NPR logo

Geithner Faces Congressional Ire On AIG

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript
Geithner Faces Congressional Ire On AIG

Geithner Faces Congressional Ire On AIG

Geithner Faces Congressional Ire On AIG

  • Download
  • <iframe src="" width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded audio player">
  • Transcript

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner faced questions Wednesday about the bailout of insurance giant AIG. Lawmakers pressed Geithner on why so much money intended for American International Group ended up instead with its trading partners.


From NPR News, this is ALL THINGS CONSIDERED. Im Madeleine Brand in California.


And in Washington, Im Robert Siegel.

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has been spending a lot of time testifying in front of angry members of Congress. Hes been quizzed about many aspects of the financial crisis. And today, he faced questions about the bailout of the insurance company, AIG. The federal government poured billions of dollars into AIG at the height of the financial crisis.

As NPRs Jim Zarroli reports, today, lawmakers pressed Geithner on concerns about transparency and about how the bailout money was used.

JIM ZARROLI: Members of Congress were scathing in their denunciation of the AIG bailout and in the way the bailout money was spent. Edolphus Towns, chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform, said the taxpayers propped up the hollow shell of AIG by stuffing it with money. And the rest of Wall Street came by and looted the corpse.

But Secretary Geithner held his ground. AIG had underwritten a massive number of derivatives contracts in virtually every corner of the global economy. And he said letting it to fall would have had terrible consequences.

Secretary TIMOTHY GEITHNER (Department of Treasury): The Federal Reserve faced a terrible choice to support AIG putting billions of dollars of taxpayer resource at risk or to let AIG fail and accept potentially catastrophic damage to the economy. We were not willing to accept such a catastrophe.

ZARROLI: Geithner headed the Federal Reserve Bank of New York at the time and played a pivotal role in federal efforts to contain the crisis. He said the Fed had allowed Lehman Brothers to go under, but AIG was different. It was an insurance company, and so the Feds lines of authority werent as clear.

Sec. GEITHNER: If the rules had been stable, everything had been fine, we werent on the edge of the worse recession in generations, then we could have been afforded to be completely indifferent to the fate of AIG or all those institutions.

ZARROLI: But the committees main focus was on what happened to the $180 billion that has been funneled to AIG, much of it went to pay off AIGs trading partners called counter parties. One congressman said the whole thing stinks to high haven. Geithner told Congressman Dennis Kucinich that forcing AIG to renege on the contracts would have pushed it into default.

Sec. GEITHNER: There was no way, financial, legal or otherwise, we could have imposed haircuts, selectively default on any of those institutions without the risk of downgrade and default. And that is the only reason...

Representative DENNIS KUCINICH (Democrat, Ohio): I just want to say, Mr. Secretary, since when does saving the system require the taxpayers to give a better deal than the market would normally deliver? Yet, you know, that is what the New York Fed did.

ZARROLI: The payments to counterparties have been especially controversial because they included foreign banks like Deutsche Bank and Societe Generale, but also the politically well-connected Goldman Sachs. Several of its alumni helped keep positions at the Fed and the Treasury Department including then Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson who also testified today. Paulson said he played no role in discussions over how much of Goldmans claims should be paid off.

Mr. HENRY PAULSON: My concern here was not about counterparty claims when we rescued AIG. My concern was about what was going to happen to the American economy and the American people.

ZARROLI: But it was Geithner who took the brunt of the committees criticism. He was asked repeatedly about the decision to conceal key details of the AIG bailout from the public. And like Paulson, he insisted that he had played no role in the talks. By then, he said, he had been appointed Treasury secretary and had withdrawn from day to day management at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

At times, the exchanges grew heated when one congressman told Geithner that he should never have been appointed Treasury secretary, he bristled with anger.

Sec. GEITHNER: I have worked in public service all my life. I have never been a politician. I have served my country as carefully and ably as I can. And it is a great privilege to me for me to work with this president to help repair the damage that was here when we took office.

