THE MIDDLE DECADES, 1860 - 1880

  As telegraph systems began to grow, operators noticed two annoying phenomena. Because both ground conduction and electromagnetic induction fields share the same channel, multiple messages can exist simultaneously, and the result is crosstalk which interferes with the primary transmission. For example, Harvard University sent a time signal from Cambridge to Boston on a dedicated telegraph line. Operators on other lines which were near this one picked up this signal because the two systems were grounded closely together, and the ground conducted the unwanted electricity. Another example occurred on the New York-to-Boston and New York-to-Albany telegraph lines which ran near and parallel to each other for several miles. An electrical signal traveling on one line would induce a signal onto the other. This problem became especially objectionable when telephone networks emerged. But electricians realized that these phenomena could have positive attributes if the wireless communication were intentional.

By mid-century, several trends in the development of wireless began to emerge. Electricians coalesced into two groups -- those involved in basic research and the general dissemination of knowledge, and those tinkering and trying to make something work, analogous to the difference between scientists and engineers. Both the scientific and technical press grew both in quantity and quality, perhaps as a direct result of the telegraph (Czitrom, 1982, 3-29), and it became easier to publish and access information about these developments. Although many inventors worked alone, a growing number of electricians joined associations formed for the purpose of disseminating information and promoting their expertise (Marvin, 1988, 9-62). And there was more interest in protecting inventions through the patent process.

James Clerk Maxwell, a Scottish mathematician and professor at Cambridge, began to develop a theory of electrical behavior based on the work of Faraday, Henry, and others. It was Maxwell's idea that electricity traveled through the air in waves, in a method similar to and at the same speed as light. He also believed that he could simplify the explanation of this behavior by expressing it mathematically. After more than a decade of experimentation, he published Electricity and Magnetism in 1873. Maxwell's formulae and his prediction of the existence of electromagnetic waves would be the basis for the development of radio. But it would be another decade before anyone would attempt practical applications of Maxwell's ideas, and more than 20 years before Marconi and others would transmit and receive useful signals in this manner (Appleyard, 1930, 330; Dunlap, 1944, 65-68; Skilling 1948, 160-171). In the meantime, wireless electricians concentrated on the proven technologies of conduction and induction.

Mahlon Loomis, a Washington DC, dentist, became interested in electricity through the work of his elder brother and a Professor Lowell whose lectures he attended in Boston. Loomis devised a conduction telegraph system that used the air as its primary conductor and the ground as a return. It also used atmospheric electricity, or lightning, in place of batteries or some other power source. In 1866, he suspended two kites from mountains in Northern Virginia separated by 14 miles. Each kite had a copper grid affixed and was attached to the ground by wire. When Loomis opened and closed a connection on one kite wire, the action would deflect a galvanometer needle attached to the other (Loomis Papers). He also noted that the kites were elevated to approximately the same height, probably a tuned aerial conductor or antenna array (Naslund, 1979). Loomis was more interested, however, in promoting the ability of his device to draw electricity from the ether, and he failed to see the significance of his antenna design. In a succession of hard luck incidents, three groups of investors were wiped out by the financial panic of 1869, the Chicago fire of 1871, and the stock market crash of 1873. He petitioned Congress for a $50,000 grant which was rejected (Appleby, 1967, 54-70). Congress nevertheless incorporated Loomis's company, and he received a patent (Loomis, 1872) but was never able to develop the idea commercially (Loomis, 1914; Rice, 1974).

Another American, William Henry Ward, was interested in aerial telegraphy, but his idea was totally different from the Loomis design. Ward reasoned that if electricity moved through the air, moving the air itself would transmit the signal. His device, depicted in Figure 3 (below), consisted of a series of towers, mounted on mountain tops, which looked like inverted funnels with their tips bent at a right angle. The towers were vented so as to force air upward across a simple condenser, or antenna, made of two dissimilar metals. When exposed to the moisture of the upper atmosphere, the condenser would generate a small electrical charge which the air current would push toward the next tower. Ward received a patent (Ward, 1872) for this absurd device but never constructed.

The German siege of Paris in 1870 created the need to communicate with the rest of France behind enemy lines. M. Bourbouze proposed a wireless telegraph system across the Seine river, along the lines of Lindsay's design. After a successful test over a short distance, Bourbouze dispatched a confederate by balloon to Champagne with the plans to set up a transmitter. By the time the man acquired the necessary equipment and made his way back to the river, it was frozen over. Before it thawed, the French surrendered, so the Bourbouze system never got a full-scale trial (Fahie, 1899, 66-68).

Three series of experiments bear mention here. The first was begun by American inventor Thomas Edison about 1875 and would result in inventions described below. Using a spark gap between two carbon points, Edison and his assistants at Menlo Park observed that the sparks set off electrical current which seemed to diffuse in waves through the air.

Edison called this effect "etheric force" but had no way to detect or harness it (Hawks, 1927, 142; Josephson, 1959, 279). By 1878, Alexander Graham Bell had likewise turned his attention to wireless, and his experiments are featured in the next section.

In Great Britain, William Preece was hired as an electrician with the Post Office in 1877, and began in earnest to devise effective wireless communication with offshore islands, coal mines, and other locations where wired communication was difficult or unfeasible. Although Preece, who eventually became Chief Electrician for the Post Office, was most interested in conduction and induction technologies, he used his influence and membership in professional societies to stay abreast of all developments in his home country, on the European continent, and in America (Baker, 1976, 250-259; Dunlap, 1944, 71-73; Hawks, 1927, 159). He had the rare combination of academic and technical expertise, coupled with a continuing curiosity about wireless.

Next | The Early Years 1800-1860 | Introduction | The Final Decades 1880-1900 | Discussion&Conclusions | References | Return to EUonline Feature Page

[Return to EUonline Home Page]