NPR logo Tweedy vs. Bird: What Do You Want From A Concert?

Tweedy vs. Bird: What Do You Want From A Concert?

Jeff Tweedy at the Lincoln Theatre in Washington, D.C. Erica Bruce/Between Love & Like hide caption

toggle caption Erica Bruce/Between Love & Like

I've gone to a live concert every night this week. Tuesday, I saw Jeff Tweedy, and then on Wednesday, I saw Andrew Bird. The two couldn't have been more different.

Tweedy's show at Washington, D.C.'s Lincoln Theatre was a crowd-pleaser. He sang a lot of songs we all knew, dug deep into the Wilco songbook, included a few Woody Guthrie tunes and even sang an Uncle Tupelo song.

Andrew Bird at the Sixth & I Synagogue in Washington, D.C. Abby Verbosky hide caption

toggle caption Abby Verbosky

Bird didn't bring a songbook of any kind to D.C.'s historic 6th and I Synagogue. He told the audience his show was "Gezelligheid," a Dutch term for "cozy."  Bird played a few pieces that were familiar, but then he mostly tried out new song ideas, in real time, looping violin parts with rhythms, textures, melodies and more.  Sometimes he picked up the guitar to play along to his looped violin lines, or play the glockenspiel with one hand.  Sometimes the ideas worked; sometimes they didn't, and he'd abruptly abandon them. Someone described it as watching an alchemist.

So, forgetting whether you like Andrew Bird more than Jeff Tweedy or visa versa: Which show would you prefer: your favorite artist doing old favorites, or going out on a limb to try new ideas?

We no longer support commenting on NPR.org stories, but you can find us every day on Facebook, Twitter, email, and many other platforms. Learn more or contact us.