NPR logo C-Sections And The Profit Motive In California

Health Inc.

C-Sections And The Profit Motive In California

Every new analysis shows cesarean section in this country are pretty much out of control.

California map

The rates for C-sections vary widely even within a single state. hide caption

toggle caption

Now a look at the variations in the rates of cesarean sections in California find they're much more likely at for-profit hospitals — 17 percent more likely according to an investigation by the non-profit journalism outfit California Watch.

Statewide data show big variation in C-section rates, even when confined to women with low-risk pregnancies. At nonprofit Kaiser Permanente Redwood City Medical Center, the C-section rate was 9 percent. At for-profit Los Angeles Community Hospital, the rate 47 percent.

"The wide variation in C-section rates really is a cause for concern,” Dr. Jeanne Conry, California district chairwoman of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, told California Watch. (She also happens to be on staff at Kaiser Permanente.)

A hospital can make more money from a c-section birth, which can produce twice as much revenue as a vaginal delivery.

A recent snapshot of the C-section around the nation found that about a third of births are now surgical procedures. Sure record-breaking rates have something to do with more older and overweight mothers, plus more twins.

But the California investigation focused on low-risk births and still found high rates at many hospitals, especially those that are owned by for-profit companies.

A spokesman with for-profit hospital chain Tenet Healthcare said California Watch's premise was wrong and that the choice of C-section is made by the patient and doctor without influence by the hospital.

A big problem around the country is the rate of births that are induced. Nowadays, about 44 percent of attempted vaginal deliveries are induced, a decision which is twice as likely to lead to a cesarean.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.