In Porn Industry, Many Balk At Condom Proposal

A technician edits a pornographic movie at the Vivid Entertainment studio in Los Angeles. i i

hide captionAs this photo shows, costumes are often a part of pornographic films. But production studios like Vivid Video, where this movie was being edited, are resisting another piece of wardrobe: condoms.

Gabriel Bouys/AFP/Getty Images
A technician edits a pornographic movie at the Vivid Entertainment studio in Los Angeles.

As this photo shows, costumes are often a part of pornographic films. But production studios like Vivid Video, where this movie was being edited, are resisting another piece of wardrobe: condoms.

Gabriel Bouys/AFP/Getty Images

Male porn stars have been known to don all sorts of interesting attire — but one thing you'll seldom see them wear is a condom. For years, a group called the AIDS Healthcare Foundation has been lobbying to make condom use mandatory.

The companies that make erotic films have long resisted that step, but now there are signs that change is coming.

The San Fernando Valley in Los Angeles is known as the epicenter of porn. That's where you'll find Vivid Video, the studio that produced titles such as All Star Big Butts, Debbie Does Dallas Again and the Better Bosom Bureau.

But Vivid has also made a lesser-known video, in which a young woman, fully clothed, looks into the camera and says, "Workers in the adult film industry face particular hazards because actors perform sex acts" in their line of work.

No, it's not the sexiest video ever, but it is required viewing for all Vivid employees. The video goes on to explain the studio's rules: Performers must be tested for HIV and other diseases every 30 days; sex toys will be disposed of after one use; and condoms will be made available to all performers.

But many performers, both male and female, find it physically uncomfortable to do their jobs using condoms, says Vivid CEO Steve Hirsch. "If girls choose to have condoms used in their scenes, then obviously we accommodate them," he says. "Some girls choose to, and most girls don't."

Hirsch adds that most performers seem content with the current protocol for STD testing through a local clinic. "They put the results online; we can log in with a password; we can see whose tests are current, whose tests aren't current," Hirsch says.

But according to AIDS Healthcare Foundation President Michael Weinstein, that's not enough. "We know that testing, while important, is not a substitute for condom use," he says.

Weinstein points out that performers can have sex in between the time they get tested and when they make a film. That can raise the risk for spread of disease. Since 2004, Weinstein says, nearly two dozen adult film performers in Southern California have tested positive for HIV.

"HIV isn't the only lifelong infection," he says. "You have herpes among many of the performers; women who are getting chlamydia, which is making them infertile. Or other diseases which may make them susceptible to cervical cancer."

Most porn producers agree that these health risks are serious, but they don't think condoms are the solution. Hirsch says Vivid Video tried it before, for nearly seven years. "When we became a mandatory-condom company, we saw sales drop by about 20 percent," he says.

Hirsch fears a condom mandate would wipe out the region's multibillion-dollar adult film industry. He says that California, where unemployment tops 12 percent, can't afford to lose more jobs.

"People will shoot in Europe; people will shoot in Mexico. People will go to other places to shoot," Hirsch says, "and you'll see an industry move out of this state."

The foundation counters that most gay adult films use condoms — and that sector of the industry seems to fare just fine. Weinstein says he'd even be able to make some accommodations for straight porn.

"Based on the data we have, the risk for oral sex is far lower than it is for vaginal and anal sex," he says. "And for that reason, I think regulations would make condoms for oral sex optional. I think that's a fair compromise."

Weinstein says it's obvious that Americans are watching porn — but that few people want to talk about the issue.

So far, the foundation has been unable to find a lawmaker willing to support legislation requiring condoms. It sued the L.A. County Health Department — but a judge dismissed the suit.

But last winter, the foundation filed a petition with the California Division of Occupational Safety and Health, or Cal/OSHA. The organization's board recently took the first step in requiring condom use: It voted in favor of setting up an advisory committee to study the issue.

Deborah Gold, a senior safety engineer with Cal/OSHA, says that it's her group's job to ensure that when people go to work, "their health and their safety has not been jeopardized. And that applies to lead poisoning every bit as much as it does HIV transmission."

Gold says a condom mandate would support Cal/OSHA's mission of safety — but that it could be hard to enforce. For example, porn film shoots can be hard to track down; many occur in private locations instead of at a big studio.

Those challenges are sure to come up in June, when Cal/OSHA's new advisory committee meets for the first time.

Comments

 

Please keep your community civil. All comments must follow the NPR.org Community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated prior to posting. NPR reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part, and to use the commenter's name and location, in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

Support comes from: