Chile Quake Far Stronger Than That Of Haiti

The earthquake that struck Chile Saturday morning unleashed 500 times as much energy as last month's disastrous earthquake in Haiti. More than 100 people have been reported dead after the temblor. NPR's Guy Raz and Richard Harris discuss the scientific mechanics of the quake.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. For personal, noncommercial use only. See Terms of Use. For other uses, prior permission required.

GUY RAZ, host:

RAZ: Joining me now in the studio is NPR's science correspondent Richard Harris.

Richard, you're just back from reporting on the earthquake in Haiti, give us a sense of how much stronger today's quake in Chile was compared to that one Haiti?

RICHARD HARRIS: Well, today's quake was an 8.8 versus a 7.0. And the numbers may not seem that different, but actually, in terms of energy it's enormous. That's about 500 times more energy released in this earthquake in Chile than compared with Haiti. However, that's only one measure. Obviously, the Haitian earthquake did so much damage and there're a couple of reasons for that, one of which is that the energy from that earthquake was very heavily concentrated and it was extremely close to Port-au-Prince - the capital city, so it was very, very close to structures. Many - millions of people were really within intense shaking zones.

This was a much more diffused earthquake. You talk about an epicenter, but you could - I was talking to a geologist who said you should really think of this as sort of like a sausage-shaped thing that ruptured down there. It was very broadly spread out. And so the energy, even though a tremendous amount of energy came out, there wasn't anyone that close by and obviously, there were still deaths and still destruction of property but nothing compared with Haiti where everyone was right on top of that fault and, in fact, where people weren't expecting an earthquake at all. And, of course, we've all heard the stories about how badly constructed Port-au-Prince was.

RAZ: Right. Port-au-Prince.

Mr. HARRIS: Yeah. And it's a very different story in Chile.

RAZ: This same region of Chile was the site of one of the most powerful - the most powerful actually, earthquake in recorded history - this is in 1960 - a 9.5. Explain, what is it about this part of the world that causes these massive quakes?

Mr. HARRIS: Well, what's going on here is essentially, continental drift or plate-tectonics, as the geologists prefer to call it. And basically, what's happening is you've got the Nazca plate, which is under the Pacific Ocean, trying to move East and what's East of it is already South America.

RAZ: Right.

Mr. HARRIS: So it's basically running into South America and it has no place to go but down, so what happens is the continental crust slides underneath, and it's actually the reason that the Andes Mountains exist because over a long period of time, the mountains get pushed up; the crust get's pushed up, so you're seeing the effects of that on a long-term basis. On a short-term basis, what this really means though is that as these stresses accumulate, every so often, the stresses get too much, and bang, something slips underground, large areas, as we saw today sometimes, and you get these tremendous earthquakes.

RAZ: Bigger than anywhere else.

Mr. HARRIS: Well, there are certainly quakes of about this magnitude that have happened. Indonesia wasn't quite this big but it was a very large earthquake. In Alaska - there have been other places where you get large, large earthquakes. But certainly, this is one of the most seismically active parts of the planet.

RAZ: Richard, let me ask you about the tsunami threat. I mean, because obviously, people living in coastal areas along the Pacific had been warned all across the Pacific to evacuate - to go to higher ground. These waves move incredibly fast over these vast distances. Explain why some earthquakes cause, you know, these waves and others don't.

HARRIS: Well, you need an earthquake of a certain magnitude to do this. You need, generally speaking, a really powerful earthquake, such as this one to generate a tsunami. And what's happening is you're basically jolting the seafloor with an earthquake like this. And you can also, by the way, accomplish the same thing with a giant underwater landslide. That's another way you can generate a tsunami. But these earthquake tsunamis are just - you need that super strong jolt. And once you've jolted it, it's just like, you know, dropping, you know, pushing yourself in the bathtub or something. You create a wave, and the wave just takes off and the energy just gets carried across the ocean.

We've been fortunate in this circumstance that basically, Chile is really far away from many of the places that are in danger. So there's been just ample time to warn people that there could be a potential of disaster.

I think what we're also seeing is the good news is that you're not necessarily going to have widespread destruction from this; it came and went through New Zealand without apparent affect, and so on. And so, you know, you don't really know. You can't measure very exactly how a tsunami wave is going to affect things. But at least, we knew that there was a potential.

RAZ: Richard, could an earthquake this big ever hit the U.S.?

HARRIS: Yes, as a matter of fact, it could. There's a very similar circumstances up in the Pacific Northwest around Washington State and Oregon. There have been earthquakes of this nature in the historical record; not that were measured by instruments. But this sort of thing can definitely happen. It has happened in the past and it will inevitably happen in the future, but not necessarily, you know, tomorrow, or a decade, or even a century from now.

RAZ: That's NPR's science correspondent Richard Harris here in the studio with me.

Richard, thanks so much.

HARRIS: My pleasure.

