NPR logo This Blog Post Costs $3.99

Trade

This Blog Post Costs $3.99

Very, very close to $4.00. J Pat Carter/AP hide caption

toggle caption
J Pat Carter/AP

When something costs $3.99, you just round up and tell yourself it costs $4.00. Right?

Maybe not.

A growing body of research suggests that the timeless trick of charging, say, $3.99 rather than $4.00 may actually work.

In one study, researchers offered people a choice between two different pens.

When the pens were priced at at $2.00 and $3.99, nearly half of the people chose the more expensive pen.

But when the prices changed by a single penny, to $1.99 and $4.00, fewer than 20 percent of people chose the more expensive pen.

Social scientists call this the "left-digit bias" — peoples' tendency to place too much weight on the leftmost digit of a number.

"We have limited time to process stuff, so we take shortcuts," the economist Nicola Lacetera told me.

This makes some sense if something is super cheap — like, say, a pen. But people also exhibit left-digit bias with really expensive things — like, say, used cars.

Lacetera and a couple other economists recently looked at sales data from millions of used cars sold at auction. (Here's the abstract of their paper.)

Article continues after sponsorship

They found that the price of a car drops significantly when the mileage crosses multiples of 10,000.

For example, cars with 80,000 miles sell for about $210 less, on average, than cars with 79,900 miles.

By comparison, cars with 79,900 miles sell for about $10 less, on average, than cars with 79,800 miles.

This is particularly striking because there's nothing hidden about the number, and because the irrational price jump appears at every 10,000-mile increment up to 100,000 miles.

"The market is so thick and competitive," Lacetera said. "You would expect this to be washed out, and it's not."

This phenomenon — driven, ultimately, by a kind of inattention to numbers — may play out in other spheres as well. For example, Lacetera speculated that students' chances of being admitted to college may jump irrationally as test scores cross big, round-number thresholds.

"We need to pay more attention to inattention," Lacetera said.