Obama Pitches Jobs Plan In Ohio

President Obama called on Congress Friday to enact a new job-creation bill that includes tax breaks for small business hiring, and for people who make their homes more energy efficient. The comments came in Ohio, which has been hard-hit by the economic crisis.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. For personal, noncommercial use only. See Terms of Use. For other uses, prior permission required.

MADELEINE BRAND, host:

From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. I'm Madeleine Brand.

The words are repeated multiple times today by President Obama: I won't stop fighting. He was on a trip to Ohio to talk about jobs and the economy. His trip capped off a nightmare week for the White House and for Democrats. The loss of one Senate seat from Massachusetts has thrown the president's top priorities into disarray. In a moment, we'll dissect the damage with our regular political commentators.

First, NPR's Don Gonyea reports on the president's visit to the town of Elyria.

DON GONYEA: Northeast Ohio has seen steel and other manufacturing jobs disappear and the president came here to answer those who say he's not done enough for working people in his first year in office.

President BARACK OBAMA: If you ask the average person, what was the Recovery Act, the stimulus package, they'd say, the bank bailout. So let me just be clear here: The Recovery Act was cutting taxes for 95 percent of working families 15 different tax cuts for working families, seven different tax cuts for small businesses so they can start up and grow and hire.

GONYEA: The president said he's not given up on overhauling health care. He cited his proposals this week to put tough new restrictions on banking practices, and noted that he's accused of interfering with banks.

Pres. OBAMA: No, I just want to have some rules in place so that when these guys make dumb decisions, you don't end up having to foot the bill.

GONYEA: The president took questions from the audience. One came from a woman who owns a truck driving school that's hurting.

Unidentified Woman: In the past few months, we've had a number of people on a daily basis coming into our school that's unemployed, but there are no training funds for truck driver training. And I want to know why that has changed.

GONYEA: The president said he couldn't specifically address her situation, though he said the stimulus package does contain retraining money. Then he used the moment to take on another common criticism of his administration.

Pres. OBAMA: You know, Obama is just trying to perpetrate big government. What big government exactly have we been trying to perpetrate here? We're trying to fund those guys who want to go to truck driving school. We want to make sure that they've got some money to get trained for a job in the private sector.

GONYEA: The president always tells his audiences he enjoys getting out of Washington. This week, he seemed genuinely thrilled to get back to the scenes and themes of his campaign days.

Don Gonyea, NPR News, the White House.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to NPR. This transcript is provided for personal, noncommercial use only, pursuant to our Terms of Use. Any other use requires NPR's prior permission. Visit our permissions page for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR's programming is the audio.

As Obama Talks Jobs, Stimulus Remains Divisive

If there is one thing that Democrats and Republicans can agree on after President Obama's first year in office, it's that the $787 billion economic stimulus package is a defining symbol of his nascent legacy.

Heard On 'All Things Considered'

But when it comes to what, exactly, that legacy is, the White House has been slowly losing the battle of perceptions.

Obama went to the hard-hit battleground state of Ohio on Friday with a retooled message on new steps his administration wants to take to spur job creation.

"I'm calling on Congress to pass a jobs bill to put more Americans to work — building off our Recovery Act — put more Americans back to work rebuilding roads and railways; provide tax breaks to small businesses for hiring people; offer families incentives to make their homes more energy efficient, saving them money while creating jobs," he said at a town hall event.

This new push comes even as the effectiveness of the stimulus, his signature initiative, is shaping up to be a central issue in the upcoming congressional elections.

Tangled Up In The Counting

Early on, President Obama said the stimulus would save or create as many as 4 million jobs by the end of 2010, but rising unemployment made this a tough sell.

Officials tried to keep a running count of stimulus-related jobs by asking government agencies and private recipients to report the number of jobs saved or created. The figures were posted, nearly in real time for a while, at Recovery.gov, a government Web site.

But the data became the butt of late-night TV jokes after a few listings claimed jobs in nonexistent congressional districts and ZIP codes. The errors were quickly corrected, but the political damage was done.

In December, the White House quietly decided to stop the running tally, and instead will post the numbers each quarter.

