The Message Machine

Was Gingrich Correct On His Record As Speaker? Fact-Checking the GOP Debate's Truth-O-Meter.'s Truth-O-Meter. hide caption

toggle caption

Bill Adair, editor of and Washington bureau chief for The St. Petersburg Times, wrote about how candidates at the Sioux City, Iowa, debate rated on PolitiFact's Truth-O-Meter for and It's All Politics:

The Fox News debate Thursday night offered the Republican presidential candidates something of a closing argument with less than three weeks until the Iowa caucuses.

The debate included an interesting offering of factual claims, many of which sounded familiar to us.

The most provocative was one from Rep. Michele Bachmann about ... us.

Bachmann cited PolitiFact in response to a complaint from Newt Gingrich that she wasn't being accurate with a claim about his work for Freddie Mac.

Bachmann said: "After the debate that we had last week, PolitiFact came out and said that everything I said was true."

But in fact, Bachmann earned two ratings from us at that debate, a Mostly True for her claim that Newt Gingrich advocated for the individual mandate in health care and a Pants on Fire for her claim that Mitt Romney set up a health plan in Massachusetts that is "socialized medicine."

We then rated Bachmann's new claim and gave it a Pants on Fire. (The fact that Bachmann would cite us was interesting given that her PolitiFact report card shows 60 percent of her ratings have been False or Pants on Fire.)

Newt Gingrich spent much of the debate emphasizing his conservative credentials to rebut arguments from Bachmann and others. He used one of his favorite talking points, that when he was speaker of the House, he "balanced the budget for four straight years, paid off $405 billion in debt." But we checked the numbers and found he's off on both counts. We rated that claim False.

Jon Huntsman, who has been talking about the need for energy independence, repeated a claim he had made before in New Hampshire, saying that "in this country ... we have more natural gas than Saudi Arabia has oil." We don't, although we currently produce more natural gas than Saudi Arabia produces oil, so we rated it Mostly False.

For more political fact-checking, you can tune in on Saturday morning when Bill Adair joins Weekend Edition to discuss how candidates are fairing on the truthfulness scale so far this election season.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from