ZARROLI: Geithner said AIG had grown so big by underwriting billions of dollars in contracts it didnt have collateral for. And he said that should never have been allowed to the happen. If Congress really wants to prevent a repeat of the AIG debacle, he said, it needs to think about passing financial market reforms. Geithner did acknowledge that he wondered often about whether regulators had made the right decision during the financial meltdown. But he also said he was ultimately proud of the decision to bailout AIG and that the meltdown would have been much graver if nothing had been done.

Jim Zarroli, NPR News, New York.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. Visit our website terms of use and permissions pages at for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced using a proprietary transcription process developed with NPR. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.

Geithner Comes Under Fire At AIG Bailout Hearing

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner told the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform on Wednesday that it would have been "catastrophic" for the U.S. economy if AIG had failed. Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images hide caption

toggle caption
Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner told the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform on Wednesday that it would have been "catastrophic" for the U.S. economy if AIG had failed.

Mandel Ngan/AFP/Getty Images

Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner testified Wednesday that he had "no role" in what some lawmakers say were efforts by the New York Federal Reserve to conceal deals that funneled billions of dollars meant to bail out American International Group to big banks exposed to the insurance giant.

"I had no role in making decisions regarding what to disclose about the specific financial terms," the Treasury chief said.

Geithner appeared before a House panel looking into whether he had any direct involvement in withholding details of $62 billion in AIG payments to counterparties such as Goldman Sachs Group — and why some banks got 100 cents on the dollar.

Although he was head of the New York Fed at the time, Geithner said he "withdrew from monetary policy decisions ... and day-to-day management" once then-President-elect Obama announced his intention to nominate him to be Treasury secretary on Nov. 24, 2008.

But some of the members of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform expressed skepticism. California Rep. Darrell Issa, the panel's top Republican, said many lawmakers on the committee "have a hard time believing Secretary Geithner entered into an absolute cone of silence."

One lawmaker after another lit into Geithner, venting rising public frustration over bank bailouts and bonuses as Wall Street firms recover from the recession but unemployment remains at 10 percent.

Rep. Stephen Lynch (D-MA) told Geithner: "It just stinks to the high heaven what happened here. The disclosure was not there at the proper time to tell the American people and tell this Congress what was going on."

Florida Republican John Mica, recalling the controversy at Geithner's confirmation hearings over his failure to pay some personal income taxes, said: "You gave lame excuses then, you are giving lame excuses now. Why shouldn't we ask for your resignation as secretary of the Treasury?"

"You have a right to your opinion," Geithner responded.

AIG received a bailout of $182 billion from the Troubled Asset Relief Program, a decision that Geithner and his predecessor, Henry Paulson, have repeatedly defended.

"The consequences of AIG failing at that time, in those circumstances, would have been catastrophic for our economy and for American families and businesses," Geithner testified Wednesday. He added: "I don't think there was a better alternative available."

Committee Chairman Edolphus Towns (D-NY) summed up what he said was the public's view of the bailout.

"In effect, the taxpayers were propping up the hollow shell of AIG by stuffing it with money, and the rest of Wall Street came by and looted the corpse," Towns said.

Although Geithner and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke have drawn the most heat for the government's bank rescue, the effort began under Paulson during the Bush administration.

Paulson followed Geithner at Wednesday's hearing, reiterating many of the same points about the vital need to bail out AIG. The nation's largest insurer "could not be effectively wound down," he said, much as he would have preferred to do so. Paulson also denied any involvement in decisions about payments from AIG to its business partners and other Wall Street firms.

Bernanke said he was "not directly involved in negotiations" either. In a written response to the committee, he said the deals were handled primarily by the staff of the New York Fed.

The Federal Reserve chief also said the financial condition of those businesses "was not a factor in the decision regarding the amount paid to the counterparties or whether concessions should be sought from them."

From NPR staff and wire reports