Miss Universe contestants congratulate fifth-place-finisher, Kaci Fennell of Jamaica. Many pageant watchers on social media argued that Fennell should have won. Wilfredo Lee/AP hide caption itoggle caption Wilfredo Lee/AP Code Switch Miss Colombia Wins Pageant; Miss Jamaica Wins Twitter? January 27, 2015 Days later, bad feelings linger among the Miss Universe pageant viewers who believe that the wrong contestant won. Many watchers on social media say Miss Jamaica should be wearing the crown.