackhouse porch is cool? Check it out.

Sent by SKB | 9:29 PM ET | 02-12-2008

Get a grip! Its a stretch to try and do any comparison here. Amy is not even in the league, let her come here and influence our children when she cleans up her act.

Sent by HT | 1:16 AM ET | 02-13-2008

Amy was finally allowed to leave rehab to accept an award for Rehab, a song about not going to rehab.

She sings:

"They tried to make me go to rehab but I said 'no, no, no'

Yes I've been black but when I come back you'll know know know"

Correct me if I'm wrong, but the only way "I've been black" makes any sense at all is as a kind of archaic figure of speech meaning "I've been bad" or "I've been naughty."

So I think that what the song is trying to convey is a feeling something like, "Yeah, I know I've totally messed up lateley, but it's not about if I can play the blues, I BE the blues, and when I get back, you'll wish that pain had stayed home and not visited.



Sent by Dave | 9:18 AM ET | 02-18-2008



   
   
   
null


 
John Ridley.

John Ridley

BLOGGER

 
 
 

About Visible Man

John Ridley is an Emmy Award winning commentator and writer for Esquire and Time magazines as well as a contributor to CNN, MSNBC, Fox News, and NPR.

He is the author of seven published novels, the most recent of which is What Fire Cannot Burn. Collectively, his works have been chosen as editor's picks or "best of the year" by The New York Times, The Wall Street Journal, the Los Angeles Times, Entertainment Weekly and the Baltimore Sun.

Ridley is the Founding Editor of That Minority Thing, a nonpartisan Web site that provides news and opinions in support of a wide range of voices, including ethnic, racial, religious, disabled, gender, and sexual minorities.

If you'd like to know more about John and his Visible Man blog, please consult the FAQ entry.

 
 

Discussion Guidelines

Read the discussion guidelines for John Ridley's Visible Man.

 
 

Comment Privately

If you would like to send private comments or questions to John Ridley's Visible Man, please use our contact form.

 
 
 

Search 'John Ridley's Visible Man'

Search for the word(s):
 
 

Browse Topics

Services

Programs