Behind Closed Doors: 'Colorism' in the Caribbean
MICHELLE MARTIN, host:
I'm Michelle Martin, and this is TELL ME MORE from NPR News.
Later on the program: He risked his life to bring stories from the frontline of the civil rights movement. But he's never told his own story until now. But first, in our segment Behind Closed Doors, we talked about difficult topics that aren't easy to discuss. Today, we're going talk about colorism. In this country, people of a certain age are familiar with this ditty: if you're white, you're all right. If you're brown, stick around. If you're black, stay back. African-Americans have been trying for years to erase this legacy of skin color hierarchy in the U.S., but in many countries it lives on.
Today we're going to talk about skin color in Latin America, were it's all the more ironic since in many of these countries the official line is there is no racism. Frances Robles covers the Dominican Republic, Cuba and Puerto Rico for the Miami Herald. She recently published an intriguing story as part of the paper's multipart series on Afro-Latinos, "Rising Voices." She took a particularly close look at the Dominican Republic. Frances Robles is in our member station WLRN in Miami. Thanks for being here.
Ms. FRANCES ROBLES (Reporter, Miami Herald): Thanks for having me.
MARTIN: As the Herald's person in the Caribbean and in Latin America, you spent a lot of time in communities where blacks are a majority. And yet you wrote in your June 16th story that being black is a source of shame for many people. Talk about that.
Ms. ROBLES: I would say it's a complete denial. I would say that the majority of the black people - particularly in the Dominican Republic - don't consider themselves black. And I'm talking - not people who look like Hispanic but could be considered black. I'm saying people who are in the United States would be an African-American like any one else. They just don't see that in themselves.
MARTIN: And why not?
Ms. ROBLES: The Dominican Republic is the only country in Latin America that got its freedom - not from Spain - but from Haiti, from a black country. In the 1800s, Haiti gets independence, and then a few years later it takes over the entire of island of Hispaniola. So for 22 years, the Dominicans were under the rule of the Haitians. And for many years after that, even after they were freed, you have presidents in the Dominican Republic who really instigated a sense that anything Haitian was bad, anything black was bad.
So that when you have an island now of, I don't know, something like 10,000,000 people who believed that blackness and Haitianness is bad, it's not even our fault, frankly. It's a historic, learned behavior.
MARTIN: So how those this play out? How does whole color case hierarchy play out?
Ms. ROBLES: That's really interesting. What you see in the Dominican Republic -for one thing what fascinated me - first of all, I should say that I'm not black. You meet black people who will talk bad about black people, and you're scratching your head, thinking wait a second. You look pretty black to me. And what you hear over and over again from the Dominicans is that they didn't find out that they where black until they went to the United States.
MARTIN: Well, what do you mean by that you talk bad about black people? They say - what do they say? That those blacks this, that those blacks that? Or what?
Ms. ROBLES: Exactly. Like, oh, look at those blacks. Or God, can you believe she married a guy that dark? Or I bet he's Haitian. There's a real pressure on woman to marry guys who are lighter so that they can have children - or even men, really - to have children who are lighter than them and not have children who are darker.
MARTIN: Well, you know where we should start? We should back up, because you start your story in the most obvious place, and it's just - it's almost like hiding in plain sight - the hair saloon. The hair salon. Many people are familiar with the whole kind of the cult of the Dominican hairdresser. And there's all this - I don't know if you get your hair done, but it's almost like legendary, like the Dominican hairdresser as being particularly skilled at straightening hair. And you're telling us that there's a legacy behind that.
Ms. ROBLES: Absolutely. There's a real obsession with hair texture. One thing that's really interesting about the Dominican Republic that I noticed - I don't have any statistics on this - but even the white people tend to have coarse hair, because there's - the roots with Africa are so prevalent. So everybody straightens their hair in the Dominican Republic. It's not a black thing per se.
So even, you know, Hispanic people who look like the traditional Hispanic person, most of them are straightening their hair. Wearing your hair curly or in braids - I was trying to think of an analogy. And I thought, you know what it would be like? It would be like in the United States with it - shaving your head. You know, that kind of - oh, wow, well, you're shaving your head. Why would you do that? And that's how they look at natural hair.
MARTIN: Did you find anybody sort of conscious of the idea that this is really a fundamental rejection of self, to be so obsessed with taking on characteristics of another ethnic group was really a denial of self?
Ms. ROBLES: There's a small clique I would even call them of intellectuals - of black intellectuals who are trying to raise that consciousness. So there's two women that I interviewed in the story who are feminist activists in the Dominican Republic. They're both light-skinned black women who wear their hair in natural state. And it's been - it's real painful struggle for them to be accepted that way.
One of the women that I interviewed, Ms. Fortuna(ph), she says she can't ride the bus. Because if she rides the bus, people are going to stick combs on her hair. But despite that, she's adamant. And she's going to do it. She's not going to sort of follow the rules of the European tenets of beauty. She's going to - this is my hair. My hair is beautiful. And maybe someday, people will accept it.
MARTIN: Wait. Frances, hold up. Wait. People stick combs on her hair on the bus? She really - going outside is really that big of a struggle, wearing her hair natural, that she draws that much attention?
Ms. ROBLES: I heard it a lot. I heard it from people saying, well oh, my God. Well, I would never wear my hair natural. People are going to say light a match to that nest, you know, and people will scream at them in the street, heckle them.
(Soundbite of laughter)
MARTIN: I'm just trying to take it in. What about…
Ms. ROBLES: It's really sad. It's really is.
