NPR logo S&P's 'Golden Goose'


S&P's 'Golden Goose'

The Justice Department is investigating whether Standard & Poor's improperly rated mortgage-backed securities during the housing boom, the NYT reports.

The story says the investigation started before S&P downgraded the U.S. earlier this month. This is not surprising, given the fact that the ratings agencies have been criticized for years for giving high ratings to mortgage-backed securities that collapsed in the crisis.

In fact, investigators appear to be following up on a Bloomberg News story published nearly three years ago.

Today's NYT says:

Investigators have been asking about a remark supposedly made by David Tesher about mortgage security ratings, two people said. The investigators have asked witnesses if they heard Mr. Tesher say: "Don't kill the golden goose," in reference to mortgage securities.

The Bloomberg News story, from September, 2008, quotes Richard Gugliada, a former S&P managing director:

Gugliada says that when the subject came up of tightening S&P's criteria, the co-director of CDO ratings, David Tesher, said: "Don't kill the golden goose."

Today's NYT story says Gugliada "has been mentioned in investigators' interviews."

The agencies have been criticized in part for their business model: They were paid by the banks whose securities they were rating. The 2008 Bloomberg story describes a "race to the bottom" in which S&P and Moody's both "repeatedly eased their standards as they pursued profits ... ."

One key question today's NYT story does not answer — but that seems likely to emerge in the follow-up coverage — is whether the Justice Department is also investigating Moody's and Fitch, the other two big ratings agencies.

We no longer support commenting on stories, but you can find us every day on Facebook, Twitter, email, and many other platforms. Learn more or contact us.