Racial Profiling: Cops on the Prowl?

Profiling. Stop and Frisk. Driving while Black...

How are you reacting to this? Are you rolling your eyes and saying, "Oh, that again?" ...Or are you saying, "Yeah, that's right. What about that?"

I point it out because this is not simple arithmetic, as in one plus one equals two. It is just inescapable that where you stand on questions like this often depends on where you sit. One less-discussed result from the recent Pew Poll (pdf) on racial attitudes (conducted in association with NPR) is that Blacks have a very different view of law enforcement than whites do...

Pew Poll: Young people, regardless of race, have the least amount of confidence in local police. Only 16% of all blacks under the age of 30 consistently express trust in police on all three measures, compared with 26% of those blacks 65 years and older. While whites have significantly more confidence than blacks in local police, young whites are skeptical...

I am guessing this was probably less discussed (although we did talk about it) because the other results were so interesting ... but also because that perspective is so well known.

I am raising this because our lead story this morning is both new and not new. How many times have you heard a Black/African American or Latino man — especially a young man — complain of his treatment by the police? And, how many times have you heard the police say it didn't happen, or get over it? We have a story like that this morning ... a young reporter for the New York Post, Leonardo Blair, talks about how he was treated by the NYPD when he got home from work last week. He wrote about it in the Sunday paper.

Usually, the situations we hear about involve an interracial dynamic. But in the case we talked about this morning, everybody involved was black or Latino. So, we thought it a good idea to add another voice to the mix, and that would be Stanley Couch, a well-known writer and columnist who kind of gives no quarter to anybody. He raises the question of how to balance the real need to fight crime — much of which is black-on-black or Latino-on-Latino — with a need to respect the rights of law-abiding citizens.

Also, we have the additional benefit of hearing a perspective from the New York City deputy police commissioner for public information. Hear his take on the interaction between Blair and the two police officers.

And later, on a happier note (it's the holiday season), ways to do some GOOD. We'll have a variety of perspectives this week. We start in New York and then travel south. There's a program called DonorsChoose, where you can decide how your money gets spent on projects for school kids around the country. In other words, it's an version of our Ordinary Oprahs. We'll have more for you over the week.

Merry, merry and Happy Hanukah, which begins tonight. Send me some gelt if you have any left over ... the good kind.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

To this story..there is more going on then what you have typically found out in the south..Who is running the short and long of it..Racial profiling is more deeper now..then find ways to beat you down if you stand up against them..for I tell you now come to Mobile..there is more than a cop in question..try the attorneys under the DA...there is more than color..its who will sell themselves to the highest bidder to commit civil violations to hold there position..check it out..try it..thee is moe...Apachecheynne

Sent by Apachecheynne | 9:24 PM | 12-6-2007

One of our (Black People) "dirty" and not so "hidden" secrets, is the black cops tend to be much more harder on blacks, especially in the presence of white cops. It is like they feel they have to prove something to their peers.
I have no doubt about the incident. I have had similar experiences with black police officers. It seems to me, that this phenomena is another facet of the "slave mentality" within which we are all impacted, even down to our youngest generation.

Sent by ron tillman | 3:18 PM | 12-7-2007

There are so many prejudices..its when one acts on them that make it a wrong to label or defame..its not just about race..its about indifference..This is a survival of holding on to what is yours and protecting what one thinks is ego!

Sent by Apachecheynne | 10:54 AM | 5-4-2008


NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from