Data Tell A Confusing Story

Obama's supporters cite a raft of economists who say the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, passed last February, prevented even steeper job losses and helped to stave off a second Great Depression. The nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office said in November that the gross domestic product in the third quarter of 2009 was between 1.2 percent and 3.2 percentage points higher than it would have been without the stimulus.

But Republicans stepped in with an anti-big government message that attacked the program's spending on infrastructure, education and clean energy programs as a big budgetbuster. It was a huge hit with disgruntled GOP loyalists and a number of independents.

"We saw it resonating with the public over the spring," says Charles Franklin, a political scientist at the University of Wisconsin, Madison, who studies public opinion. "Previous polling had not shown that deficits were at the top of the public's agenda over the past 12 months."

Indeed, the GOP's successful messaging helped fuel the growth of the Tea Party movement, which this week helped Republican Scott Brown win a historically Democratic Senate seat in Massachusetts. That, of course, ended Democrats' Senate supermajority — and endangered the rest of Obama's agenda.

Obama's critics have been helped by the continuing flood of bad news on the jobs front. The unemployment rate, which stood at 7.7 percent in January when Obama took office, has shot up to 10 percent, even with the stimulus spending.

Most economists agree that the economy was even weaker at the beginning of 2009 than many experts, including those at the White House, had realized. But there is little agreement in the political world over what role the stimulus played.

"The problem with the stimulus is that while people have their own direct experiences with the economy, the impact of government action on the economy is almost always subtle and less than powerfully visible," Franklin says.

And, he says, Democrats didn't help matters: "I don't think Democrats did a very good job of selling what they did, either."

Partisan Discord

The irony is that at the beginning of the Obama administration, the economy appeared to be one issue where Democrats and Republicans could work together.

Republicans say that the White House and congressional Democrats made things worse by how they handled the negotiations over the stimulus. Republicans wanted to see a much larger emphasis on tax cuts instead of various spending programs. While Democrats agreed to boost some tax-cut provisions, the bill remained heavily focused on infrastructure, clean energy programs and a range of other "shovel ready" projects.

"It led conservatives to believe that the purpose of much of this spending was not stimulus, but to implement an agenda that Democrats on Capitol Hill had pursued for a long period of time," says Vin Weber, a Republican who was in the House of Representatives from 1981 to 1993 and now works as a strategist. "That's why you hear Republicans say this is just a liberal spending bill."

But many Democrats say that Republicans were simply looking for vulnerabilities in a presidency that enjoyed very high popularity in its early days.

'Bang For The Buck'

The White House, meanwhile, got bogged down trying to defend itself by estimating — and then trying to count — the number of jobs saved or created by the bill [sidebar]. Some supporters say this counting exercise ended up being a distraction from understanding the package's overall effects, because only about a third of the overall spending was dedicated to projects where jobs could even be counted directly.

"I'm a little concerned that the political imperative is to look for jobs you can identify and count," says Chad Stone, the director of federal fiscal policy for the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. "It tends to obscure the importance of things that don't produce countable jobs but produced lots of bang for the buck, like the extension of unemployment insurance."

The Recovery Act's effects have also been obscured by its own design. The spending was deliberately spread out over the course of at least two years to avoid another crash after the stimulus cash runs out. As of December 2009, only $263 billion of the original $787 billion has been spent, which means that the effects of the stimulus will continue to be felt through 2010.

Some Democrats are arguing that the economy remains fragile enough that even more stimulus measures are necessary. But that promises to be another tough political battle. Some Democratic lawmakers may be reluctant to back big new spending programs in light of their recent losses at the polls, particularly in Massachusetts.

"The stimulus remains a central element, but not the only element, in what will be a pretty ideological contest going into the fall," Weber says. "A serious argument about the size, scope and role of government is not a bad thing to have, and that's what we're going to have. The stimulus is going to get wrapped into that."

Franklin says that Democrats can only hope that the economy rebounds enough to start producing significant numbers of new jobs by the summer.

"If we do see GDP growth coming back and unemployment starting to come down, it might be easier for Democrats going into the fall campaign to claim some success," Franklin says.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.