Bush, Senators to Meet on Immigration Bill

  • Playlist
  • Download
  • Embed
    <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

President Bush plans to visit with Senate Republicans Tuesday to discuss reviving a bipartisan immigration bill that stalled in the Senate last week. Sen. Jon Kyl (R-AZ), a chief architect of the compromise bill, says he is still confident a deal can be reached once proposed amendments to the bill can be heard.


Tomorrow, President Bush goes to Capitol Hill to have lunch with Republican senators. On the menu: immigration. The president's immigration bill failed to pass a cloture vote last week. It's under attack for many conservative Republicans as well as from liberal Democrats, whose groups tend to object to different aspects of the bill.

The chief Republican architect of the compromise Senate bill is Senator Jon Kyl of Arizona who joins us now. Welcome to the program, Senator Kyl.

Senator JON KYL (Republican, Arizona): Thank you. Good to be with you.

SIEGEL: The administration sounds upbeat about the prospects for the immigration bill. What can the president possibly tell your Republican colleagues that might make them more open to one?

Sen. KYL: Well, I think first of all, he will acknowledge that a lot of what we're hearing from our constituents back home is actually true. Our folks are worried that the government will not enforce a new immigration bill because, frankly, the current law is not very well enforced. I think he'll acknowledge that, but make the point that, actually, we need some changes in the law for it to be enforceable, especially in area of workplace verification.

Today, the law based on the 1986 Amnesty Act is not enforceable. Employers have to accept what they know or probably know are counterfeit documents, and yet they can't turn people down for employment. Under the new bill that has been written, that won't be true anymore. The government databases will be checked for verification of both social security information and identity. And we're not going to be relying anymore on the same kinds of counterfeitable documents.

SIEGEL: Is that really is a strong case that the lack of enforcement over the past several years has been for lack of legislative authority, or is it for lack of will to crack down on employers?

Sen. KYL: It's some of both. And it's also a lack of will to secure the border. Neither the previous administration - with whom I fought continuously - or this administration, or the Congress have been very forward leaning about enforcing the law or securing the border. And as I said, at the workplace, it's not easy to enforce. The administration has tried some of it, but you have to prove things that are very, very difficult to prove in order to hold employers accountable.

So, in some areas, the law really does have to be changed. In other areas, we could do a much better job with what we have.

SIEGEL: You said yesterday that passing the immigration bill is doable. All you have to do on the Republican side is sit down with those who have amendments, get those amendments in a reasonable package - not too many - so that members can say that they've had their chance. Are you saying that there are several senators who were disturbed by the bill, want to amend it, but if they can have a debate on their amendments and see them lose even, they would then permit the bill to go forward and be voted on?

Sen. KYL: I believe that's true. Now, it is also true that there are probably a couple of members who will try to filibuster the bill no matter how many times they were voted on including their own amendments. So, we do want to make sure that all Republicans and Democrats for that matter have a reasonable opportunity to get amendments voted on. And since we have not voted on as many amendments this year as we did last year, some are pointing to that as an objective test.

And it's not an unreasonable test. So, that being the case, there would be at least 10 more Republican roll call votes that would be required to have more than last year or as many as last year. So, that we can package up. We can take it to the majority leader. Show him that that could be done within a couple of days. Hopefully, therefore, persuade him that it's worth putting back on the schedule in order to be able to complete it before the 4th of July recess.

SIEGEL: Is a couple of days approximate or do you mean two days to vote it to do amendments?

Sen. KYL: That's approximately two days. There will be some Democrat amendments too. And assuming that each and one of them has an hour of debate, for example, you can see that it could be done within two days.

SIEGEL: How many Republican senators do you think are there in your caucus who accept the notion of legalizing 12 million immigrants now here illegally as opposed to those who think that what you're doing here is an amnesty that just shouldn't be done?

Sen. KYL: Well, in the abstract, I don't accept it. But as part of a bipartisan consensus that includes agreements on a variety of subjects, I'm willing to include it in a piece of legislation that I support. So, I think you have to ask the question that way, if the question is at the end of the day, with all of the different agreements that have been made here and things that are important to Republicans being in the bill, will we have a majority of Republicans willing to support this bipartisan consensus? I think the answer to that question is yes.

SIEGEL: You mentioned at the beginning what senators have been hearing from their constituents. You come from a state from Arizona, where Governor Napolitano has declared an emergency over immigration. What are you hearing from Arizonans about this bill?