Copyright © 2010 NPR. All rights reserved. No quotes from the materials contained herein may be used in any media without attribution to NPR. This transcript is provided for personal, noncommercial use only, pursuant to our Terms of Use. Any other use requires NPR's prior permission. Visit our permissions page for further information.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by a contractor for NPR, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of NPR's programming is the audio.

  • Chilean troops and firefighters unload relief supplies Wednesday from a military helicopter in the coastal town of Dichato, which was heavily damaged by tsunami waves produced by Saturday's 8.8-magnitude earthquake.
    Hide caption
    Chilean troops and firefighters unload relief supplies Wednesday from a military helicopter in the coastal town of Dichato, which was heavily damaged by tsunami waves produced by Saturday's 8.8-magnitude earthquake.
    Ricardo Mazalan/AP
  • A policeman stands near medicine and other items donated Wednesday for earthquake victims.
    Hide caption
    A policeman stands near medicine and other items donated Wednesday for earthquake victims.
    Evaristo Sa/AFP/Getty Images
  • A woman washes her hands at a makeshift shelter for displaced people in the seaside town of Constitucion on Tuesday.
    Hide caption
    A woman washes her hands at a makeshift shelter for displaced people in the seaside town of Constitucion on Tuesday.
    Fernando Vergara/AP
  • Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is greeted by Chilean President Michelle Bachelet at the airport in the capital, Santiago, on Tuesday.
    Hide caption
    Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is greeted by Chilean President Michelle Bachelet at the airport in the capital, Santiago, on Tuesday.
    Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP
  • Chilean army armored personnel carriers drive along a bridge Tuesday in Concepcion, the country's second-largest city. Bachelet said Chile has dispatched 14,000 to devestated areas.
    Hide caption
    Chilean army armored personnel carriers drive along a bridge Tuesday in Concepcion, the country's second-largest city. Bachelet said Chile has dispatched 14,000 to devestated areas.
    Daniel Garcia/AFP/Getty Images
  • People wait for supplies in front of a supermarket in Concepcion.
    Hide caption
    People wait for supplies in front of a supermarket in Concepcion.
    Aliosha Marquez/AP
  • Police arrest a woman who was carrying goods out of a supermarket in Concepcion.
    Hide caption
    Police arrest a woman who was carrying goods out of a supermarket in Concepcion.
    Mario Quilodran/El Mercurio/AP
  • Rescue workers help an injured woman in Concepcion.
    Hide caption
    Rescue workers help an injured woman in Concepcion.
    Francesco Desgasperi/AFP/Getty Images
  • A man holds a child outside a quake-damaged building in Concepcion early on Saturday.
    Hide caption
    A man holds a child outside a quake-damaged building in Concepcion early on Saturday.
    AP
  • A boat rests next to a building Monday after it was washed ashore by the tsunami in Talcahuano.
    Hide caption
    A boat rests next to a building Monday after it was washed ashore by the tsunami in Talcahuano.
    Daniel Garcia/AFP/Getty Images
  • Throughout central Chile, travelers faced obstacles. Here, a collapsed bridge across the Claro river, about 112 miles south of Santiago.
    Hide caption
    Throughout central Chile, travelers faced obstacles. Here, a collapsed bridge across the Claro river, about 112 miles south of Santiago.
    Aliosha Marquez/AP
  • Smoke from a burning building fills the sky on the outskirts of Santiago.
    Hide caption
    Smoke from a burning building fills the sky on the outskirts of Santiago.
    Martin Bernetti/AFP/Getty Images
  • Firemen search for survivors in a destroyed building in Concepcion on Sunday.
    Hide caption
    Firemen search for survivors in a destroyed building in Concepcion on Sunday.
    Natacha Pisarenko/AP
  • People in Concepcion stand outside guarding their homes on Monday.
    Hide caption
    People in Concepcion stand outside guarding their homes on Monday.
    Natacha Pisarenko/AP
  • A man holds a torn and soiled Chilean flag on Sunday in a flooded area of Pelluhue, about 200 miles southwest of Santiago.
    Hide caption
    A man holds a torn and soiled Chilean flag on Sunday in a flooded area of Pelluhue, about 200 miles southwest of Santiago.
    Roberto Candia/AP
  • Bejamira Neira Zapata sits in the doorway of her house Monday after the massive earthquake struck the village of Penco. The tsunami engulfed the normally placid Penco and neighboring villages.
    Hide caption
    Bejamira Neira Zapata sits in the doorway of her house Monday after the massive earthquake struck the village of Penco. The tsunami engulfed the normally placid Penco and neighboring villages.
    Evaristo Sa/AFP/Getty Images
  • Concepcion, about 70 miles from the epicenter, suffered some of the worst damage.
    Hide caption
    Concepcion, about 70 miles from the epicenter, suffered some of the worst damage.
    AP
  • Following one of the largest earthquakes ever recorded, a woman stands in front of a destroyed home in Pelluhue.
    Hide caption
    Following one of the largest earthquakes ever recorded, a woman stands in front of a destroyed home in Pelluhue.
    Roberto Candia/AP

1 of 18

View slideshow i

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: