NPR logo
In France, A Balancing Act Between Liberty And Security
  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/462230399/462230400" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
In France, A Balancing Act Between Liberty And Security

Postcards

In France, A Balancing Act Between Liberty And Security

In France, A Balancing Act Between Liberty And Security
  • Download
  • <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/462230399/462230400" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Flowers and messages at Paris' Place de la Republique commemorate the victims of last year's January and November shooting attacks. i

Flowers and messages at Paris' Place de la Republique commemorate the victims of last year's January and November shooting attacks. Charles Platiau/Reuters /Landov hide caption

toggle caption Charles Platiau/Reuters /Landov
Flowers and messages at Paris' Place de la Republique commemorate the victims of last year's January and November shooting attacks.

Flowers and messages at Paris' Place de la Republique commemorate the victims of last year's January and November shooting attacks.

Charles Platiau/Reuters /Landov

One year ago, gunmen stormed the Paris offices of satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo and began a three-day killing spree that would claim 17 lives. Ten months later, in November, armed Islamist radicals struck the city again, killing scores at cafes and a concert hall.

In 2015, we saw the most deadly attacks on French soil since World War II. President Francois Hollande says France is at war. His country, which has long stood for individual freedom, is trying to balance that freedom with the need for security.

In his traditional New Year's Eve address, Hollande told the French they aren't finished with terrorism. "The threat is still there," he said, "and it's at its highest level ever. We are regularly thwarting new attacks."

Police stand on patrol in the north of Paris on Thursday, as the city remained on edge after a man attempted to gain access to a police station while brandishing a knife. Police shot the man, who later died. i

Police stand on patrol in the north of Paris on Thursday, as the city remained on edge after a man attempted to gain access to a police station while brandishing a knife. Police shot the man, who later died. Thierry Chesnot/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption Thierry Chesnot/Getty Images
Police stand on patrol in the north of Paris on Thursday, as the city remained on edge after a man attempted to gain access to a police station while brandishing a knife. Police shot the man, who later died.

Police stand on patrol in the north of Paris on Thursday, as the city remained on edge after a man attempted to gain access to a police station while brandishing a knife. Police shot the man, who later died.

Thierry Chesnot/Getty Images

Indeed, Paris police on Thursday shot and killed a man brandishing a knife who'd tried to enter a police station wearing a fake suicide vest.

To fight terrorism, Hollande said the French government would seek to amend the country's constitution to make it easier for the president to impose states of emergency in the future. The state of emergency allows police to conduct searches and seizures and detain people at any time without a warrant.

Hollande also wants to modify the constitution to enshrine a proposal long associated with the far right: stripping convicted terrorists with dual citizenship of their French nationality.

The proposals have caused a political uproar. But in today's France, facing terror in its streets, the lines between left and right have blurred.

Constitutional law professor Didier Maus says the debate is similar to that in the U.S. over the Patriot Act.

French President Francois Hollande kisses the mother of late police Officer Ahmed Merabet during commemorations in Paris on Tuesday. Hollande paid tribute to Merabet, who was killed a year ago as he tried to chase down the gunmen responsible for the Charlie Hebdo attacks. i

French President Francois Hollande kisses the mother of late police Officer Ahmed Merabet during commemorations in Paris on Tuesday. Hollande paid tribute to Merabet, who was killed a year ago as he tried to chase down the gunmen responsible for the Charlie Hebdo attacks. Benoit Tessier/AP hide caption

toggle caption Benoit Tessier/AP
French President Francois Hollande kisses the mother of late police Officer Ahmed Merabet during commemorations in Paris on Tuesday. Hollande paid tribute to Merabet, who was killed a year ago as he tried to chase down the gunmen responsible for the Charlie Hebdo attacks.

French President Francois Hollande kisses the mother of late police Officer Ahmed Merabet during commemorations in Paris on Tuesday. Hollande paid tribute to Merabet, who was killed a year ago as he tried to chase down the gunmen responsible for the Charlie Hebdo attacks.

Benoit Tessier/AP

"We must find a middle place between what is acceptable in the name of fighting terrorism and what is impossible in the name of defending liberty," he says.

All week, French TV has aired riveting documentaries detailing the attacks. They show some stunning security failures. When police arrived at Charlie Hebdo, the killing had not yet started. But officers were unaware that the controversial newspaper was located in the building — even though it had been firebombed four years earlier for republishing Danish cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.

One of the two attackers was supposed to be under police surveillance, but authorities lost his trail when he left Paris for another French city.

France is struggling to deal with radicalization, and the prime minister, Manuel Valls, says 1,000 French citizens have gone to fight in Syria — the highest number of citizens of any European country.

Former terrorism judge Jean de Maillard says France has good intelligence but doesn't have the manpower to keep track of individuals once they're identified as potential threats. Hollande has promised more police and judges. And Charlie Hebdo's new editor now has five security guards.

On Tuesday, a plaque to the victims was unveiled near the offices of Charlie Hebdo. Train driver Gilbert Houdinet came to see it. He says France is grasping to deal with a new reality of jihad and terrorism.

"I think people are pushed to extremism because of unemployment and general misery," he says. "Taking away their nationality won't solve the problem. We have to offer jobs and hope for people to live on."

Houdinet says that would cost a lot less than paying all these soldiers and police to guard us.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.