MARTIN: What about for the men? I mean, are the men expected to straighten their hair or adhere to certain European norms?
Ms. ROBLES: No, the men are not expected to straighten their hair. I mean, they wear their hair short like any other black man would. What I heard from men was more stories about racism. Men told you more about not being able to get into nightclubs, you know, being treated bad at work, things of that nature.
MARTIN: That's the other question I was going to have, is okay, so maybe we can say okay, that's messed up. People should be able to walk outside without being accosted over their hair texture. But is there a real social impact or economic impact to being darker? Does - color does it have a real profound effect on your life?
Ms. ROBLES: A lot of the feedback that I got from people in the Dominican Republic is that the Dominican Republic is a very racially-mixed society. So they say well, how can any of this that you're saying be true if we are such a brown people? That means that it's all cool. You know, it's fine to be black.
Then you have black people say well, that's funny, because they had a very -one of the biggest stories in the press this year was about a black girl who was killed at a disco because she went to go to the disco - and apparently she was a regular there. But she went to bring a bunch of guys, a bunch of her friends, and they got into a fight with the bouncers because the bouncers didn't want to let them in.
And one thing led to another, and this girl was killed by the bouncers. And that opened a lot of wounds. That opened a lot of people saying hey, you know what? I'm tired of not being allowed into the clubs that I want to go to, of being told that tonight's a special private party.
But I will say that for every person which gave me a story like that, I had, you know, five others say no, no, no. You know, we're a very racially open and mixed society, so I'm not sure. I bet the truth is somewhere in the middle.
MARTIN: What kind of feedback did you get on this series and on the article that you wrote?
Ms. ROBLES: It was amazing. I have to tell you, I covered Cuba for the Miami Herald, and so the general consensus has always been that the most important issue to our readers is Cuba. This story, I got so many more e-mails and phone calls than I have ever gotten on a Cuba story. I mean, I probably got anywhere between 50 and 100 e-mails from readers all over the country, mostly women, thanking me and saying wow. I can't believe I'm reading this in the mainstream newspaper. Finally, someone telling my story. And along, of course, with that was quite a few hate mails.
MARTIN: Saying what?
Ms. ROBLES: Saying a couple of things. You had people who sort of proved my point by saying oh, but that's a lie. There are no black people in Dominican Republic. It's like, oh, okay. So you're denying that there's black people, which was kind of the crux of the story. And then you had people saying they felt offended. They felt that I had put the Dominican people down, that I made them look ignorant, which, of course, was not my intention. My intention was to explore a sensitive subject that I knew was going to be provocative, that I knew was going to maybe even hurt some people's feelings.
MARTIN: You just said that a lot of people, when they come to the U.S., it's when these issues start to sort of come to the fore. Did you get any interesting letters from people about that, about how that affected their thinking about these issues?
Ms. ROBLES: Well, the few people who are very sort of culturally aware and intellectually aware of this issue in the Dominican Republic, most of them have studied in the United States at some point in their lives. And they say that that process of transformation of awareness - of black awareness, mostly happened in the U.S. When someone said - I don't know whatever anyone would have said about being black - and the person went, me? Who? Who you talking about? Well, you. You're black. Well, I'm not black.
And then, you know, it would happen once, it would happen twice, and it would happen three times, and then they suddenly have to realize, oh, wait a second. I am black. In this country, I'm treated different. And so that opened a tremendous amount of awareness in people. And what was really fascinating to me is that several people that I talked to that went through that process were very light skinned. So then you had very dark-skinned Dominicans who don't consider themselves black, and then you had very light-skinned black Dominicans who now consider themselves black and embrace that.
MARTIN: That's interesting. Frances, finally, I think you mentioned that you're Puerto Rican. Why don't you describe your look and tell me how you were received as you were reporting the story in the Dominican Republic? How were you treated?
Ms. ROBLES: Well, it was interesting. I almost felt uncomfortable because I have really, really straight hair. You know, for 20 years, I spent - you know, I permed to make it curly, but anyway, I do now, accepted the straightness and I wear it straight. So I did feel a little bit of awkwardness in asking people about hair when I have this straight hair. And I have what's very classic term in the Dominican Republican and in Puerto Rico, I have what's called good hair. And so what does that mean? That means a curly hair is bad hair. And what I did with every single interview was I asked people - oh, because one of the things that you see in the Dominican Republic is that there's a lot of different labels for race. Nobody's black.
I mean, they're Indian or they're dark Indian or they're dirty Indian or they're - all these other words that don't make any sense. So I would ask people, okay, what am I? I have pretty brownish skin, but I have a very small, straight nose and I have pin straight hair. So what would I be? And I had people - oh, well, you're blonde. Oh, you're completely white. And I didn't have a single person tell me that I would be, you know, mixed or anything that would suggest brownness, because the way you define brownness in the Dominican Republic is not by your brown skin. It's by your hair and by your nose, and those make me white.
MARTIN: Wow. That's interesting. So you're passing?
(Soundbite of laughter)
Ms. ROBLES: Not by any fault of my own, but yes, I suppose so.
MARTIN: Very interesting story, Frances. Thanks so much for talking with us about it.
Ms. ROBLES: I really enjoyed our conversation.
MARTIN: Frances Robles is a foreign correspondent for The Miami Herald. She joined us from our member station, WLRN in Miami. Frances, thanks again.
Ms. ROBLES: Thank you.
NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio.