Professor: Smaller Class Sizes Optimal For Kids
MADELEINE BRAND, host:
School has started, and a lot of students are having a hard time finding a seat. That's because state budget cuts across the country have meant teacher layoffs and larger class sizes. Take Los Angeles: Some high schools there have as many as 43 students in a class. So will these kids learn less? Someone who has studied how big is too big is Jeremy Finn. He's a professor of education at SUNY Buffalo.
Welcome to the program.
Dr. JEREMY FINN (Professor of Education, State University of New York): Thank you. Glad to be here.
BRAND: Well, 43 sounds like a lot. Is that too big?
Dr. FINN: Forty-three is too big, yes.
BRAND: Too big, period?
Dr. FINN: Too big, period. There's just a point at which teachers can't really get to know the individual students, can't teach the materials. Students split off into splinter groups and withdraw from the classroom interactions, and 43 is well into that range.
BRAND: So give us a rough ballpark for those kids from kindergarten through third grade, and then higher. What are optimal class sizes, and what are class sizes you can live with?
Dr. FINN: The research has shown definitively that classes of under 20 students, in kindergarten through third grade, have all kinds of advantages. They increase the - both the academic and social engagement of students, and they increase learning. That's especially true for students at risk - that is, minority students from low-income homes, and students for whom English is a second language. In small classes, students' behavior changes even more than does teacher behavior.
BRAND: How is student behavior different in small class sizes?
Dr. FINN: It's because every student is on what I would call the firing line. You can't hide in the back corner of the room. Students are better behaved. They pay more attention. They support each other in learning more, and their - definitely, their achievement scores go up. Furthermore, it's been shown that for children who were in small classes for three or four years, graduation from high school is more likely. Taking college entrance exams is more likely. So these early grades of small classes have long-lasting effects.
BRAND: And by early grades, you're talking kindergarten through third grade.
Dr. FINN: That's correct.
BRAND: I read an article recently in the New Yorker written by Malcolm Gladwell, and it talked a lot about teachers and class size, and I just want to read you a quote from him. He is skeptical that class size is as important as it's made out to be. He writes: You have to cut the average class almost in half to get the same boost that you'd get if you switched from an average teacher to a teacher in the 85th percentile. So in essence, he's saying that teacher competency is better and more important to student achievement than class size.
Dr. FINN: I've heard that argument many times before. There really aren't data that make that comparison directly. But I would argue, and as I have many times, that what you want is both a good teacher and a small class. Imagine what a good teacher could do with a small class.
BRAND: Are there any strategies, though, if parents are just faced with, you know, my kid is going to a high school with 43 kids in every class. What do I tell my son or daughter to do to get the best education possible in this situation?
Dr. FINN: I wish I had the answer to that because I would tell every parent to do that. There are things a school can do, though, to help students at risk, and one thing is to make the students feel welcome, warmly received and supported in their classes, even if the class is larger than you might like. As simple as the administrator standing at the front door of the school when kids arrive and greeting each kid and talking to them, something about their school day or their morning makes - there actually is a research study on this that's shown that that makes kids feel more warmly received.
BRAND: Jeremy Finn is a professor of education at SUNY Buffalo, and we've been talking about the effects of large class sizes.
Thank you very much.
Dr. FINN: You're quite welcome.