NPR logo The Time A Cartoonist Was Told To 'Lighten Up' A Character

The Time A Cartoonist Was Told To 'Lighten Up' A Character

Cartoonist Ronald Wimberly was told to "lighten up" a Mexican and African-American character. i

Cartoonist Ronald Wimberly was told to "lighten up" a Mexican and African-American character. Ronald Wimberly/The Nib hide caption

toggle caption Ronald Wimberly/The Nib
Cartoonist Ronald Wimberly was told to "lighten up" a Mexican and African-American character.

Cartoonist Ronald Wimberly was told to "lighten up" a Mexican and African-American character.

Ronald Wimberly/The Nib

In a beautifully illustrated comic over at The Nib, cartoonist Ronald Wimberly relays the story of working with an editor who asked him to lighten the skin tone of a character he was working on, Melita Garner, who has been described as Mexican and African-American, a reporter, and Wolverine's ex-girlfriend.

Given her ethnicity, Wimberly figured he'd "make her some kind of brown." But he got a request from the editor to use a much lighter color instead. "Melita's changed over the years," his editor wrote to him. "i've been told that she is latina and white."

Melita Garner is a character who is described as Mexican and African-American.

Melita Garner is a character who is described as Mexican and African-American. Ronald Wimberly/The Nib hide caption

toggle caption Ronald Wimberly/The Nib

But Wimberly didn't know what to make of that, either. Latinas, he points out in his work, can look very different depending on where they're from. He draws images of three women, an Arab Mexican (hexidecimal ID #ebb8ac), a Japanese-Brazilian (hexidecimal ID #d8b983) and a Dominican (hexidecimal ID #503636) — to show the wide range of skin tones needed to illustrate them.

" 'Latina' refers to an ethnicity with a broad range of possible nationalities, appearances and skin tones," Wimberly writes.

" 'Latina' refers to an ethnicity with a broad range of possible nationalities, appearances and skin tones," Wimberly writes. Ronald Wimberly/The Nib hide caption

toggle caption Ronald Wimberly/The Nib

"Why is it important to change the skin tone of this character a few degrees? What purpose does it serve?" Wimberly wonders. "I wondered if a black editor would have asked me to change her skin tone. I'll keep wondering. After 12 years working in comics, I've yet to have a black editor."

To see and read his entire cartoon essay, visit The Nib.

Comments

 

Discussions about race, ethnicity and culture tend to get dicey quickly, so we hold our commenters on Code Switch to an especially high bar. We may delete comments we think might derail the conversation. If you're new to Code Switch, please read over our FAQ and NPR's Community Guidelines before commenting. We try to notify commenters individually when we remove their comments, but given that we receive a high volume of comments, we may not always be able to get in touch. If we've removed a comment you felt was a thoughtful and valuable addition to the conversation, please don't hesitate to get in touch with us by emailing codeswitch@npr.org.