Which Reigns Supreme: New Or Old Rock?

Hear The Debate

29 min 48 sec
 

Host David Dye plays mediator between Dave Thompson and Ryan Schreiber, who take up the momentous battle of old school vs. new music. Which reigns supreme?

Bon Iver Vs. Thin Lizzy (300)

If Bon Iver and Thin Lizzy got into a fight, who would win? Photo Illustration: Lars Gotrich; Photos: Drew Kaiser, iStock, Keystone/Hulton Archive. hide caption

itoggle caption Photo Illustration: Lars Gotrich; Photos: Drew Kaiser, iStock, Keystone/Hulton Archive.

Making the case for contemporary music is Schreiber, editor of the Internet publication Pitchfork and a champion of contemporary rock. And in the old-school corner is Thompson, critic and author of the classic-rock manifesto I Hate New Music.

As guest DJs, they spin select tracks to intensify the debate, pitting M.I.A. against Focus and Bon Iver against Thin Lizzy. Delving into some of the core dividing issues, the rivals discuss how the Internet has affected the process of music discovery, and how musicians draw from prior eras.

This story was originally aired on May 21st, 2009.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.