Sen. KYL: Interestingly, over half of the people who have been calling my office are not from Arizona, but we're still getting a lot of calls from Arizona. And the primary point that they raise is that the law needs to be enforced. And why would we think a new law will be enforced when the old one isn't? What I'm hoping is that with the new powers and also the new funding that's made available under this bill, we will have a much better opportunity to enforce the law than we do now.

SIEGEL: So just to, sort of, chart the way forward here right now, as you understand it, now is the time for you, your Republican colleagues in the Senate - perhaps with some encouragement from the White House - to agree to limit the number of amendments that they will present on the floor. And for the majority leader, the Democrat Senator Reid, to admit that he'll bring it back for that discussion to then have the cloture vote after that.

Sen. KYL: Indeed. That's exactly the way forward. And if we can do that, the two or three days that we might spend now will mean nothing in the overall historical context. Twenty years from now, nobody will know how many days we took. But if we're successful in this, it could mean a great deal for our country.

SIEGEL: Well, Senator Kyl, thank you very much for talking with us.

Sen. KYL: You're very welcome.

SIEGEL: That's Senator John Kyl, Republican of Arizona, a chief sponsor of the compromise immigration bill.

Copyright © 2007 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.

Bush Says Immigration Bill Can Be Revived

President Bush and wife Laura review a Bulgarian honor guard during an official welcoming ceremony.

President Bush and wife Laura review a Bulgarian honor guard during an official welcoming ceremony in Sofia, June 11, 2007. Bush arrived on Sunday for his first visit to Bulgaria, the last stop on his European tour. Dimitar Dilkoff hide caption

toggle caption Dimitar Dilkoff

President Bush, visiting Bulgaria on Monday, predicted the stalled immigration bill would be revived and that his embattled attorney general would survive a Senate vote of no-confidence.

Warmly welcomed in both Bulgaria after arriving from Albania, the president spoke at a news conference with Bulgarian President Georgi Parvanov on the last stop of his eight-day trip in Europe. Bush said he would make a trip to Capitol Hill on Tuesday to personally lobby lawmakers on immigration.

"I believe we can get it done," Bush said of the immigration bill that has run into deep trouble on Capitol Hill. "I'll see you at the bill signing."

He dismissed a planned Senate vote against Attorney General Alberto Gonzales as purely political, and said it would have "no bearing" on Gonzales' fate. "I'll make the determination as to whether he's effective," Bush said.

The no-confidence vote follows months of investigations and the disclosure of internal Justice Department documents that contradicted Gonzales' initial assertions that the firing of federal prosecutors was not politically motivated or directly coordinated with the White House.

"They can have their votes of no-confidence but it's not going to make the determination about who serves in my government," Bush said.

Sofia is the president's last stop on his trip, which also took him to the Czech Republic, Poland, Germany, Italy and Albania.

On a sunny, cool morning, thousands of Bulgarians lined the cobblestoned main street through Nevsky Square as an honor guard played both countries' national anthems.

Bush and Parvanov walked past a line of Bulgarian troops wearing white coats trimmed in red, and navy pants tucked into high black boots. After watching troops goose-stepping to upbeat military music, Bush prayed before a wreath at an eternal flame that marks Bulgaria's tomb of the unknown soldier.

Afterward, Bush greeted Bulgarian soldiers who have served in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Bulgarian parliament recently extended the Iraq mission until March 2008, and last year, Bulgaria signed an agreement with Washington allowing U.S. troops to use Bulgarian military facilities.

Bush then worked the crowd, reaching in to shake hands as the locals beamed and cheered. In contrast to thousands of anti-Bush protests at earlier stops, Bush seemed to bask in the affectionate attention he received here and, even more enthusiastically, in Albania the day before.

"I call him George, and he calls me George," Bush joked about he and Parvanov share the same first name.

Bulgaria's welcome for Bush, however, had one notable gaffe. On the president's motorcade route, every other American flag was accidentally mounted upside down.

At a news conference with Parvanov, Bush's comments on immigration reflected his determination to pass a bill to give millions of unlawful immigrants a path to citizenship. It is a top priority for the remainder of his presidency, but a fragile bipartisan compromise on the issue has unraveled.

"Now, it's going to require leadership from the Democrat leaders in the Senate, and it's going to require me staying engaged and working with Republicans who want a bill," Bush said.

From The Associated Press



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

NPR thanks our sponsors

Become an NPR sponsor

Support comes from