Two Brothers, Measured Against One Another By Fate

W: Tobey Maguire and Jake Gyllenhaal in 'Brothers'

Ties That Bind: Sam (Tobey Maguire), a Marine presumed lost in combat, returns home to find that his once-wayward brother (Jake Gyllenhaal) has found a new purpose — looking out for Sam's wife and children. Lorey Sebastian/Lionsgate hide caption

itoggle caption Lorey Sebastian/Lionsgate


  • Director: Jim Sheridan
  • Genre: Drama
  • Running Time: 110 minutes

Rated R: Language, disturbing violent content

With: Tobey Maguire, Jake Gyllenhaal, Natalie Portman and Sam Shepard

Watch Clips

Two brothers, separated by ... everything — that's Brothers, a new film from Jim Sheridan, centered on the war in Afghanistan and what it costs a family here at home.

Sam, played by Tobey Maguire, is a captain in the Marines, has a wife and kids; he's solid, stable and headed out for another tour of duty in Afghanistan. His brother Tommy, played by Jake Gyllenhaal, never finishes anything, drinks too much and is just getting out of prison on the day Sam ships out.

A few months later, tragedy strikes. Tommy goes joy riding in Sam's car and returns late at night to find Sam's wife, Grace, looking stricken: Sam's helicopter has gone down over water in enemy territory. Everyone is presumed lost.

And the family is lost, too: With nothing expected of him, Tommy's actually holding up best. Grace can barely drag herself out of bed, though she has to, for the kids.

But Sam's not lost, as it happens. I'm not spoiling anything here — from the moment Sam's copter goes down, Sheridan cuts between the grieving family and unfolding events in Afghanistan. He flashes between scenes of ne'er-do-well Tommy unexpectedly finding purpose as he helps Grace and the kids, and scenes of Sam being captured by the Taliban. From Tommy bonding with the family to Sam being tortured; first Tommy growing into a new maturity, then Sam wasting away. By the time Sam is rescued, he's damaged — so much so that his family can barely recognize him.

Brothers is an American remake of a Danish drama that was quite good, actually — very spare, without music or even artificial lighting coming between the audience and the characters. Sheridan has given the new version a jolt of star power — Maguire and Gyllenhaal scarily real as the titular brothers, Natalie Portman affecting as Grace. And he's also given it Hollywood polish, somehow without cheapening it. He takes his time establishing characters, works nuances rather than plot twists, and avoids histrionics, so that when emotional fireworks finally come, they're explosive.

In many ways, this Irish director is a perfect fit for the material. Family has always been central in his work, from My Left Foot to his story about his own parents, In America. Politics has been central too. And while that's rarer in Hollywood movies, it seems appropriate that this one notes the obvious: that the horrors soldiers experience in war don't always get left overseas when they come home.

Sheridan sticks to the family part of the equation, never leaning too hard on its social ramifications. With a troop surge announced just three days ago, he doesn't have to: You can't help peering at the barren, rocky landscapes in Brothers with widened eyes right now.



Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the Community rules and Terms of Use. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.