Inside The BPP

Siegel to the 'BPP': Where Are the Comments?



  • Playlist
  • Download
  • Embed
    <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">

Lee Siegel takes on the Bryant Park Project, day two


Lee Siegel could deal with a little less "noise." Jill Krementz hide caption

toggle caption Jill Krementz

Lee Siegel and his new book — Against the Machine: Being Human in the Age of the Electronic Mob — are everywhere right now. Siegel's even quoted on that television thing in our office elevator. The powerhouse critics has agreed to critique the Bryant Park blog and Twitter feed this week.

In our conversation on day one, he cautioned against mere talkativeness, then relished a Tweet about cupcakes. Today he's onto a Tweet about our daily breakfast order, and also an anonymous comment about him. Someone wrote, "Lee Siegel is a genius," and signed it "Sprezzatura." That's Siegel's onetime nom de net, one that got him into something of a pickle, let's say. He's brave about it.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

I'm absolutely loving this whole discussion/conversation. The timing is perfect for me. I just started using twitter, somewhat under duress, for work. By searching for NPR I found your twitter feed and blog. Lee Siegel's take on twitter is really interesting, and I'm really enjoying your tweets. (Still having a hard time with that phrase for some reason.) Just thought I'd let you know I appreciate what you're doing. Thanks!

Sent by BB | 4:04 PM | 1-29-2008

The irony to which I referred, and perhaps which I should have been more clear about, wasn't that someone make a Sprezzatura joke on the Lee Siegel post.

It would have been ironic if BPP, since comments here are moderated, let that comment go through without getting the inside joke. At least I think it would have been ironic.

Maybe I don't understand the word "ironic."

I do wonder how much the Sprezzatura incident has colored Siegel's analysis and understanding of blogs, and the web in general. It's seems that, instead of gaining insight about how Internet culture works -- distinguishing, for example, between anonymity ("Sprezzatura") and pseudonymity ("Atrios," who's a guy named Duncan and lives in Philly and likes to grill on his roof) -- it's actually pushed him farther away from seeing what's really happening.

Sent by carlo | 5:25 PM | 1-29-2008

Wait, did I completely misinterpret what Lee Siegel was saying, or did he just compare himself to Megan Meiers?

Sent by Stewart | 10:17 PM | 1-29-2008

Honestly I usually listen/read every day and try to comment where ever I feel I might have something to add, but sometimes I worry about being the only one posting (especially if it's multiple entries in a row).

Sent by alice | 6:12 AM | 1-30-2008

Twittering makes me happy. Too much analyzing and it will ruin it for me.

Sent by wareagle | 9:47 AM | 1-30-2008

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from